Saving Russia. Neorealist Theorists and the Interpretation of the Kremlin’s International Policy according to the Actor-Network Concept

Alla Kyrydon; Serhiy Troyan

Saving Russia. Neorealist Theorists and the Interpretation of the Kremlin’s International Policy according to the Actor-Network Concept

Publication date: 21.11.2024

Central European and Balkan Studies, 2024, Volume XXXIII, pp. 171 - 189

https://doi.org/10.4467/2543733XSSB.24.010.20034

Authors

Pobierz pełny tekst

PDF

Titles

Saving Russia. Neorealist Theorists and the Interpretation of the Kremlin’s International Policy according to the Actor-Network Concept

Abstract

The Russian-Ukrainian war of 2014–2024 and the destructive role of Russia negatively affects regional and global aspects of the life of peoples and states. It has created a threat of serious chaos in international relations. Russia’s aggressive policy has caused a crisis in world politics that even the great powers of today cannot overcome. The return to a new Cold War and the outbreak of a major war in Europe threatens the entire modern international system with dangerous turbulence. The purpose of the study is to analyze the concept of effectiveness and the role of influential international actors in the modern Russian-Ukrainian war in the field of actor-network theory. The research methodology is based on the principles of science, objectivity, historicism and the basic conceptual and theoretical provisions of the study of world politics and international relations. Actor-network theory was introduced by Michel Callon and Bruno Latour in the second half of the 1980s. In accordance with this theory, relations between participants are determined by the network itself and are marked by the intensity and orientation of the network of interactions. In the sense of international relations and world politics, this means that they are under the strong or even decisive influence of powerful international actors (big powers and flexible interstate coalitions). Russia is seen as one of the most influential international players or “core of localities” that interact. Accordingly, other influential international actors are very cautious about the complete break of relations with Russia; they do not consider the possibility of its complete defeat in the aggressive war against Ukraine. Such a position was reflected and substantiated in various theoretical approaches, examples of which are the ideas of neorealism representatives such as John Mearsheimer, Farid Zakaria and Henry Kissinger.

Keywords

Russian aggression, Russian-Ukrainian war 2014–2024, actor-network theory, realism / neorealism in international relations

References

Download references

Acharya A., Constructing Global Order: Agency and Change in World Politics, Cambridge and New York 2018.

Acharya A ., Buzan B., The Making of Global International Relations. Origins and Evolution of IR at its Centenary, Cambridge and New York 2019.

Akulov M.I., Kontseptsiya chasu v aktorno-merezheviy teoriyi: osoblyvosti pobudovy ta kontseptual’ni superechnosti [The concept of time in the actor-network theory: peculiarities of construction and conceptual contradictions], Kyyiv 2021 (in Ukrainian).

Badie B., New Perspectives on the International Order. No Longer Alone in This World, London 2019.

Bartosiak J., Friedman G., Wojna w kosmosie. Przewrót w geopolityce [War in space. A revolution in geopolitics], Warszawa 2023 (in Polish).

Bieleń S., Turbulence in the Post-Cold War Era, Warszawa 2021.

Buzan B., Lawson G., The Global Transformation: History, Modernity and the Making of International Relations (Cambridge studies in international relations; 135), Cambridge 2015.

Callon M., Law J., Rip A . (еds.), Mapping the Dynamics of Science and Technology: Sociology of Science in the Real World, London 1986.

Danylenko Y ., Yak zupynyty potraplyannya zakhidnykh komponentiv do rosiys’kykh raket. Holovne z dyskusiyi Atlantic Council [How to stop Western components from entering Russian missiles. Highlights from the Atlantic Council discussion], 2023, https://speka.media/yak-zupiniti-potraplyannya-zaxidnix-komponentiv-do-rosiiskix-raket-golovne-z-diskusiyi-atlantic-council-9d4519 (date accessed: 29.12.2023) (in Ukrainian).

Deyneka A .V., Stratehiyi pozytsionuvannya aktorno-merezhevoyi teoriyi v dyskursi suchasnoho sotsiolohichnoho teoretyzuvannya [Positioning strategies of actor-network theory in the discourse of modern sociological theorizing], “Aktual’ni problemy sotsiolohiyi, psykholohiyi ta pedahohiky” 2017, vol. 1 (32), pp. 60–77 (in Ukrainian).

Deyneka A .V., Evrystychnyy potentsial aktorno-merezhevoyi teoriyi dlya sotsiolohichnoyi kontseptualizatsiyi ahentnosti [Heuristic potential of actor-network theory for sociological conceptualization of agency], Kyyiv 2019 (in Ukrainian).

