Montenegro’s Contentious Politics: How Clerical Protests brought Down the Government
cytuj
pobierz pliki
RIS BIB ENDNOTEChoose format
RIS BIB ENDNOTEMontenegro’s Contentious Politics: How Clerical Protests brought Down the Government
Publication date: 30.06.2023
Teoria Polityki, 2023, No. 7/2023, pp. 247 - 270
https://doi.org/10.4467/25440845TP.23.013.17526Authors
Montenegro’s Contentious Politics: How Clerical Protests brought Down the Government
Parliamentary elections in Montenegro in 2020 marked an end of Milo Đukanović’s ruling Democratic Party of Socialists, DPS. The defeat was an outcome of clerical protests led and organized by the Serbian Orthodox Church, SOC. This paper explores the contentious politics used by SOC to bring down the DPS-led government over the controversial Law on Freedom of Religions. SOC used its well-rooted repertoires of contention in nonviolent religious processions and channeled the discontent that was present among the people in Montenegro to its advantage. Montenegro’s democratic deficits and systemic corruption helped mobilize the people against Đukanović and DPS. First part contextualizes the evolution of relations between SOC and the government in the past thirty years, to determine the internal dynamics that would define religious re- volt in 2020. Second part looks specifically at religious processions traditionally used by SOC as a type of modular collective action for achieving its political aims. Finally, we dis- cuss how the strategy of non-violent protests of 2020, changed discourse and general mo- nopolization of anti-government sentiments led to a successful outcome at the elections. SOC not only accomplished its goal of terminating the Law, but continues to behave as a state above the state.
Aljović, A. (2020). “Strujić: I Bošnjaci su stvarali Crnu Goru” [Strujić: Bosniaks Also Contributed to the Formation of Montenegro]. Balkans.aljazeera.net. Available at: https://balkans.aljazeera.net/teme/2020/9/3/strujic-i-bosnjaci-su-stvarali-crnu-goru (accessed: 17.10.2022).
Bieber, F. (2013). “The Party System of Montenegro”. In: V. Stojarová, P. Emerson (eds.).
Party Politics in the Western Balkans. London–New York: Routledge.
Biserko, S. (ed.) (2007). Vukovarska tragedija. Beograd: Svedočanstva.
Brockett, C.D. (2005). Political Movements and Violence in Central America. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Brown, W. (2006). “American Nightmare: Neoliberalism, Neoconservatism, and De‑democratization”. Political Theory, 34(6), pp. 690–714.
CDM (2020). “Učesnici litija ne znaju šta piše u Zakonu, cilj im rušenje vlasti” [Protestors Do Not Know What the Law States]. Available at: https://www.cdm.me/politika/ucesn-ici-litija-ne-znaju-sta-pise-u-zakonu-cilj-im-rusenje-vlasti (accessed: 16.10.2022).
Csis (2020). “Russia’s Weaponization of Tradition: The Case of the Orthodox Church in Montenegro”. Available at: https://www.csis.org/blogs/post-soviet-post/russias-weaponization-tradition-case-orthodox-church-montenegro (accessed: 16.10.2022).
Dacrema, E., Benati, S. (2020). “The Mechanics of Contentious Politics: An Agent-based Modeling Approach”. The Journal of Mathematical Sociology, 44(3), pp. 163–198.
Deutche Welle (2020). “Montenegro’s New Government Faces Uphill Battle”. Available at: https://www.csis.org/blogs/post-soviet-post/russias-weaponization-tradition-case-orthodox-church-montenegro (accessed: 10.10.2022).
Direktno (2020). “Veličanstvena auto-litija u Nikšiću” [Magnificant Car-lity in Nikšić]. Available at: https://direktno.rs/vesti/drustvo-i-ekonomija/292416/velicanstvena-auto-litija-u-niksicu-video.html (accessed: 16.10.2022).
Djokić, D. (2011). “National Mobilisation in the 1930s: The Emergence of the ‘Serb Question’ in the Kingdom of Yugoslavia”. In: D. Djokic, J. Ker-Lindsay (eds.). New Perspectives on Yugoslavia: Key Issues and Controversies. London–New York: Routledge, pp. 62–81.
Dolenec, D. (2016). “Problemi demokratske transformacije na Bliskom istoku”. In: M. Kasapović (ed.). Bliski istok. Zagreb: Političke analize, pp. 375–396.
