FAQ
logotyp Uniwersytetu Jagiellońskiego

2017 Następne

Data publikacji: 13.12.2017

Licencja: CC BY-NC-ND  ikona licencji

Redakcja

Redakcja zeszytu Dorota Czyżowska, Ewa Gurba

Zawartość numeru

Georg Lind

Psychologia Rozwojowa, Tom 22, Numer 3, 2017, s. 15 - 24

https://doi.org/10.4467/20843879PR.17.013.7573
For a century, developmental psychology, and psychology as a whole, has been caught in an objectivity-validity dilemma which divides the scientific community: when measuring psychological traits, researchers either strive for objectivity at the expense of validity in regard to the object of the measurement, or they strive for validity by using subjective information from participants and subjective methods of rating this information, thus lacking objectivity.
While the main problem of physical measurement is precision, the main problem of psychology is validity: does an instrument really measure what it should? On the one hand, psychologists like Sigmund Freud, Jean Piaget and Lawrence Kohlberg believed that valid inferences on psychological functioning can only be made through subjective methods like clinical interviews – at the expense of objectivity. On the other hand, scientists working in the tradition of Louis Leon Thurston and Karl Pearson wanted to turn psychology into an objective science by assessing psychological traits through behavioral data even if that meant deleting important psychological traits like moral orientations and moral competence from the scientific research agenda.
In this article I will show that this methodological dilemma can be (and has been) resolved on the basis of the ideas of Franciscus Cornelis Donders (1868), who, a long time ago, showed how we can study internal mental processes in an objective way, that is, without relying on the subjective experience of the participant and without subjective scoring. Interestingly, Donders used behavioral dilemmas in order to measure thinking.
It took us a long time to understand the significance of Donders’ invention and to apply it to psychological measurement. Our Moral Competence Test (MCT) is probably the first method of psychological measurement based on it. The MCT has helped us to test many hypotheses on moral orientations and moral competence objectively, which hitherto could be studied only with subjective methods. It has also made possible to design and evaluate new, effective methods of moral education.
Czytaj więcej Następne

Marian Olejnik

Psychologia Rozwojowa, Tom 22, Numer 3, 2017, s. 25 - 34

https://doi.org/10.4467/20843879PR.17.014.7574

The subject of this paper is the concept of development in life span psychology. The claim was put forward that the picture of human development presented by contemporary developmental psychology is unsatisfactory, and that the reason for this is the incompatibility of the methodological paradigm of natural sciences adopted by psychology with the specificity of the object of study of developmental psychology. An analysis of the nature of development within Bernard Kaplan’s genetic-dramatism perspective and John R. Searle’s theory of mind and social reality was presented. Also, its methodological implications were delineated, drawing attention to the attempt of both perspectives to coordinate the logic of cause and effect with the one of intention, purposes and aims in studying human development

Czytaj więcej Następne

Ewa Gurba, Dorota Czyżowska

Psychologia Rozwojowa, Tom 22, Numer 3, 2017, s. 37 - 55

https://doi.org/10.4467/20843879PR.17.015.7575
The article attempts to define the relationship between cognitive competences and identity styles in different periods of life: adolescence, early, middle and late adulthood. It also examines whether there are differences between the age groups in the dominant style of identity and in cognitive competences (formal and post-formal thinking).
The 495 participants: 192 adolescents, 131 young adults, 91 adults and 81 seniors were tested in a baseline study using the Test of Formal Thinking (Horneman, Longeot) and the Identity Styles Questionnaire: ISI-3 (Berzonsky). In an additional pilot study, 281 participants: 166 adolescents, 87 young adults and 28 seniors were tested by means of the “Everyday problems” method (Sebby, Papini).
The results show that early and middle adults in comparison with adolescents revealed a higher level of formal reasoning. In all age groups, the Informational Style of identity prevailed, followed by the Normative and Diffused styles, but with age the level of Commitment and the intensity of the Informational and Normative Style of identity changed.
Among adolescents, there was a negative correlation between TOF scores and Commitment and Normative Style, while a positive but low correlation was found between the level of formal thinking and the level of Commitment in the senior group.
The analysis of the results of the additional study in which the links between the identity styles and the level of post-formal reasoning were tested indicates that there is a stronger correlation compared to the measurement of the relationship between the identity styles and the level of formal thinking in each age group.
Czytaj więcej Następne

