FAQ

Volume 6, Issue 4

2013 Next

Publication date: 27.05.2014

Description
Volume Editors: prof. dr hab. Dorota Malec, prof. dr hab. Wacław Uruszczak, dr Maciej Mikuła

Licence: None

Editorial team

Issue editor Wacław Uruszczak, Dorota Malec, Maciej Mikuła

Issue content

Michaela Knollová

Cracow Studies of Constitutional and Legal History, Volume 6, Issue 4, 2013, pp. 317 - 326

https://doi.org/10.4467/20844131KS.13.019.1694
The paper is focused on the area of Ancient Egyptian administration with an emphasis on the central person – the official. The clerical profession was considered very lucrative , the official, an educated person taking into account the illiteracy of most people, enjoyed great respect. The highest officer, being the vizier, was (in some cases) the most powerful person in the state. However, there were certain boundaries that were not supposed to be exceeded in the practice of official functions. Today we still call them the same way: “the principles of good governance”. These principles are contained in a number of documents, mostly in so-called learnings, as well as in some non-legal documents. These principles were not merely recommended behaviour patterns − those who breached them were severely punished. Upon closer examination of the principles governing official functions it becomes clear that despite the fact that many of them are centuries old they are still used today. This paper is based on religious, educational, and literary text but also on legal texts which are reactions against above mentioned situations when the principles were breached.
Read more Next

Grzegorz Blicharz

Cracow Studies of Constitutional and Legal History, Volume 6, Issue 4, 2013, pp. 327 - 340

https://doi.org/10.4467/20844131KS.13.020.1695

Sea loan or pecunia traiecticia belongs to the heritage of Roman legal thought. It seems to occupy a distinctive position in the conceptual framework of private law and few researchers are interested in investigating it. One of them is Z. Benincasa who has analyzed the topic in her general monography on risk in maritime journeys till the 2nd century AD. This article has been inspired by her book, however it is also the result of own studies on sea loan not only in the ancient Roman law but also in the medieval, modern and contemporary legal thought. Thanks to broad insight into the history of sea loan it was possible to take an approach which was only mentioned before. Namely that Roman sea loan provides the solution which today seems to be present in Project Finance. It was reasonable to start the broad comparison again from ancient Roman law. First of all, it has shown that sea loan served not only as a method of taking over the risk by a creditor, but it was also a kind of speculative investment and opportunity to gain a great profi t from maritime trade. At the same time it enabled a debtor to organize a risky journey. There were two kinds of sea loan. One was a loan given on the condition that a debtor would successfully reach the port of his destination. The other one was a loan with the same condition, but also with an added time limit, e.g. 200 days of navigation – so called dies incertus sensu stricto. Secondly, the profit of a creditor was strictly attached to the gains from maritime trade and depended on the success of a maritime journey. On the one hand, debtors’ personal liability was moved as far as possible, in order to satisfy creditors just from profit or items acquired during the trade expedition. On the other hand, the way to enter into the contract to attach high interests and finally to sue a debtor and his heirs was very flexible. Thirdly, emperors were interested in sea loan and provided in their constitutions balanced position of a creditor and a debtor. It can suggest that pecunia traiecticia was important for Roman economy, maybe in the same way that Project Finance is for our times. This work seeks to broaden previous studies on western legal tradition and Roman law and is an attempt to find out whether the Roman concept of sea loan is applicable also nowadays.

Read more Next

Miroslav Černý

Cracow Studies of Constitutional and Legal History, Volume 6, Issue 4, 2013, pp. 341 - 350

https://doi.org/10.4467/20844131KS.13.021.1696
Feudal Law, that was originally divided and fragmented like the entire medieval feudal world in which the law was created from disparate sources, gradually found its stable place alongside rediscovered Roman law and the newly organized canon law. At first, between 1154 and 1158, Obertus dall'Orto, a consul in Milan and expert of practical application of feudal law, wrote two letters to his son, Anselm, in which he summed up the elements of feudal law. This version is known as „Compilatio antiqua”. Around 1240 he was followed by Jacopo d’Ardizzone who wrote Summa feudorum. The last work called the Vulgate or Accursiana, that was divided into two books, was then incorporated in the most privileged place, right in the glossed Justinian legislation, behind the Novellae as the tenth amendment: Collatio. The subjects of these books included feudal relations between individual persons, a description of the investiture, different kinds of fiefs and the possibility of inheriting them. However, while Roman law of glossators was beginning its second life, feudal law represented rather the type of social relationships that (emptied from its original content) was coming to an end.
Read more Next

