Disposal of In-Game Items for Consideration in Polish Personal Income Tax
cytuj
pobierz pliki
RIS BIB ENDNOTEChoose format
RIS BIB ENDNOTEPublication date: 20.12.2024
Financial Law Review, 2024, Issue 35 (3)/2024, pp. 79 - 96
https://doi.org/10.4467/22996834FLR.24.015.20924Authors
Disposal of In-Game Items for Consideration in Polish Personal Income Tax
The article discusses the taxation of disposal of in-game items for consideration under Polish personal income tax. This is an issue which has received little attention in the tax literature to date and which, given the growing popularity of online games and the blurring of the boundaries between the real and virtual economy, is of significant practical importance. The main aim of this contribution was to analyse and evaluate the positions of the tax authorities on this matter, based on the individual tax interpretation issued. The first part of the study presents the features of in-game items as well as the rules for crafting and trading such items. The second part deals with the taxation of the disposal of such items for consideration by both entrepreneurs and non-business persons. The considerations serve to prove the hypothesis that the interpretation of the current Polish legislation in the context of transactions with game objects poses problems for both taxpayers and tax authorities, which is evidenced by the numerous doubts of taxpayers expressed in requests for individual tax interpretations, as well as the divergent positions of the tax authorities. The analysis carried out has made it possible to identify the issues which give rise to controversy and the main theoretical assumptions which should precede the introduction of legislative changes in this area.
Barroso, P. M.: Hyperreality and virtual worlds: when the virtual is real, Sphera Publica, vol. 2, No 19, 2019.
Bondecka-Krzykowska, I.: Cechy obiektów rzeczywistości wirtualnej, (in) Stacewicz P., Skowron B. (edit.) Przedmioty Wirtualne, Warszawa, 2019.
Brzeziński, K., Lubacz, J.: Skąd się biorą przedmioty wirtualne (in) Stacewicz P., Skowron B. (edit.) Przedmioty Wirtualne, Warszawa, 2019.
Brzostowska, M., Kubiesa, P.: PIT. Komentarz, SIP Lex 2024.
Burns, B.: Do Virtual World Activities Give Rise to Real Canadian Tax Liabilities?, Asper Review of International Business and Trade Law, Vol. 10, No 1, 2010.
Cai, X., Cebollada, J., Cortiñas, M.: A grounded theory approach to understanding in-game goods purchase, PLoS ONE 2021, 17(1): e026998. Available at https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0262998, accessed: 23 July 2024.
Damer, B.: Meeting in the Ether: A Brief History of Virtual Worlds as a Medium for User-Created Events, ARTIFACT, Vol. II, Issue 2, 2008.
Duda-Hyz, M.: Gambling with in-game items and virtual currencies – the current legal status and challenges for the Polish legislator (in) Tomášková E., Neckář J. (edit.); Interaction of Law and Economics: Sustainable Development. 19th International Conference Perspectives of Business and Entrepreneurship Development and 22nd Annual Conference of the International Center of Public Finance and Tax Law Research – Perspective of Law hosted by the Faculty of Business and Management,
Brno University of Technology and the Faculty of Law, Masaryk University, Brno, 2023.
Dziwok, E.: Rynek gier wirtualnych MMO i jego wpływ na bank centralny, Nauki o Finansach, Vol. 2, 2014.
Gienas, K.: Prawo autorskie w ramach „wirtualnych światów”, BBKE e-Biuletin, Vol. 4, 2007.
Gołaczyński, J.: Wirtualne światy a własność wirtualna (in) Jagielska M., Pazdan M., Rott-Pietrzyk E., Szpunar M. (edit.), Rozprawy z prawa prywatnego. Księga jubileuszowa dedykowana Profesorowi Wojciechowi Popiołkowi, SIP LEX 2017.
Greer, N., Rockloff, M., Browne, M., Hing, N., Kong, D. L.: Esports Betting and Skin Gambling: A Brief History, Journal of Gambling Issues, Vol. 43, 2019.
Herbet, A.: Commentary to Article 22 (in) Machnikowski P. (edit.), Zobowiązania. Przepisy ogólne i powiązane przepisy księgi I KC. Tom I. Komentarz, SIP Legalis, 2022.
Hofman-Kohlmeyer, M.: Zarządzanie zakupem wirtualnych produktów przez użytkowników gier komputerowych typu Second Life (in) Grochowina K., Tokarski D., Sawicki A. (edit.), Wybrane obszary ekonomii i zarządzania we współczesnych przedsiębiorstwach, Pelpin, 2020.
Janicki, T.: Podatki w wirtualnym świecie, Przegląd Podatkowy, No 10, 2015.
Janowski, J.: Wirtualizacja prawa cywilizacji informacyjnej: techniczno-ideologiczne symulatory zjawisk prawnych (in) Stacewicz P., Skowron B. (edit.) Przedmioty Wirtualne, Warszawa, 2019.
Kais, M., Al-Gnbri, A.: Accounting and Auditing in the Metaverse World from a Virtual Reality Perspective: A Future Research, Journal of Metaverse, Vol. 2, Issue 1, 2022.