Fedunyak S., Vplyv rosiys’ko-ukrayins’koyi viyny na diyal’nist’ providnykh instytutiv bezpeky v konteksti formuvannya novoyi modeli mizhnarodnykh vidnosyn [The impact of the Russian-Ukrainian war on the activities of leading security institutions in the context of the formation of a new model of international relations], “Mediaforum” 2022, vol. 11, pp. 131–140 (in Ukrainian).

Felshtinsky Y., Stanczew M., Blowing Up Ukraine: The Return of Russian Terror and the Threat of World War III, London 2022.

Fisanov V., Ukrayina u mizhnarodnykh vidnosynakh Postvestfal’s’koyi doby: zmina heostratehichnoyi roli [Ukraine in international relations of the Post-Westphalian era: changing geostrategic role], “Istoryko-politychni problemy suchasnoho svitu: Modern Historical and Political” 2022, vol. 46, pp. 51–61 (in Ukrainian).

GFP Military Strength Ranking, 2023, https://www.globalfirepower.com/countries-listing.php (date accessed: 30.12.2023).

Henasambleya OON , Henasambleya OON ukhvalyla rezolyutsiyu z vymohoyu do Rosiyi pokynuty Ukrayinu zarady vseosyazhnoho, spravedlyvoho i mitsnoho myru: 141 krayina “za” [The UN General Assembly adopted a resolution demanding that Russia leave Ukraine for the sake of a comprehensive, just and durable peace: 141 countries “for”], 2023, https://ukrainian.voanews.com/a/oon-uchvalyla-rezoljuciju-shodo-vijny/6976346.html (date accessed: 30.12.2023) (in Ukrainian).

Herasymchuk T., Mizhnarodnyy poryadok XXI stolittya: osnovni teoretyko-kontseptual’ni pidkhody [International order of the 21st century: basic theoretical and conceptual approaches], “Mizhnarodni zv’yazky Ukrayiny: naukovi poshuky i znakhidky” 2016, vol. 25, pp. 335–355 (in Ukrainian).

Herpen, M.H. Van, Putin’s Wars: The Rise of Russia’s New Imperialism, Second Edition, Lanham 2015.

Horodyns’ka V., Viys’kova tekhnika ta mil’yardy dolariv: shcho otrymala Ukrayina vid partneriv za rik viyny [Military equipment and billions of dollars: what Ukraine received from partners during the year of the war], 2023, https://24tv.ua/economy/mizhnarodna-dopomoga-2023-skilki-viyskovoyi-finansovoyi-dopomogi_n2270406 (date accessed: 29.12.2023) (in Ukrainian).

Kissinger H., How to avoid another world war, 2022, https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/the-pushfor-peace/ (date accessed: 30.12.2023).

Knoke D ., Kuklinski J., Network Analysis, Bewerly Hills 1982.

Knoke D ., Pappi F., Broadbent J., Tsujinaka J., Comparing Policy Networks: Labour Politics in the US, Germany and Japan, Cambridge 1996.

Kuźniar R ., Zmierzch liberalnego porządku międzynarodowego 2011–2021 [The Twilight of the Liberal International Order 2011–2021], Warszawa 2022 (in Polish).

Kyrydon A .M., Aktorno-merezheva teoriya [Actor-network theory], 2019, https://vue.gov.ua/ (date accessed: 27.12.2023) (in Ukrainian).

Kyrydon A ., Troyan S., Conceptual Fundamentals of Post-Westphalian International Relations, “Roczniki Nauk Społecznych” 2020, vol. 12 (48), no. 4, pp. 69–85.

Kyrydon A ., Troyan S., International relations as a system and a discipline: From the Westphalian to the post-westphalian world order, “Studia i A nalizy Nauk o Polityce” 2021, no. 1, pp. 107–121.

Kyrydon A ., Troyan S., The Russian-Ukrainian war (2014–2022): Basic preconditions and causes, “Balkan Social Science Review” 2022, vol. 20, pp. 157–179.

Kyrydon A ., Troyan S., Wojna rosyjsko-ukraińska w kontekście bezpieczeństwa globalnego [The Russian-Ukrainian war in the context of global security], “Kultura – Historia – Globalizacja” 2023, no. 29, pp. 75–92 (in Polish).

Latour B., Reassembling the Social: An Introduction to Actor-Network-Theory, Oxford 2005.

Latour B., Pieriesborka sotsyal’noho: vviedieniye v aktorno-sietievuyu teoriyu [Reorganization of the social: introduction to actor-network theory], Moskva 2014 (in Russian).