Vilém Knoll

Cracow Studies of Constitutional and Legal History, Volume 6, Issue 4, 2013, pp. 351 - 363

https://doi.org/10.4467/20844131KS.13.027.2194
For the emperors of the Hohenstaufen Egerland was a part of the Mid East complex of imperial possessions. Its local administration was organized by ministeriales. The documented provincial authorities were: provincial judge (iudex provincialis), bailiff (iudex civitatis), „mint master“ (magister monetae) a „forest master“ (forestarius). The highest representative of the provincial administration of Egerland in the time of Hohenstaufen provincial rulers was the provincial judge. The office of the provincial judge was documented for the first time in the sources of 1215. A person occupying that position was a representative of the monarch and exercised a wide range of powers (documented especially in earlier sources). The spectrum of information that can be retrieved from the preserved documents of Hohenstaufen period is determined by the fact that all of them were issued in favour of religious institutions. The preserved documents show that the provincial judge was influential mostly in the judicial area (provincial court or arbitration courts). He used to confirm written copies of judgments or declarations of settlement between opposing sides as well as church property transfers or acts granting a property as fief.
Read more Next

Laurent Waelkens

Cracow Studies of Constitutional and Legal History, Volume 6, Issue 4, 2013, pp. 365 - 386

https://doi.org/10.4467/20844131KS.13.022.1697
The article presents a synthetic approach to the history of Belgian commercial law. The author starts with the regulations of Roman law and leads us from the beginnings of civil law in the times of the Roman Republic, describing the role of aediles and praetors, to the times of the Roman Empire. A significant part is dedicated to the grain trade and searches – not always successfully – for a self-contained commercial law. A separate analysis of the Roman banking practices includes a discussion of cheques and accounting. The fall of the Western Roman Empire brought changes in trade in the Mediterranean region. The description of the Middle Ages includes a series of causal factors that contributed to the development of commercial law in Western Europe and that were related to the Roman tradition (for example the development of canon law and the Church itself as an institution, as well as the development of universities). It also contains the analysis of organisational elements of commercial law that mainly pertain to Italy, which at that time had a leading role. Attention is also devoted to the development of the notarial profession and the bill of exchange. In the 11th century, cities and, by consequence, autonomous and trade-oriented systems of city rights began to gain importance. This evolution which started on the Apennine Peninsula later also took place in the north of Europe, including in the German maritime cities, and eventually brought organisational changes and led to the establishment of the Hanseatic League. Legal regulations embraced, inter alia, the maritime trade. When the first annual fairs were organised,  improved safety and decreased toll rates furthered the development of towns situated on trade routes. Changes in the socioeconomic structure and the fall of Constantinople influenced the progressive standardisation of commercial law in different countries. The Greeks brought to the West not only their money and wealth but also their law. In the modern era, the first companies with legal personality appeared. The origins of contemporary Belgian commercial law are without a doubt connected with French law. The French rulers’ protectionist policies, which were characterised by a strong interference in laws regulating trade, were included in the ordinance of 1673, the main drafter of which was Savary, and the ordinance of 1681. Such actions resulted in traders developing their own judicial bodies. The next stage that was important for contemporary Belgian law was the issuing of the Napoleonic Code de Commerce of 1807. The French law was implemented in the parts of the Netherlands conquered by Napoleon. Commercial law courts after the French model were established and were staffed not by professional judges but by entrepreneurs. When the Belgians gained independence in 1830, one of their goals was to implement a new commercial code. In the end, however, they chose a different path – a comprehensive revision of the existing law that continued throughout the following decades. In that process Belgian commercial law was complemented with, among other things, private companies. The changes to the legal code in the 20th century resulted mainly from the developments in international law (e.g. the acceptance of conventions concerning promissory notes) as well as European law. In 1999 company law was transferred from the Code de Commerce to the Companies Code. The French commercial court system was adopted after the Belgian Independence, but during the last two hundred years the organisation of these courts was changed. Although some argue that there is a need for reform and for the removal of non-professional judges, the author of this paper is of the opinion that lay judges are efficient.
Read more Next

Dominik Galas

Cracow Studies of Constitutional and Legal History, Volume 6, Issue 4, 2013, pp. 387 - 404