Dudouet, V. (2008). “Non-Violent Resistance in Power Asymmetries”. Available at: https://berghof-foundation.org/files/publications/dudouet_handbookII.pdf (accessed: 16.10.2022).
Duggan, L. (2003). The Twilight of Equality: Neoliberalism, Cultural Politics, and the Attack on Democracy. Boston: Beacon Press.
Đuranović, D., Zečević N. (2020). “Amfilohije pokušavao da sastavi i vladu i vrh parlamenta” [Amfilohije Tried to Form a Government and the Top of the Parliament). Available at: https://www.pobjeda.me/clanak/amfilohije-pokusavao-da-sastavi-i-vladu-i-vrh-parlamenta (accessed: 16.10.2022).
Dževerdanović Pejović, M. (2020). “Religious vs Secular Discourse and the Change of Political Power in Montenegro”. Journal of Balkan and Near Eastern Studies, 24(6), pp. 861–879.
Džuverović, N., Milošević, A. (2021). “‘Belgrade to Belgradians, Not Foreign Capitalists’: International Statebuilding, Contentious Politics, and New Forms of Political Representation in Serbia”. East European Politics and Societies, 35(1), pp. 190–209.
East, R., Potin, J. (1997). Revolution and Change in Central and Eastern Europe. London: Pinter Publishers Ltd.
Ec.europa (2022). “Key Findings of the 2022 Report on Montenegro”. Available at: https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/COUNTRY_22_6103 (accessed: 16.10.2022).
Emerson, P., Stojarova, V. (eds.) (2010). Party Politics in the Western Balkans. London– New York: Routledge.
Finkel, E., Brundy, Y.M. (2013). Coloured Revolutions and Authoritarian Reactions. London–New York: Routledge.
Flassbeck, H., Steinhardt, P. (2020). Failed Globalization; Inequality, Money, and the Renaissance of the State. Singapore: World Scientific Publishing.
Heckert, F.M. (2020). “Protests against the Law on Freedom of Religions Freedom in Montenegro. A Challenge to the ‘Đukanović-System?’”. Contemporary Southeastern Europe, 7(1), pp. 11–24.
Heka, L. (2022). “Crnogorsko nacionalno pitanje: Pravne posljedice odluka Podgoričke skupštine 1918. Godine”. Politička misao: časopis za politologiju, 59(1), pp. 24–48.
Hoffmann-Riem, W. (2014). “The Venice Commission of the Council of Europe – standards and impact”. European Journal of International Law, 25(2), pp. 579–597.
Huntington, S.P. (1993). The Third Wave: Democratization in the Late Twentieth Century. Norman, OK: University of Oklahoma Press.
Ifimes (2020). “2020. Parliamentary Elections in Montenegro: End of Milo Đukanović’s Era”. Available at: https://www.ifimes.org/en/researches/2020-parliamentary-elections-in-montenegro-end-of-milo-dukanovics-era/4642 (accessed: 16.10.2022).
Jovanović, S.L. (2014). “Svečovječna misija SPC” [Universally Human Mission of SOC]. Available at: https://www.akuzativ.com/teme/662-svecovjecanska-misija-spc (accessed: 16.10.2022).
Kathimerini (2021). “Σερβία: Σε «πολεμικό κλίμα» η ενθρόνιση του νέου Μητροπολίτη Μαυροβουνίου” [Serbia: The Enthronement of the New Metropolitan of Montenegro in the Warlike Climate]. Available at: https://www.kathimerini.gr/world/561487327/servia-se-polemiko-klima-i-enthronisi-toy-neoy-mitropoliti-mayrovoynioy (accessed: 16.10.2022).
Kennedy, R. (2014). “Fading Colours? A Synthetic Comparative Case Study of the Impact of ‘Colour Revolutions’”. Comparative Politics, 46(3), pp. 273–292.
Kissinger, H. (1957). A World Restored: Metternich, Castlereagh and the Problems of Peace 1812–22. Brattleboro: Echo Point Books & Media.
Komar, O., Novak, M. (2020). “Introduction: (De)democratisation in Slovenia and Montenegro: Comparing the Quality of Democracy”. Politics in Central Europe, 16(3), pp. 569–592.
Kovačević, A. (2020). “Srbi Iz Indijane Ispisali Isoriju Amerike: Prva litija u SAD, hiljadu i po ljudi klicalo: ‘Ne damo svetinje!’” [Serbian People in Indiana Went Down in History: First Lity in USA, a Thousand and a Half People Cheerd: “We Will Not Give Up the Temple!”]. Serbiantimes.info. Available at: https://serbiantimes.info/srbi-iz-indijane-ispisali-istoriju-amerike-prva-litija-u-sad-hiljadu-i-po-ljudi-klicalo-ne-damo-svetinje-videofoto-galerija (accessed: 17.10.2022).
