The Cathar myth of the fall. A late invention of independent heretical exegesis?

Piotr  Czarnecki

Titles

Abstract

Some scholars, following a deconstructivist interpretation of Catharism (which denies the existence of Catharism as dualistic heresy, or at least diminishes the significance of dualism as its distinctive feature) propose a hypothesis which assumes that Cathar dualism was not an idea imported from the East (from the earlier dualist traditions, especially from Bogomilism), but that it emerged independently in the West, later than it is reported by the sources, as an effect of specific scriptural exegesis developed in the dissidents’ schools. The main aim of this article is to verify, through the analysis of Biblical exegesis, this hypothesis, on which the myth of the fall – crucial for the dualist doctrine – was built. Based on various sources, both polemical and created by the Cathars themselves, it reconstructs biblical foundations of this crucial myth in two main branches of Catharism: the moderate and the radical (within the latter in two of its options: the angelic doctrine, and the doctrine of the two worlds), comparing them to the analogical exegetical concepts developed earlier by the Bogomils.

Keywords

kataryzm, herezje średniowieczne, egzegeza biblijna

catharism, medieval heresies, Biblical exegesis

References

Sources

Alanus de Insulis, De fide catholica contra Haereticos sui temporis, J.P. Migne (ed.), Patrologia Latina, vol. 210.

De erroribus manicheorum, J.N. Garvin, J.A. Corbett (eds.), [in:] J.N. Garvin, J.A. Corbett, The Summa contra Haereticos Ascribed to Praepositus of Cremona, Notre-Dame 1958, p. 292.

De Heresi Catharorum in Lombardia, A. Dondaine (ed.), “Archivum Fratrum Praedicatorum” 1949, no. 19, pp. 306–312.

Disputatio inter catholicum et paterinum hereticum, I. Da Milano (ed.), “Aevum” 1940, no. 14,
pp. 125–140.

Durandus de Huesca, Liber antiheresis, K.V. Selge (ed.), [in:] K.V. Selge, Die ersten Waldenser. Mit Edition des Liber Antiheresis des Durandus von Osca, vol. 2, Berlin 1967, pp. 3–258.

Durandus de Huesca, Liber contra manicheos, Ch. Thouzellier (ed.), [in:] Ch. Thouzellier, Une somme anti-cathare: le Liber contra Manicheos de Durand de Huesca, Louvain 1964, pp. 66–336.

Eckbertus Abbas Schonaugensis, Sermones contra catharos, J.P. Migne (ed.), Patrologia Latina, vol. 195, Parisiis 1855, pp. 13–103.

Interrogatio Iohannis, E. Bozoky (ed.), [in:] eadem, Le livre secret des cathares. Interrogatio Iohannis. Edition critique, traduction commentaire, Paris 2009.

Jacobus de Capellis, Disputationes nonnulae adversus haereticos, D. Bazzocchi (ed.), L’eresia catara. Appendice, Bologna 1920.

Liber de duobus principiis, A. Dondaine (ed.), [in:] idem, Un traité neo-manichéen du XIIIe siècle, Le Liber de duobus principiis, suivi d’un fragment de rituel cathare, Roma 1939, pp. 81–146.

Manifestatio haeresis albigensium et lugdunensium, A. Cazenave (ed.), [in:] A. Zimmermann (ed.), Die Mächte des Guten und Bösen: Vorstellungen im XII. u. XIII. Jahrhundert über ihr Wirken in der Heilsgeschichte, Berlin 1977, pp. 384–387.

Moneta de Cremona, Adversus Catharos et Valdenses libri quinque, T.A. Ricchini (ed.), Roma 1743.

S. Petrus Martyr, Summa contra haereticos, T. Kaepelli (ed.), “Archivum Fratrum Praedicatorum” 1947, no. 17, pp. 320–335.

Summa Fratris Raineri de ordine fratrum praedicatorum, de Catharis et Pauperibus de Lugduno, A. Dondaine (ed.), [in:] A. Dondaine, Un Traité Neo-Manicheen du 13 siècle, le Liber de duobus principiis suivi d’un fragment de Rituel Cathare, Roma 1939, pp. 64–78.

Tractatus de Hereticis, A. Dondaine (ed.), “Archivum Fratrum Praedicatorum” 1950, no. 20, pp. 308–324.