Józef Maciuszek, Paulina Materna

Psychologia Rozwojowa, Tom 22, Numer 3, 2017, s. 57 - 67

https://doi.org/10.4467/20843879PR.17.016.7576
Studies of the acquisition of negative meanings suggest that rejection (refusal) is the first semantic category of negation children are able to express. The second negative function that is typically attested in children’s gestures and speech refers to the expression of disappearance or nonexistence – this function of negation is the topic of our study. In this article an experiment is presented demonstrating that negation can have paradoxical effects, making children believe that a negated idea actually existed. In the experiment, the participants (five and six year old children) listened to a description of a house, in which some objects were mentioned, some were negated, and some were not mentioned at all. After one day, when questioned about the existence of all the objects, the children gave more false alarms in the case of the negated items that the ones not mentioned at all. The results are discussed in terms of the inhibition and retention hypothesis.
Czytaj więcej Następne

Małgorzata Lazar-Siekierka

Psychologia Rozwojowa, Tom 22, Numer 3, 2017, s. 69 - 86

https://doi.org/10.4467/20843879PR.17.017.7577
The education of children and youth is based on two non-controversial assumptions. The first is that it relies on communicating the cultural heritage of previous generations. The second is that it is essential to choose from the overall humanity achievements only that which is useful and effective for young people to deal with current challenges. Based on these assumptions, we now see two strategies for action in the field of education. The dominating one relies on the principle that the adult generation decides on the cultural achievements to be absorbed by young people. The second one involves assisting young people in using the achievements of humanity on their own responsibility. The dominant strategy limits the creative work of students and teachers to the field of methods and ways to achieve goals of education established outside of schools by the ideology prevailing in society. The alternative liberates educational creativity at school from this constraint and relieves it to the full extent with the creation of a school education program by teachers and students. The data from an empirical study confirm that the dominating thinking about education among teachers narrows it down to teaching methodology, and in thinking about the value of education what prevails over the autonomy of education is the dependence of the value of education, limited to the utility and benefits obtained from it. The data from the study also suggest that the understanding of educational creativity depends on the way in which education is valued. Based on these findings, realistic plans to emancipate education in the lives and development of individuals and societies can be created.
Czytaj więcej Następne

Krzysztof Dudek

Psychologia Rozwojowa, Tom 22, Numer 3, 2017, s. 87 - 103

https://doi.org/10.4467/20843879PR.17.018.7578

Cheating in school, which involves presentation of someone else’s work as one’s own in order to obtain a reward and avoid punishment by meeting the teacher’s expectations, seems to take place in heteronomous education, which is subordinated to a given curriculum. There is no reason for cheating in autonomous education, where the authorship of students and teachers in school is respected. Nevertheless, schools with their students and teachers do not enjoy a full autonomy and they never will. Autonomous education consists in implementing a curriculum derived from the students and teachers’ internal interpretation of educational good and giving every student an opportunity to enjoy it. The educational good has the nature of an ideal, which is not directly accessible, but which can be captured by the human mind only through inner interpretation, although never fully and never clearly enough. It is essential to introduce education in relation to the child’s development. Following Szuman (1959), Przetacznikowa (1963) and Wygotski (1971) – Niemczyński (2016a, 2017) presented a theory of the convergence of child’s development with education. It argues that the autonomous development of children and adolescents draws support from education as long as education protects it from heteronomous pressure. The more effective this protection is, the less probability there is of cheating in school and the more importance is awarded to the respect for the authorship of intellectual products at school. This could take place in a school managed in a way that respects the autonomy of education.

Czytaj więcej Następne