FAQ

O dominującym charakterze zabudowy – polemika z tezą glosy K. Rokickiej-Murszewskiej do wyroku NSA z 14 lutego 2019 r. (II OSK 626/17)

Publication date: 12.2021

Attorney-at-Law, 2021, 3 (28), pp. 182-190

https://doi.org/10.4467/23921943RP.21.029.15121

Authors

Iwo Fisz
All publications →

Titles

O dominującym charakterze zabudowy – polemika z tezą glosy K. Rokickiej-Murszewskiej do wyroku NSA z 14 lutego 2019 r. (II OSK 626/17)

Abstract

The author engages in a polemic with the views expressed in the judgement of the Polish Supreme Administrative Court (NSA) of February 14, 2019 (case file no. II OSK 626/17) and the approving gloss by K. Rokicka-Murszewska to this judgement. The subject of the polemics is both the validity of the NSA’s view as to the need to establish the dominant function of the construction on the given territory and the practical capabilities of establishing such a function as part of the analysis of the function and characteristics of the construction and land development carried out over the course of the proceedings for the issuance of land development conditions. In the opinion of the author, the NSA’s view may be effectively used by the municipal authorities to implement their urban planning policy in a manner not compliant with the binding provisions of law.

References

Download references
Orzeczenia

Wyrok WSA w Lublinie z 2 marca 2021 r., II SA/Lu 661/20 (nieprawomocny; CBOSA).

Wyrok WSA w Lublinie z 2 marca 2021 r., II SA/Lu 662/20 (nieprawomocny; CBOSA).

Wyrok WSA w Lublinie z 2 marca 2021 r., II SA/Lu 663/20 (nieprawomocny; CBOSA).

Wyrok WSA w Łodzi z 26 maja 2021 r., II SA/Łd 768/20 (nieprawomocny; CBOSA).

Wyrok NSA z 17 kwietnia 2018 r., II OSK 2627/17, CBOSA.

Wyrok WSA w Gdańsku z 5 maja 2021 r., II SA/Gd 41/21, CBOSA

Information

Information: Attorney-at-Law, 2021, 3 (28), pp. 182-190

Article type: Original article

Titles:

Polish:

O dominującym charakterze zabudowy – polemika z tezą glosy K. Rokickiej-Murszewskiej do wyroku NSA z 14 lutego 2019 r. (II OSK 626/17)

English:

On the dominant character of development –  the polemic towards the gloss by K. Rokicka-Murszewska to the judgement of the Polish Supreme Administrative Court of February 14, 2019 (case file no. II OSK 626/17)

Published at: 12.2021

Article status: Open

Licence: None

Percentage share of authors:

Iwo Fisz (Author) - 100%

Article corrections:

-

Publication languages:

Polish