Lalović, D. (2021). “Crnogorska država i njen crkveni pravoslavni čvor”. Matica crnogorska, 86, pp. 7–120.
Lalović, D., Ivezić A. (2021). Crnogorski izazovi. Zagreb: Disput.
Markovich, S.G. (2014). “Memories of Victimhood in Serbia and Croatia from the 1980s to the Disintegration of Yugoslavia”. In: A. El-Affendi (ed.). Genocidal Nightmares: Narratives of Insecurity and the Logic of Mass Atrocities. London: Bloomsbury Academic, pp. 70–95.
Markovina, D. (2020). “Nije vam posve jasno što se događa u Crnoj Gori? Upravo raskidaju sve veze sa srpskim nacionalizmom” [It Is Not Entirely Clear to You What Is Happening in Montenegro? They Are Cutting All Ties with Serbian Nationalism at This Moment). Available at: https://www.telegram.hr/politika-kriminal/nije-vamposve-jasno-sto-se-dogada-u-crnoj-gori-upravo-raskidaju-sve-veze-sa-srpskimnacionalizmom (accessed: 16.10.2022).
McAdam, D., Tarrow, S., Tilly, Ch. (2001). Dynamics of Contentions. New York: Cambridge University Press.
McVeigh, R., Sikkink, D. (2001). “God, Politics, and Protest: Religious Beliefs and the Legitimation of Contentious Tactics”. Social Forces, 79(4), pp. 1425–1458.
Miladinović, A. (2019). “Kako se menjao odnos srpske crkve i politike” [How Has the Relationship between SOC and Politics Changed Over Time]. Available at: https://www.bbc.com/serbian/lat/srbija-48271300 (accessed: 16.10.2022).
Milić, P. (2020). “MCP: Litije će biti mirne i nenasilne” [Protest Litiyás Will Be Peaceful and Nonviolent). Available at: https://www.glasamerike.net/a/crna-gora-crkva-liti-je-zakon/5458472.html (accessed: 16.10.2022).
Mportal (2022). “Oće da donesu oružje blizu Nikšića u selo i da se naoružaju, da krenu” [They Want to Bring Weapons Near Nikšić to Arm Themselves and Then Set Off]. Available at: https://mportal.me/drustvo/-oce-da-donesu-oruzje-blizu-niksica-u-selo-i-da-se-naoruzaju--da-krenu---audio (accessed: 16.10.2022).
N1info (2020). “Marković: Propali pregovori sa SPC-om” [Marković: The Negotiations with SOC Have Failed]. Available at: https://ba.n1info.com/vijesti/a449504-markovic-propali-pregovori-sa-spc-om (accessed: 17.10.2022).
Nedeljnik (2020). “Odavno čekam da izgovorim ovo: Berlinski zid je pao i u Crnoj Gori...” [I Was Waiting a Long Time for This, the Berlin Wall Finally Fell in Montenegro]. Available at: https://www.nedeljnik.rs/odavno-cekam-da-izgovorim-ovo-berlinski-zid-je-pao-i-u-crnoj-gori (accessed: 16.10.2022).
Nepstad, S.E. (2011). Nonviolent Revolutions: Civil Resistance in the Late 20th Century. Oxford University Press.
Nezavisne novine (2022). “Šta simboliše zastava koja obilježava litije u Crnoj Gori” [What the Flag of Protest Litiyás in Montenegro Symbolizes]. Available at: https://www.nezavisne.com/novosti/ex-yu/Sta-simbolise-zastava-koja-obiljezava-litije-u-Crnoj-Gori/585763 (accessed: 16.10.2022).
Novaković, D. (2011). “Položaj crkava i vjerskih zajednica i ostvarivanje vjerskih sloboda u ustavima Srbije”. Društvena istraživanja, 20(2), pp. 517–539.
Nwitimes (2020). “‘It’s Against the Identity of Our People’: Serbs March in Solidarity with Protesters in Montenegro”. Available at: https://www.nwitimes.com/news/local/lake/it-s-against-the-identity-of-our-people-serbs-march/article_5bb92091-42b3-5b6e-9e36-d685285ce02e.html?fbclid=IwAR1Jgswgv5VTMWfD_Nx9hEoZExfO-qhoENMcK9ywmeX4d9ajMKTNy5o94tCY (accessed: 3.01.2023).