Matviychuk Y ., Na Zakhodi hostro krytykuyut’ Kissingera, yakyy “zaproponuvav Ukrayini pominyaty terytoriyi na myr” [Kissinger is sharply criticized in the West, who “offered Ukraine to exchange territories for peace”], 2022 https://ukrainian.voanews.com/a/reakcia-na-slova-kisingera-pro-ukrainu/6589368.html (date accessed: 30.12.2023) (in Ukrainian).

Mearsheimer J., The Tragedy of Great Power Politics, New York 2001.

Mearsheimer J., The Great Delusion: Liberal Dreams and International Realities, New Haven, Conn 2018.

Mearsheimer J., John Mearsheimer on why the West is principally responsible for the Ukrainian crisis, “The Economist” 2022, 19 March.

Motyl A .J., Kissinger is dead wrong about the Russian war against Ukraine, 2023, https://www.factsandarts.com/index.php/current-affairs/kissinger-dead-wrong-about-russian-war-againstukraine?fbclid=IwAR3q8oDBWPmW95WLmVfl1CT59mM8iosFKk2uw14vMNS4srAZpF_-J_bAwQg (date accessed: 30.12.2023).

Nechayeva-Yuriychuk N ., Troyan S., Evolution of the Westphalian Order under the Influence of the World Wars: Historical and International Relations Aspects, “Codrul Cosminului” 2020, vol. 26, no. 1, July, pp. 187–206.

Nechayeva-Yuriychuk N ., Troyan S., Modern problems of international security: a look through the prism of J. Mearsheimer’s structural theory of offensive realism, “Studii Naţionale de Securitate: Revistă ştiinţifico-practică” 2022, no. 1 (5), pp. 90–103.

Nechayeva-Yuriychuk N ., “Nichoho ne sudylosya”. Shans, yakyy dala svitovi pandemiya COVID-19 (notatky na polyakh knyhy Farida Zakariyi) [“Nothing was destined”. The chance given to the world by the COVID-19 pandemic (notes in the margins of Farid Zakaria’s book)], “Wschód Europy” 2023, vol. 9, no. 1, pp. 211–221 (in Ukrainian).

Panyushkina Y ., “Populizm ne vyrishuye problem, a prosto znakhodyt’ vynnykh”. Veduchyy CNN Farid Zakariya pro holovni vyklyky suchasnosti [“Populism doesn’t solve problems, it just finds the culprits”. CNN presenter Farid Zakaria on the main challenges of our time], 2019, https://thepage.ua/ua/interview/populizm-ne-virishuye-problem-a-prosto-znahodit-vinnih-veduchij-cnn-farid-zakariya-pro-golovni-vikliki-suchasnosti (date accessed: 30.12.2023) (in Ukrainian).

Pietraś M. (ed.), Międzynarodowe stosunki polityczne [International Political Relations], Lublin 2021 (in Polish).

Reznikov O ., Antykremlivs’ka koalitsiya vzhe skladayet’sya z 54 krayin, yaki viryat’ u peremohu Ukrayiny [The anti-Kremlin coalition already consists of 54 countries that believe in the victory of Ukraine], 2023, https://vechirniy.kyiv.ua/news/78967/ (date accessed: 30.12.2023) (in Ukrainian).

Roloff H. and Tiedev P., Vermittlungen zwischen Washington und Moskau. Kissinger soll neuen Kalten Krieg verhindern [Negotiations between Washington and Moscow. Kissinger is supposed to prevent a new Cold War], 2016, https://www.bild.de/politik/ausland/donald-trump/kissingerwill-zwischen-russland-und-usa-vermitteln-49482764.bild.html (date accessed: 30.12.2023) (in German).

Solod’ko S., Aktorno-merezheva teoriya yak sotsiolohichna skladova intelektual’noho proektu Bruno Latoura [Actor-network theory as a sociological component of the intellectual project of Bruno Latour], “Sotsiolohiya: teoriya, metody, marketynh” 2014, vol. 4, pp. 156–170 (in Ukrainian).

Tolstov S., Mizhnarodna systema pochatku XXI stolittya [The International System of the Beginning of the XXI Century], “Foreign_Affairs” 2013, vol. 9, pp. 8–11; vol. 10, pp. 8–13; vol. 11, pp. 12–17 (in Ukrainian).

Troyan S., Świat po zimnej wojnie: zasady ewolucji współczesnego porządku międzynarodowego [The world after the Cold War: principles of evolution of the contemporary international order], in: Ład światowy w perspektywie relacji transatlantyckich, W. Gizicki (ed.), Lublin 2014, pp. 37–46 (in Polish).