https://doi.org/10.4467/20844131KS.13.023.1698

The beginning of sulphur ore mining in Swoszowice, having lasted for almost 500 years, goes back to the 15th century when the need for sulphur increased along with the firearm production development. In the Middle Ages alchemists called sulphur the ‘element of flammability’. After the invention of fi rearm sulphur gained big importance. It became an ingredient gunpowder. The real impulse for sulphur mining development in Swoszowice, a village near Krakow, was the publication of two documents: Village Land Act in Swoszowice and Diploma, that permitted mining in Swoszowice and gave a privilege to miners guild (co-partnership extracting sulphur ore) that enabled them to carry out extraction of sulphur in the whole country. It was given in 1415 by the Polish king,Władysław II Jagiełło. In the beginning, the miners guild consisted of well-known Cracow burghers: Michał Fayger, Piotr Słodownik, Mikołaj Sołtys from Stradom and a mineworker Krystian. Then it became a part of goods of Corpus Christi Monastery in Kazimierz and after the partitions of Poland it was a state-owned entity until 1887. Sulphur mining in Swoszowice made Jagiellonian dynasty powerful and influential. It lasted almost continually till 1886. At that time the pit in Swoszowice was the biggest in Europe. In the 18th century 250 workers worked there and 2,5 tones of sulphur were mined each year. In the late 19th century (1871–1876) the mine in Swoszowice covered 80–90 % of sulphur demand in Austro-Hungarian Monarchy. There were many reasons for the fall of the sulphur mine in Swoszowice such as: predatory economy, decrease in sulphur ore and increase of production costs, caused for example by the rise of wood prices (wood was needed to make protection systems of the shafts), groundwater floods in the shafts. Miners were also exposed to harmful impact of hydrogen sulfi de. Additionally, the mine business in Swoszowice was negatively infl uenced by ongoing competition, the renewal of sulphur production in Sicilia, cheaper sulphur production from pirytes in Hungary, markdown of tariffs on sulphur carriage as a consequence of the Trade Act between Austria and Italy lowering the duty on imported sulphur from Sicilia. The last attempts to restart the mine in Swoszowice were made during the World War I, in 1917. For that reason the Polish Sulphur Factory consortium was created. It conducted mining works in the area of bathing facilities. Two shafts were deepened: Elżbieta and Piotr. Sulphur ore, with 22–25% sulphur content, was discovered on a depth of 18 meters in the first one. The mining works were stopped though.

Read more Next

Michał Gałędek

Cracow Studies of Constitutional and Legal History, Volume 6, Issue 4, 2013, pp. 405 - 422

https://doi.org/10.4467/20844131KS.13.024.1699
The article presents basic issues that arose in the Duchy of Warsaw after the implementation of departmental division of tasks between different offices of central administration, including ministries and structures subject to them. The author investigates the origins of departmental division introduced in the Duchy of Warsaw by Napoleon, its primary shape, later modifications and the degree of its endurance after it fell. A great emphasis has been placed on the issue of general importance and position of the Ministry of the Interior functioning as a kind of a meta-ministry. In addition to the analysis of normative solutions the paper also looks at the actual determinants of the departmental division and at how it was influenced by Polish tradition. In this context the author investigates how normative solutions have been put into practice.
Read more Next

Kinga Császár

Cracow Studies of Constitutional and Legal History, Volume 6, Issue 4, 2013, pp. 423 - 427

https://doi.org/10.4467/20844131KS.13.025.1700
The article presents the issue of judicial decisions and court practices concerning criminal cases in Hungary in the years between 1879 and 1918. The first part contains a brief overview of Hungarian criminal law’s evolution in the 19th century with a strong emphasis on the milestone being the implementation of Csemegi’s Criminal Code of 1880. For example, whereas in the period before the codification court rulings often included penalties or repressive measures of Catholic origins, the new code modifi ed the Hungarian criminal law to a great extent. The studies of the records of the Royal County Court of Kaposvar have enabled the author to present a reader with the picture of a woman – offender, and a woman – vitim characteristic of Hungary at the end of the century. The article presents, inter alia, statistics related to the sex of an offender, and particularly problematic questions concerning cases of abortion, infanticide, rape or adultery. The analyzed judicial decisions show particular court practices characteristic of some cases, for example those of adulteresses, that lead to signifi cant deviation from the normative content of Csemegi’s criminal code.
Read more Next

Reviews

Krzysztof Fokt

Cracow Studies of Constitutional and Legal History, Volume 6, Issue 4, 2013, pp. 429 - 431

The note refers to the volume dedicated to the problems of the organization of municipal authorities in Silesia and the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth between the 13th and 18th century. It was edited in 2013 as one of the results of a wide-ranged project aiming at studying the history of offices in the towns of the above mentioned territories and Western Pomerania.
Read more Next

Іryna Vasylyk

Cracow Studies of Constitutional and Legal History, Volume 6, Issue 4, 2013, pp. 433 - 435

The book by Ivan Terljuk, that has been reviewed in this paper, analyzes chronologicaly the most important stages of the formation of socio-political constitution, as well as legal and judicial system of Ukraine, from their dawn until the beginning of the 21th century. The autor focuses especially on the problems of formation and development of the institutions of power and government, sources of law and the process of systematization of the rules of law. The most essential documents of Ukrainian law were also analyzed.
Read more Next