Karkut, D.: Własność wirtualna. Problemy definicyjne i perspektywa polskiego prawa (in) Kalina-Prasznic U. (edit.), Własność w prawie i gospodarce, Wrocław, 2017.
Lutkiewicz-Rucińska, A.: Commentary to Article 22 (in) Balwicka-Szczyrba, M., A. Sylwestrzak A. (edit.) Kodeks cywilny. Komentarz aktualizowany, SIP LEX 2024.
Mandal, S.: Brief Introduction of Virtual Reality & its Challenges, International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research, Vol. 4, Issue 4, 2013.
Matusiak, I.: Postacie świata wirtualnego w prawie autorskim, Przegląd Prawa Handlowego, Vol. 7, 2009.
Modzelewski, W. (edit.): Komentarz do ustawy o podatku dochodowym od osób fizycznych, SIP Legalis 2024.
Nazir, M., Siu Man Lui, C.: A Brief History of Virtual Economy, Virtual Worlds Research, 2016, Vol. 9, No 1, 2016.
Olszewski, A.: Konstrukcja prawna umowy sprzedaży wirtualnych przedmiotów w świetle prawa polskiego, Transformacje Prawa Prywatnego, Vol. 4, 2011.
Papagiannidis, S., Bourlakis, M., Li, F.: Making Real Money in Virtual Worlds: MMORPGs and Emerging Business Opportunities, Challenges and Ethical Implications
in Metaverses, Technological Forecasting and Social Change, Vol. 75, 2008.
Petrovskaya, E., D. Zendle, D.: Predatory Monetisation? A Categorisation of Unfair, Misleading and Aggressive Monetisation Techniques in Digital Games from the Player Perspective, Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 181, 2022. p. 1065.
Pietrasz, P.: Przychody wynikające z czynności, które nie mogą być przedmiotem prawnie skutecznej umowy. Komentarz praktyczny, SIP LEX 2024.
Regan, J.: Commentary do Article 22 (in) Załucki M. (edit.) Kodeks cywilny. Komentarz, SIP Legalis, 2023;
Spence, J.: Virtual Worlds Research: Consumer Behavior on Virtual Worlds, Journal of Virtual Worlds Research 2008, Vol. 1, No. 2, 2008.
Stacewicz, P.: Wirtualność w perspektywie obliczeniowej (in) Stacewicz P., Skowron B. (edit.) Przedmioty Wirtualne, Warszawa, 2019.
Steuer, J.: Defining Virtual Reality: Dimensions Determining Telepresence, Social responses to communication technologies, October 15, 1993, SRCT Paper#104.
Sung, M.: Umar W., On Taxing E-Sports Virtual Goods Transaction in Indonesia, Indonesian Comparative Law Review, vol. 3, No 1, 2020.
Święch-Kujawska, K.: Opodatkowanie dochodów małoletnich dzieci na gruncie ustawy o podatku dochodowym od osób fizycznych, Studia Prawnicze KUL, No 3, 2022, nr 3.
Wyczik, J.: Dobra wirtualne z perspektywy użytkowników i dostawców treści. Prawne uwarunkowania obrotu, Warszawa, 2022.
Wyczik, J.: Hazard w e-sporcie. Wybrane zagadnienia (in) Grabczyk K. (edit.), E-sport. Prawne aspekty, SIP LEX 2021.
Yaman, D.: Taxation of Virtual Worlds: Analysis Under United States of America and Turkish Tax Regulations, Sosyoekonomi, Vol. 31, 2023.
Zimmer-Czekaj, J.: Prawa własności intelektualnej w wirtualnych światach, Prace z Prawa Własności Intelectualnej, No 105, 2009.
Act of 27 July 1991 on Personal Income Tax, Journal of Laws 2024, item 226, as amended.
Judgment of the Supreme Administrative Court (NSA) of 9 August 2013, ref. II FSK 2480/11, SIP LEX no. 1383401.
Judgment of the Supreme Administrative Court of 7 April 2017 r., ref. II FSK 724/15, SIP Lex no. 2332975.
Judgment of the Supreme Administrative Court (NSA) of 27 January 2022 r., ref. II FSK 1225/19, SIP LEX no. 3334124.
Judgment of Supreme Administrative Court (NSA) of 23 August 2023, ref. II FSK 191/21, SIP LEX no. 3636986.
Judgment of the Voivodeship Administrative Court (WSA) in Warsaw of 8 June 2005, ref. III SA/Wa 423/03, SIP LEX no. 181423.
Judgment of the Voivodeship Administrative Court (WSA) in Wroclaw of 13 September 2018 r., I SA/Wr 560/18, SIP Lex no. 2738089.
Judgment of the Voivodship Administrative Court (WSA) of Lublin of 6th July 2022, ref. I SA/Lu 8/22, SIP LEX no. 3392236.
Individual tax interpretation of 10 May 2011, Director of the Tax Chamber in Bydgoszcz, ref. ITPB1/415-168/11/MR.
