Medical Malpractice Liability in the United States of America in the Light of the 19th Century Origins of the American Legal System

Marcin Michalak

Medical Malpractice Liability in the United States of America in the Light of the 19th Century Origins of the American Legal System

Data publikacji: 03.09.2021

Krakowskie Studia z Historii Państwa i Prawa, Tom 14 (2021), Tom 14, Zeszyt 3, s. 287 - 305

https://doi.org/10.4467/20844131KS.21.023.14088

Autorzy

Pobierz pełny tekst

PDF

drukuj

Tytuły

Medical Malpractice Liability in the United States of America in the Light of the 19th Century Origins of the American Legal System

Abstrakt

The American model of medical malpractice liability has been the subject of lively public and scientific debate for years. This system is characterized by a large number of lawsuits against doctors and very high damages awarded in such cases. In turn, these phenomena contribute to the occurrence of so-called medical malpractice crisis. It seems that an important place in the proper understanding of the American model of physicians’ liability for medical malpractice may be the historical analysis of legal norms regulating this matter. The text claims that the modern specificity of the system of liability for medical malpractice is closely related to the development of American law in its formative period in the nineteenth century. The article indicates four features of the legal system developed at that time, which today are identified as responsible for a large number of lawsuits and high compensation in malpractice trials. These include, in particular, linking medical liability to the tort law regime, domination of the civil law dimension of liability for medical errors, the role of the jury in lawsuits for medical malpractice, and the method of remuneration of attorneys in such cases.

* The article was prepared thanks to the funds that the author received to prepare a doctoral dissertation on the development of medical malpractice liability in the United States of America from the National Science Center as part of financing a doctoral scholarship on the basis of decision number DEC-2015/16/T/HS5/00432.

Słowa kluczowe

medical malpractice, medical law, American law, physicians’ liability

Bibliografia

Pobierz bibliografię

Table of cases

Poor v. Greene, 5 Binn. 554, (Pa. 1813).

Commonwealth v. Thompson, 6 Mass. 134 (1809).

Rice v. State, 8 Mo. 561 (1844).

McCandless v. McWha, 22 Pa. 261 (1853).

Major’s Executor v. Gibson, 1 Pat. & H. 48 (1855).

Primary sources

Blackstone, William. Commentaries on the laws of England: In four books. Philadelphia: Printed for the subscribers. By Robert Bell, at the late Union Library, in Third-Street, 1771–2.

Elwell, John J. A medico-legal treatise on malpractice and medical evidence: Comprising the elements of medical jurisprudence. New York: J.S. Voorhies, 1860.

“Legal liabilities of Physicians and Surgeons”. Boston Medical and Surgical Journal 5 (1866): 353–6.

March, Alden. “Case of Alleged Mal-Practice in Surgery”. Boston Medical and Surgical Journal 37 (1847): 9–14.

Sanger, Eugen F. “Medical Notes”. The Boston Medical and Surgical Journal 99 (1878), 91.

Sanger, Eugen F. “Report of the Committee on Suits for Malpractice”. Transactions of the Main Medical Association 6 (1877–1879): 360–82.

“Surgical Malpractice”. Boston Medical and Surgical Journal 36 (1847): 283–4.

Smith, Stephen. “Review of John Elwell’s Treatise on Malpractice”. American Journal of Medical Science 40 (1860): 154.

Stille, Alfred. “Medical Instructions in the United States: An address delivered to the students of the Philadelphia Association for Medical Instruction, at the close of a Session of 1846”. The Medical Examiner, and Record of Medical Science 3 (1847): 26–32.

“The suit against professor Gross”. Medical Times and Register 1 (1871): 280–1.

Wood, William W. “Thoughts on Suits for Malpractice, Suggested by Certain Judicial Proceedings in Erie County, Pennsylvania”. American Journal of Medical Science 18 (1849): 395–400.

