FAQ

Prace Etnograficzne

Belgrade street drama of the 1990s: (Re)constructing history and memory

Data publikacji: 2018

Prace Etnograficzne, 2018, Tom 46, Numer 2, s. 27 - 48

https://doi.org/10.4467/22999558.PE.18.015.10088

Autorzy

Miroslava Lukić-Krstanović
Serbian Academy of Sciences and Arts
Wszystkie publikacje autora →

Abstrakt

This paper recapitulates two influential JRAI articles to discuss comparison in anthropology. Charles Lindholm’s 1995 article criticized the then new, now well-established, trend in Middle East ethnography for its radical emphasis on particularism and lack of theorization, driven by fears of de-humanizing subjects. In turn, Joel Robbins’s 2013 article proposed an “anthropology of the good” as a substitute to the particularism of the anthropology of the “suffering subject”. This would reinstate the notion of cultural diversity and its comparative vocation as touchstones of contemporary anthropology. Connecting these articles is a discussion of Middle East and Palestine ethnography’s major shift in the 1970’s to an anthropology of suffering reflected in anthropology at large. The 

conclusion is that suffering, just as comparison, must be qualified. Thus, qualified comparison must be the foundation to anthropological critiques of Western reason as much as it is to classical cultural critique.

Bibliografia

Azaryahu M.

1999 Politički simboli u svakidašnjici: polisistemski pristup istraživanju, Etnološka “tribina”, no22/29, 255–267.

Asman A.

2011 Duga senka prošlosti / Der Lange Schatten der vergangnheit, Beograd.

Bojm S.

2005 Budućnost nostalgije / The Future of Nostalgia, Beograd.

Butler J.

2011 Bodies in Alliance and the Politics of the Street,http://eipcp.net/transversal/1011/butler/en, (access: 16.07.2018).

Čolović I.

1994 Pucanje od zdravlja / Shooting of Health, Beograd.

1997 Politika simbola, Ogledi o političkoj antropologiji, Beograd.

Čolović I., Mimica A. (ed.)

1992 Druga Srbija, Beograd.

Čupić Č.

1998 Duh vedrine, Kultura protesta – protest kulture, Građanski i studentski protest 96/97, Beograd.

Dragićević-Šešić M.

1992 Druga Srbija, in: I. Čolović, A. Mimica (eds.), Beogradski krug, Centar za antiratnu akciju, Beograd.

1997  Ulica kao politički prostor. Prostor karnevalizacije,“Sociologija” no 39(1), p. 55–65.

ĐorđevićI.

2015 Antropolog među navijačima / An anthropologist among fans, Beograd.

Đorđević J.

1998  Simbolika protesta, in: Duh vedrine, kultura protesta, ed. Č. Čupić, Beograd,
p. 21–32.

 Gibb R.

2001 Toward and Anthropology of Social Movements, “Journal des anthropologues”, no 8586, http://journals.openedition.org/jda/2904 (access: 23 April 2018).

Giddens A.

1999 Risk and Responsibility, “The Moder Law Review”, vol. 62, no. 1, p. 1–10,

https://courses.washington.edu/sales09/Handouts/Giddens_Risk_Responsibility.pdf   (access: 24.04. 2018).

Gorunović G., Erdei. I.

1997  O studentima i drugim demonima, Zbornik radova studenatat etnologije i antropologije Filozofskog fakulteta u Beogradu, Beograd.

Ilić V.

2001  Između Evrope i retradicionalizacije – Narodni pokret Otpor’’, vol. 1, Helsinški odbor za ljudska prava u Srbiji, Beograd.

Jansen S.

2005 Antinacionalizam, Beograd.

Jovičević A.

2000 Teatar, parateatar i karneval: Građanski i studentski protesti u Srbiji 1996–1997, in: Urbani spektakli, ed. M. Dragičević-Šešić, Beograd, p. 147–160.

Kuljić T.

2006 Kultura sjećanja, Beograd

Lukić Krstanović M.

1995 Masovna politička okupljanja. Priče iz života, “Glasnik Etnografskogo institute SANU” no XLIV, p. 222–234.

2010 Spektakli XX veka. Muzika i moć, Beograd.

Milić A., Čičkarić L.

1998 Generacija u protesta, Sociološki portret učesnika Studentskogo protesta 96/97 na Beogradskom univerzitetu, Beograd.

Milosavljević O.

2007 “Dobri” nacionalizam, https://pescanik.net/dobri-nacionalizam/ (access: 6.07.2018).

Moskovisi S.

1997 Doba gomile / Lage des Foules,Beograd.

Mumford L.

2010 Kultura gradova, Novi Sad.

Naumović S.

1998 Romanticists or Double Insiders? An Essay on the Origins of Ideologised Discourses in Balkan Ethnology, “Ethnologia Balkanica”, no. 2, p. 101–120. 

Prelić M.

1995 Revival of the Serbian National Myth (The Myth of the Battle of Kosovo) in the Contemporary Public Speech in Serbia, “Etnologia Balkanica”, p. 191–206.

Prošić-Dvornić M.

1993 “Enough” – Student Protest ’92. The Youth of Belgrade in Quest of “Another Serbia”, “Anthropology of East Europe Review”, no 11 (1–2), p. 129–130.

Radović S.

2014Beogradski Odonimi/Belgrade Odonyms, Beograd.

Sztandara M.

2017 Sporna susedstva i praksa vraćanja grada natrag svojim stanovnicima: slučaj kvarta Savamala u Beogradu, “Glasnik Etnografskogo instituta SANU”, no LXV (2), p. 485–490.

2018 To be Unworthy of National Stage. Women’s Disobedience as Performative Practices, “Glasnik Etnografskogo instituta SANU” no  2, p. 347–366.

Tomić Đ.

2009 Ulične studije – Odsek Protesti! Studentski protesti tokom’’ ere Milošević’’, in: Novi društveni pokreti u Jugoslaviji od 1968 do danas, (eds.) Đ. Tomić, P. Atanacković, Novi Sad, p. 184–231.

Turner V.

1974  Dramas, Fields and Metaphors, Symbolic Action in Human Society,London.

Verderi K.

2005 Šta je bio socijalizam išta dolazi posle njega/ What was Socialism and What Comes Next?, Beograd.

Vujović S.

2000 Beograd kao pokretni praznik, in:Urbani spektakl, ed. M. Dragičević-Šešić, I. Šentevska, Beograd, p. 130–146.

Žirarde R.

2000 Politički mitovi i mitologije,Beograd.

Press data

Danas,https://www.danas.rs/drustvo/studenti-su-ozbiljno-uzdrmali-rezim-slobodana-milosevica/ (access: 12.07.2018).

www.kaleidoskop-media.com/klik-na-svetlost/prote (access: 6. 07. 2018).

Informacje

Informacje: Prace Etnograficzne, 2018, s. 27 - 48

Typ artykułu: Oryginalny artykuł naukowy

Tytuły:

Angielski:

Belgrade street drama of the 1990s: (Re)constructing history and memory

Autorzy

Serbian Academy of Sciences and Arts

Publikacja: 2018

Status artykułu: Otwarte __T_UNLOCK

Licencja: CC BY-NC-ND  ikona licencji

Udział procentowy autorów:

Miroslava Lukić-Krstanović (Autor) - 100%

Korekty artykułu:

-

Języki publikacji:

Angielski

Liczba wyświetleń: 1159

Liczba pobrań: 924