Individual tax interpretation of 28 January 2013, Director of the Tax Chamber in Bydgoszcz, ref. ITPB1/415-1237/12/DP.
Individual tax interpretation of 24 May 2013, Director of the Tax Chamber in Katowice, ref. IBPBII/1/415-226/13/AA.
Individual tax interpretation of 9 July 2014, Director of the Tax Chamber in Bydgoszcz, ref. ITPB1/415-435/14/AD.
Individual tax interpretation of 21 July 2014, Director of the Tax Chamber in Bydgoszcz, ref. ITPB1/415-471/14/MR.
Individual tax interpretation of 17 September 2014, Director of the Tax Chamber in Katowice, ref. IBPBII/1/415-510/14/MK.
Individual tax interpretation of 25 June 2015, Director of the Tax Chamber in Katowice, ref. IBPBII/1/4511-279/15/MK.
Individual tax interpretation of 8 February 2016, Director of the Tax Chamber in Bydgoszcz, ref. ITPB1/4511-1121/15/MR.
Individual tax interpretation of 7 March 2016, Director of the Tax Chamber in Łódź, ref. IPTPB1/4511-850/15-2/MH.
Individual tax interpretation of 7 September 2016, Director of the Tax Chamber in Bydgoszcz, ref. ITPB1/4511-661/16/PSZ.
Individual tax interpretation of 27 October 2016, Director of the Tax Chamber in Warsaw, ref. 1462-IPPB1.4511.973.2016.2.EC.
Individual tax interpretation of 1st December 2016, Director of the Tax Chamber in Katowice, ref. 2461-IBPB-1-1.4511.480.2016.2.BK.
Individual tax interpretation of 14 February 2017, Director of the Tax Chamber in Bydgoszcz, ref. 0461-ITPB1.4511.19.2017.1.JS.
Individual tax interpretation of 8 March 2017, Director of the Tax Chamber in Łódź, ref. 1061-IPTPB1.4511.1068.2016.1.AP.
Individual tax interpretation of 8 March 2017, Director of the National Revenue Administration Information Center (KIS), ref. 1061-IPTPB1.4511.1045.2016.2.AP.
Individual tax interpretation of 29 August 2017, Director of the National Revenue Administration Information Center (KIS), ref. 0115-KDIT3.4011.190.2017.1.WM.
Individual tax interpretation of 23 January 2018, Director of the National Revenue Administration Information Center (KIS), ref. 0113-KDIPT2-1.4011.457.2017.1.MM.
Individual tax interpretation of 13 March 2018, Director of the National Revenue Administration Information Center (KIS), ref. 0112-KDIL3-1.4011.98.2018.2.IM.
Individual tax interpretation of 25 April 2018, Director of the National Revenue
Administration Information Center (KIS), ref. 0113-KDIPT2-1.4011.107.2018.2.MM.
Individual tax interpretation of 8 September 2020, Director of the National Revenue Administration Information Center (KIS), ref. 0115-KDIT1.4011.511.2020.1.MR.
Individual tax interpretation of 24 September 2020, Director of the National Revenue
Administration Information Center (KIS), ref. 0113-KDIPT2-1.4011.648.2020.1.MM.
Individual tax interpretation of 22 September 2022, Director of the National Revenue
Administration Information Center (KIS), ref. 0113-KDIPT2-1.4011.588.2022.2.ID.
Individual tax interpretation of 22 September 2022, Director of the National Revenue
Administration Information Center (KIS), ref. 0114-KDIP3-2.4011.983.2023.1.MR.
Individual tax interpretation of 27 September 2023, Director of the National Revenue
Administration Information Center (KIS), ref. 0114-KDIP3-2.4011.651.2023.2.MT.
Individual tax interpretation of 9 July 2024, Director of the National Revenue
Administration Information Center (KIS), ref. 0112-KDSL1-1.4011.261.2024.4.DT.
National Corpus of the Polish Language, https://nkjp.pl/poliqarp/nkjp300/query/103/, accessed: 1st July 2024. https://nkjp.pl/poliqarp/nkjp300/query/19/, accessed: 1st July 2024.
PwC, Perspectives from the Global Entertainment & Media Outlook 2023-2027. Resetting expectations, refocusing inward and recharging growth, https://www.pwc.com/gx/en/industries/tmt/media/outlook/insights-and-perspectives.html, accessed: 16 May 2024.
Statista, Consumer spending on in-game purchases from 2020 to 2025 (in million U.S. dollars), https://www.statista.com/statistics/558952/in-game-consumer-spending-worldwide/, accessed: 16 May 2024.
Information: Financial Law Review, 2024, Issue 35 (3)/2024, pp. 79 - 96
Article type: Original article
Faculty of Law and Administration University of Opole 87A Katowicka, 45-060 Opole, Poland
Published at: 20.12.2024
Received at: 11.09.2024
Accepted at: 19.10.2024
Article status: Open
Licence: CC BY-NC-ND
Percentage share of authors:
Information about author:
Classification number:
Article corrections:
-Publication languages:
EnglishView count: 10
Number of downloads: 9