Secondary sources

Ames, James B. “The History of Assumpsit. I. Express Assumpsit”. Harvard Law Review 2, no. 1 (1888): 1–19.

Anderson, Richard E. “Effective Legal Reform and the Malpractice Insurance Crisis”. Yale Journal of Health Policy, Law, and Ethics 5, no. 1 (2005): 343–55.

Annas, George J. “Doctors, patients, and lawyers – two centuries of health law”. The New England Journal of Medicine 367, no. 5 (2012): 445–50.

Baker, John H. An introduction to English legal history. New York: Oxford University Press, 2007.

Baker, Tom. The Medical malpractice myth. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2005.

Bal, Sonny. “An Introduction to Medical Malpractice in the United States”. Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research 467, no. 2 (2009): 339–47.

Burns, Chester R. “Malpractice Suits in American Medicine Before the Civil War”. Bulletin of the History of Medicine 43 (1969): 41–56.

Burns, Chester R. “Medical Malpractice Law and the Public’s Health in the United States During the Nineteenth Century”. Historie des Sciences Medicales 17, special number/1 (1982): 75–7.

Costante, Patricia A. and Puro, Janet S. “Medical malpractice: An historical perspective”. New Jersey Medicine 100, no. 7–8 (2003): 21–5.

Danzon, Patricia. Medical malpractice: Theory, evidence, and public policy. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1985.

Danzon, Patricia and Epstein, Andrew J. and Johnson, Scott J. „The «Crisis» in Medical Malpractice Insurance”. In Brookings-Wharton Papers on Financial Services: 2004, eds. Robert E. Litan, Richard J. Herring, 55–96. Washington: Brookings Institution Press, 2004.

De Ville, Kenneth Allen. Medical Malpractice in Nineteenth-Century America: Origins and Legacy. New York: New York University Press, 1990.

Field, Robert I. „The Malpractice Crisis Turns 175: What Lessons Does History Hold For Reform?”. Drexel Law Review 4 (2010): 7–39.

Filkins, James A. “«With no evil intent»: The criminal prosecution of physicians for medical negligence”. Journal of Legal Medicine 22, no. 4 (2001): 467–99.

Friedman, Lawrence M. A history of American law. New York: Simon and Schuster, 2005.

Garner, Bryan A. ed. Black’s Law Dictionary, 9th ed. St. Paul: West, 2009.

Gordon, Victor M. “The origin, basis and nature of medical malpractice liability”. Connecticut Medicine 35, no. 2 (1971): 73–7.

Grossman, Lewis A. “The origins of American health libertarianism”. Yale Journal of Health Policy, Law and Ethics 13, no. 1 (2013): 76–134.

Haar, Charles M. The Golden Age of American Law. New York: G. Braziller, 1965.

Halberda, Jan. Historia zobowiązań quasi-kontraktowych w common law. Kraków: Księgarnia Akademicka, 2012.

Hans, Valerie P. “Jury Systems Around the World”. Cornell Law Faculty Publications, article 305 (2008): 276–97.

Harrison, Louis B. and Worth Melvin H., Jr. and Carlucci, Michael A. “The Development of the Principles of Medical Malpractice in the United States”. Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 29, no. 1 (1985): 41–72.

Holmes, Jr. Oliver W. The common law. Boston, Mass.: Little, Brown & Co. 1881.

Horwitz, Morton J. The transformation of American law, 1780–1860. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1977.

Jena, Anupam B. and Seabury, Seth and Lakdawalla, Darius. „Malpractice Risk According to Physician Specialty”. New England Journal of Medicine 365, no. 7 (2011): 29–636.

Johnson, David A. and Chaudhry, Humayun J. Medical licensing and discipline in America: A history of the federation of State Medical Boards. Lanham: Lexington Books, 2012.

Johnson, Kirk B. and Phillips, Carter G. and Orentlicher, David and Hatlie, Martin S. “A fault-based administrative system for resolving medical malpractice claims”. Vanderbilt Law Review 32 (1989): 1365–406.