Omelicheva, M.Y., Ahmed, R. (2018). “Religion and Politics: Examining the Impact of Faith on Political Participation”. Religion, State & Society, 46(1), pp. 4–25.
Pavlović, S. (1999). “The Podgorica Assembly in 1918: Notes on the Yugoslav Historiography (1919–1970) about the Unification of Montenegro and Serbia”. Canadian Slavonic Papers, 41(2), pp. 157–176.
Plattner, M. (2011). “The Global Context”. Journal of Democracy, 22(4), pp. 5–12. Pobjeda (2019). “DPS za obnovu CPC” [DPS Wants to Reestablish Montenegrin Orthodox Church]. Available at: https://www.pobjeda.me/clanak/dps-za-obnovu-cpc (accessed: 16.10.2022).
Popović, D. (2021). “Vreli dalmatinski srpanj 1989” [Hot Dalmatian July 1989]. Tragovi, 4(2), pp. 93–121.
Popović, P., Todorović, N. (2021). “Balkanske dileme: između velikodržavnog projekta i europskih integracija” [Balkan Dilemmas: Between the Project of the Great State and European Integration]. Političke analize: tromjesečnik za hrvatsku i međunarodnu politiku, 10(39), pp. 3–10.
Portal Analitika (2015). “Amfilohije: Crkva je u Crnoj Gori danas na raspeću” [The Church in Montenegro Is Crucified Right Now]. Available at: https://www.portalanalitika.me/clanak/189290--amfilohije-crkva-je-u-crnoj-gori-danas-na-raspecu (accessed: 16.10.2022).
Portal Analitika (2020). “Medijska haranga je bila artiljeriska priprema, litije su već ulazak pješadije” [The Media Harangue Was an Artillery Preparation, the Litiyás Already Symbolize the Entry of the Infantry]. Available at: https://www.portalanalitika.me/clanak/medijska-haranga-je-bila-artiljerijska-priprema-litije-su-vec-ulazak-pjesadije (accessed: 5.10.2022).
Pravno-informacioni-sistem (2006). “Službeni glasnik RS: 036/2006”. Available at: https:// www.pravno-informacioni-sistem.rs/SlGlasnikPortal/viewdoc?uuid=2d58099c-9663-4c77-89f9-e9f7856331e2 (accessed: 16.10.2022).
Radio Slobodna Evropa (2018). “Irinej se nije izvinio Crnoj Gori” [Irinej Did Not Apologized to Montenegro]. Available at: https://www.slobodnaevropa.org/a/irinej-crna-gora-ndh-povratakspc/29544677.html (accessed: 16.10.2022).
RTRS (2020). “Spektakularno u Crnoj Gori! Morska litija u Budvi, predvodi gradonačelnik Bato Carević” [Spectacle in Montenegro! Sea-lity in Budva Led by the Major Bato Carević]. Available at: https://lat.rtrs.tv/vijesti/vijest.php?id=397236 (accessed: 16.10.2022).
Saggau, E.B.H. (2019). “The Revival of the Serbian Orthodox Church in Montenegro from 1990”. Socioloska Luca, 13(1), pp. 9–25.
Sartori, A., Pranzl, J. (2018). “Politics Going Civil: Contentious (Party) Politics in Montenegro”. Comparative Southeast European Studies, 66(4), pp. 554–576.
Šćepanović, L. (2020). “Zašto je DPS izgubio 15.000 birača?” [Why DPS Lost 15.000 V-oters?]. Available at: https://www.slobodnaevropa.org/a/za%C5%A1to-je-dps-izgu-bio-15-000-bira%C4%8Da/30815322.html (accessed: 16.10.2022).
Šćepanović, L., Tomović, P. (2020). “Episkop SPC Joanikije i osam sveštenika pušteni na slobodu” [Bishop Joanikije and 8 SOC Priests Released from Jail]. Available at: https://www.slobodnaevropa.org/a/niksic-sud-pritvor-episkop-joanikije-svestenici-protesti/30613728.html (accessed: 16.10.2022).
Sharp, G. (1973). The Politics of Nonviolent Action, 3 Vols. Boston: Porter Sargent.
Shin, D.C. (1994). “On the Third Wave of Democratization: A Synthesis and Evaluation of Recent Theory and Research”. World Politics, 47(1), pp. 135–170.