Troyan S., Persha i Druha svitovi viyny u paradyhmi evolyutsiyi Vestfal’s’koho svitoporyadku [The First and Second World Wars in the paradigm of the evolution of the Westphalian world order], “Ukraine–Europe–World” 2019, vol. 23, pp. 49–60 (in Ukrainian).

Ukraina, Ukrayina otrymala status kandydata na chlenstvo v YES [Ukraine received the status of a candidate for EU membership], 2022, https://www.kmu.gov.ua/news/ukrayina-otrimala-statuskandidata-na-chlenstvo-v-yes (date accessed: 30.12.2023) (in Ukrainian).

Ukraina, Ukrayina podaye zayavku na vstup do NATO [Ukraine applies to join NA TO], 2022, https://www.ukrinform.ua/rubric-polytics/3583117-ukraina-podae-zaavku-na-vstup-do-natozelenskij.html (date accessed: 30.12.2023) (in Ukrainian).

Vidnyans’kyy S.V., Ukrayina – Yevropeys’kyy Soyuz: novyy etap vzayemovidnosyn v umovakh rosiys’ko-ukrayins’koyi viyny 2014–2022 rr. [Ukraine – European Union: a new stage of relations in the conditions of the Russian-Ukrainian war 2014–2022], “Mizhnarodni zv’yazky Ukrayiny: naukovi poshuky i znakhidky” 2022, vol. 31, pp. 10–37 (in Ukrainian).

VVP, VVP stran mira – 2022 [GDP of the world – 2022], https://fingeniy.com/vvp-stran-mira-2022-rejting-i-dolya-stran-v-mirovom-vvp/ (date accessed: 30.12.2023) (in Russian).

Zakaria F., The post-American World, N.Y.-L 2008.

Zakaria F., Ten Lessons for a Post-Pandemic World, Dublin 2021.

Zakaria F., Opinion Russia is the last multinational empire, fighting to keep its colonies, 2022, https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/03/31/ukrane-fighting-russia-imperialismeastern-europe-algeria-kenya/?fbclid=IwAR38R0WBY5l9A9Oi_Rk2-Xe21UZz2yPX2IY3tL9m4VQG4B8aBQbI_sx-q-0 (date accessed: 30.12.2023).

Zakaria F., Opinion: It’s time to start thinking about the endgame in Ukraine, 2022, https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/06/16/ukraine-war-endgame-russia-europe-us-goals/ (date accessed: 30.12.2023).

Zakaria F., Opinion: There is a path to ending the Ukraine war, 2023, https://edition.cnn.com/-2023/02/24/opinions/fareed-zakaria-ukraine-column/index.html (date accessed: 30.12.2023).

Information

Information: Central European and Balkan Studies, 2024, Volume XXXIII, pp. 171 - 189

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4467/2543733XSSB.24.010.20034

Article type: Original article

Titles:

English: Saving Russia. Neorealist Theorists and the Interpretation of the Kremlin’s International Policy according to the Actor-Network Concept

Authors

Alla Kyrydon

https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4375-5350

State Scientific Institution “Encyclopedic Publishing House”
Ukraine

Serhiy Troyan

https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3053-6530

Uniwersytet Rzeszowski

Published at: 21.11.2024

Article status: Open

Licence: CC BY

Percentage share of authors:

Alla Kyrydon (Author) - 50%

Serhiy Troyan (Author) - 50%

Information about author:

Alla Kyrydon – Doctor Habilit. of Historical Sciences, Professor, Honoured Master of Sciences and Engineering of Ukraine. She is Director of the State Scientific Institution «Encyclopedic Publishing House» (Kyiv, Ukraine). Her research interests encompass issues such as Memory Studies,methodology of historical research, state-church relations, the history of international relations, Ukrainian-Polish relations, problems of identity in the context of globalization, history of Ukraine etc. She is author and co-author of more than 500 scientific publications (in Ukrainian, English, Polish, and Russian). She is the leader of the project «Great Ukrainian Encyclopedia». Scientific discipline – political science, history.

Serhiy Troyan – Doctor Habilit. of Historical Sciences, Professor, Professor of the University of Rzeszów (Poland). Research interests: world history, international relations, history of diplomacy, research methodology, foreign and domestic policy of Central and Eastern Europe (including modern Ukrainian-Polish relations). Author of more than 500 scientific works in Ukrainian, English, Polish, and Russian, which are devoted to various aspects of the history of international relations. Head of the multi-volume project «The Great War 1914–1918: retrospective analysis».

Article corrections:

Publication languages:

English

View count: 23

Number of downloads: 13

Saving Russia. Neorealist Theorists and the Interpretation of the Kremlin’s International Policy according to the Actor-Network Concept

Download xml