Karsten, Peter. “Enabling the Poor to Have Their Day in Court: The Sanctioning of Contingency Fee Contracts, a History to 1940”. DePaul Law Review 47, no. 2 (1998): 231–60.

Kessler, Daniel P. “Evaluating the Medical Malpractice System and Options for Reform”. Journal of Economic Perspectives 25, no. 2 (2011), 93–110.

Landsman, Stephen. “The civil Jury in America: Scenes from and unappreciated History”. Hastings Law Journal 44 (1993): 579–619.

Langbein, John H. and Lerner, Renée L. and Smith, Bruce P. History of the common law: The development of Anglo-American legal institutions. New York: Aspen Publishers, 2009.

Maitland, Frederic W. and Chaytor, Alfred H. and Whittaker, William J. The forms of action at common law: A course of lectures. Cambridge: University Press, 1936.

Mannlein, Melinda. “The Effects of Malpractice on Medical Specialties”. Honors Projects paper 38 (2002): 1–24.

Mello, Michelle M. and Studdert, David M. “The Medical Malpractice System – Structure and Performance”. In Medical malpractice and the U.S. health care system, eds. William M. Sage and Rogan Kersh, 11–29. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2006.

Mello, Michelle M. and Chandra, Amitabh and Gawande Atul A. and Studdert, David M. “National Costs of the Medical Liability System”. Health Affairs 29, no. 8 (2010), 1569–77.

Mello, Michelle M. and Studdert, David M. and Brennan, Troyen A. “The New Medical Malpractice Crisis”. New England Journal of Medicine 348, no. 10 (2003), 2281–4.

Michalak, Marcin. Kształtowanie się odpowiedzialności za niewłaściwe leczenie na gruncie amerykańskiego systemu prawnego w latach 1794–1860: Studium historyczno-prawne. Warszawa: Wydawnictwo C.H. Beck, 2018.

Mohr, James C. “American Medical Malpractice Litigation in Historical Perspective”. Journal of American Medical Association 283, no. 13 (2000): 1731–7.

Mohr, James C. Doctors and the law: Medical jurisprudence in nineteenth-century America. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1996.

Plucknett, Theodore F.T. A concise history of the common law. Boston, Mass.: Little, Brown and Co., 1956.

Pollock, Frederick and Maitland, Frederic W. The history of English law before the time of Edward I. Cambridge: University Press, 1898.

Robinson, Glen O. “The Medical Malpractice Crisis of the 1970’s: A Retrospective”. Law and Contemporary Problems 49, no. 2 (1986): 5–35.

Roscoe, Pound. The Formative Era of American Law, Boston, Mass.: Little, Brown and Co., 1938.

Rothstein, William G. American physicians in the nineteenth century: From sects to science. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1972.

Sandor, Andrew A. “The history of professional liability suits in the United States”. Journal of American Medical Association 163, no. 6 (1957): 459–66.

Shryock, Richard H. Medical licensing in America, 1650–1965. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1967.

Silver, Theodore. “One Hundred Years of Harmful Error: The Historical Jurisprudence of Medical Malpractice”. Wisconsin Law Review (1992): 1193–241.

Simpson Alfred W.B. A history of the common law of contract: The rise of the action of assumpsit. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1975.

Sloan, Frank A. and Chepke, Lindsey M. Medical malpractice. Cambridge: MIT Press, 2008.

Smith, Hubert W. “Medical Responsibility for Medical Malpractice, VI.: Further Information about Direct Causation and Damage”. Journal of American Medical Association 117, no. 1 (1941): 23–33.

Smith, Hubert W. “Medical Responsibility for Medical Malpractice, I: The Legal Matrix of Medical Malpractice”. Journal of American Medical Association 116, no. 10 (1941): 942–7.