Silber, L., Little, A. (1997). Yugoslavia: Death of a Nation. New York: Penguin Books.
Službeni list Crne Gore (2020). “Zakon o slobodi vjeroispovijesti ili uvjerenja i pravnom polozaju vjerskih zajednica”. Available at: https://wapi.gov.me/download/478d573b-742e-45ec-b351-9a3b21fed2c3?version=1.0 (accessed: 16.10.2022).
Sommer, H. (2000). “Bringing Nonviolence Back into the Study of Contentious Politics”. Politikon, 27(2), pp. 255–275.
Stepanova, E.A. (2008). Terrorism in Asymmetrical Conflict: Ideological and Structural Aspects, Vol. 23. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Stradner, I., Jovanović, M. (2020). “Montenegro Is the Latest Domino to Fall Toward Russia. Foreign Policy”. Available at: https://foreignpolicy.com/2020/09/17/montenegro-latest-domino-fall-russia-pro-west-europe-nato (accessed: 16.10.2022).
Tarrow, S. (2010). “Charles Tilly and the Practice of Contentious Politics: From France to England (Not Quite) Back Again”. Histoire@ Politique, 10(1), pp. 8–18.
Tass (2020). “Vucic Asked Russia to Protect Orthodox Church in Montenegro”. Available at: https://tass.com/world/1169165 (accessed: 10.10.2022).
Tilly, Ch. (1978). From Mobilization to Revolution. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley Pub. Tilly, Ch. (1993). European Revolutions, 1492–1992. Hoboken: Blackwell Pub.
Tilly, Ch. (1997). “Contentious Politics and Social Change”. African Studies, 56(1), pp. 51–65.
Tilly, Ch. (2006). Regimes and Repertoires. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Todorovic, N. (2020). Politika Rusije na Zapadnom Balkanu. Zagreb: Disput.
Tomanić, M. (2001). Srpska crkva u ratu i ratovi u njoj. Belgrade: Medijska knjižara krug.
Vijesti (2020). “Litije širom Crne Gore: Okupilo se na hiljade građana” [Litiyás Across Montenegro: Thousands of People Gathered]. Available at: https://www.vijesti.me/vijesti/drustvo/417872/vise-hiljada-gradana-na-litiji-u-beranama (accessed: 17.10.2022).
Vričko, J. (2020). “Crnogorski balvani blagoslovljeni su u Beogradu” [Montenegrin Logs Are Blessed in Belgrade]. Available at: https://www.nedjelja.ba/hr/iz-zivota/razmisljanje/crnogorski-balvani-blagoslovljeni-su-u-beogradu/13773 (accessed: 16.10.2022).
Vukadinović, Đ. (2020). “Crnogorske litije i čudo” [Montenegrin Protest Litiyás and a Miracle]. Politika Online. Available at: https://www.politika.rs/sr/clanak/446238/Crnogorske-litije-i-cudo (accessed: 16.10.2022).
Vukićević, S. (2021). “Litije – antibirokratska i antidogmatska izvidnica” [Litiyás – An Anti-bureaucratic and Anti-dogmatic Reconnaissance]. Available at: https://okfcetinje.org/slobodan-vukicevic-litije-antibirokratska-i-antidogmatska-izvidnica (accessed: 16.10.2022).
Wald, K.D., Silverman, A.L., Fridy, K.S. (2005). “Making Sense of Religion in Political Life”. Annual Review of Political Science, 8(1), pp. 121–143.
Young, G., Leszczyński, M. (2021). “Charles Tilly’s Revolutionary Process Theory”. PB Press Books. Revolutions: Theorists, Theory and Practice. Available at: https://pressbooks.buffscreate.net/revolution/chapter/charles-tillys-revolutionary-process-theory/ (accessed: 17.10.2022).
Information: Teoria Polityki, 2023, No. 7/2023, pp. 247 - 270
Article type: Original article
Titles:
Montenegro’s Contentious Politics: How Clerical Protests brought Down the Government
Montenegro’s Contentious Politics: How Clerical Protests brought Down the Government
University of Zagreb, Trg maršala Tita 14, HR-10000 Zagreb Croatia
University of Zagreb, Trg maršala Tita 14, HR-10000 Zagreb Croatia
Published at: 30.06.2023
Article status: Open
Licence: CC BY
Percentage share of authors:
Article corrections:
-Publication languages:
EnglishView count: 736
Number of downloads: 402