Smith, Hubert W. “Medical Responsibility for Medical Malpractice, II: Malpractice: Something of the Anatomy of Law”. Journal of American Medical Association 16, no. 19 (1941): 2149–59.

Smith, Hubert W. “Medical Responsibility for Medical Malpractice, III: Forgotten Ancestors of the American Law of Medical Malpractice”. Journal of American Medical Association 116, no. 24 (1941): 2490–4.

Smith, Hubert W. “Medical Responsibility for Medical Malpractice, IV: Malpractice Claims in the United States and the Proposed Formula for Testing Their Legal Sufficiency”. Journal of American Medical Association 116, no. 24 (1941): 2670–9.

Smith, Hubert W. “Medical Responsibility for Medical Malpractice’ V. Further Information about Duty and Derelication”. Journal of American Medical Association 116, no. 25 (1941): 2755–68.

Spiegel, Allen D. “America’s First Medical Malpractice Crisis, 1835–1865”. Journal of Community Health 22, no. 4 (1997): 283–308.

Starr, Paul. The social transformation of American medicine. New York: Basic Books, 1982.

Studdert, David M. and Mello, Michelle and Sage, William M. and DesRoches, Catherine M. and Jordon, Peugh and Zapert, Kinga and Brennan, Troyen A. “Defensive medicine among high-risk specialist physicians in a volatile malpractice environment”. Journal of American Medical Association 293, no. 21 (2005): 2609–17.

“The Changing Role of the Jury in the Nineteenth Century”. Yale Law Journal 74, no. 1 (1964): 170–92.

Vidmar, Neil. “Juries and Medical Malpractice Claims: Empirical Facts versus Myths”. Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research 467, no. 2 (2009): 367–75.

Vidmar, Neil. Medical Malpractice and the American Jury. Confronting the Myths about Jury Incompetence, Deep Pockets, and Outrageous Damage Awards. Ann Arbor, Mich.: University of Michigan Press, 1997.

Weigel, Charles J. “Medical Malpractice in America’s Middle Years”. Texas Reports on Biology and Medicine 32, no. 1 (1974): 191–205.

Weiler, Paul C. Medical malpractice on trial. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1991.

Wilson, Cecil B. Our ailing medical malpractice system. Washington Post, 7.09.2010.

Wood, Cece L. “Historical perspectives on law, medical malpractice, and the concept of negligence”. Emergency Medicine Clinics of North America 11, no. 4 (1993): 819–32.

Internet sources

http://docplayer.net/2734864-Analysis-of-the-current-medical-liability-climate-in-new-york-state.html (accessed: 8.09.2020).

https://www.health.ny.gov/health_care/medicaid/redesign/docs/2011-10-17_medical_malpractice_premiums.pdf (accessed: 8.09.2020).

Informacje

Informacje: Krakowskie Studia z Historii Państwa i Prawa, Tom 14 (2021), Tom 14, Zeszyt 3, s. 287 - 305

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4467/20844131KS.21.023.14088

Typ artykułu: Oryginalny artykuł naukowy

Tytuły:

Polski:

Medical Malpractice Liability in the United States of America in the Light of the 19th Century Origins of the American Legal System

Angielski:

Medical Malpractice Liability in the United States of America in the Light of the 19th Century Origins of the American Legal System

Autorzy

Marcin Michalak

https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6971-1992

Uniwersytet Gdański
ul. Bażyńskiego 1a 80-952 Gdańsk, Polska

Publikacja: 03.09.2021

Status artykułu: Otwarte

Licencja: CC BY-NC-ND

Udział procentowy autorów:

Marcin Michalak (Autor) - 100%

Korekty artykułu:

Języki publikacji:

Angielski

Liczba wyświetleń: 1101

Liczba pobrań: 631

<div id="cke_pastebin"> Medical Malpractice Liability in the United States of America in the Light of the 19th Century Origins of the American Legal System</div>

Pobierz xml