Tractatus manicheorum, Ch. Thouzellier (ed.), [in:] eadem, Un traité cathare inédit du début du XIIIe siècle d’après le Liber contra Manicheos de Durand de Huesca, Louvain 1961, pp. 87–113.

Vita Haereticorum quam fecit Bonacursus, J.P. Migne (ed.), Patrologia Latina, vol. 204, Parisiis 1855, pp. 775–792.

Literature

Acerbi A., La Visione di Isaia nelle vicende dottrinali del catarismo lombardo e provenzale, “Christianesimo nella storia” 1980, no. 1, pp. 75–122.

Arnold J., The Cathar Middle Ages as a Methodological and Historiographical Problem, [in:] Cathars in Question, A. Sennis (ed.), York 2016, pp. 53–78.

Biget J.L., Le Midi hérétique: construction d’une image (vers 1140–1209), “Religions et histoire” 2012, no. 46, pp. 40–45.

Biget J.L., Les bons hommes sont-ils les fils des bogomiles? Examen critique d’une idée reçue, “Slavica Occitania” 2003, no. 16, pp. 133–188.

Biget J.L., Réflexions sur «l’hérésie» dans le Midi de la France au Moyen Âge, “Heresis” 2001, no. 36–37, pp. 29–74.

Biller P., Goodbye to Catharism?, [in:] Cathars in Question, A. Sennis (ed.), York 2016, pp. 274–313.

Bozoky E., Le livre secret des cathares. Interrogatio Iohannis. Edition critique, traduction commentaire, Paris 2009.

Bozoky E., “Livre secret” des cathares: un lien entre l’Orient et l’Occident, “Slavica Occitania” 2003, no. 16, pp. 199–206.

Brenon A., Le faux problème du dualisme absolu, “Heresis” 1993, no. 21, pp. 61–74.

Cazenave A., Bien et mal dans un mythe cathare languedocien, [in:] Die Mächte des Guten und Bösen: Vorstellungen im XII. u. XIII. Jahrhundert über ihr Wirken in der Heilsgeschichte, A. Zimmermann (ed.), Berlin 1977, pp. 344–387.

Dondaine A., Durand de Huesca et la polémique anti-cathare, “Archivum Fratrum Praedicatorum” 1959, no. 29, pp. 228–267.

Dondaine A., La hiérachie cathare en Italie I, “Archivum Fratrum Praedicatorum” 1949, no., 19, pp. 280–312.

Dondaine A., La hiérarchie cathare en Italie II, “Archivum Fratrum Praedicatorum“ 1950, no. 20, pp. 234–324.

Dondaine A. Le manuel de l’inquisiteur, “Archivum Fratrum Praedicatorum” 1947, no. 17, pp. 85–194.

Dondaine A., Un Traité Neo-Manicheen du 13 siècle, le Liber de duobus principiis suivi d’un fragment de Rituel Cathare, Roma 1939.

Drakopoulos T., L’unité de Bogomilo-Catharisme d’après quatre textes latins analysés à la lumière des sources byzantines, Geneve 2010, http://archive-ouverte.unige.ch/unige:12233 [access: 01.09.2018].

Duvernoy J., Le catharisme II. L’histoire des cathares, Toulouse 1979.

Feuchter J., The ‘heretici’ of Languedoc: Local Holy Men and Women or Organized Religious Group? New Evidence from Inquisitorial, Notarial and Historiographical Sources, [in:] Cathars in Question, A. Sennis (ed.), York 2016, pp. 112–130.

Hamilton B., Cathar Links with the Balkans and Byzantium, [in:] Cathars in Question, A. Sennis (ed.), York 2016, pp. 131–150.

Inventer l’hérésie? Discours polémiques et pouvoirs avant l’Inquisition, M. Zerner (ed.), Nice 1998.

Jiménez-Sanchez P., De la participation des cathares rhénans (1163) à la notion d’hérésie générale, “Heresis” 2002, no. 36–37, pp. 201–218.

Jiménez-Sanchez P., Le catharisme: une origine orientale à deux tendances?, “Slavica Occitania” 2003, no. 16, pp. 207–228.

Jiménez-Sanchez P., Les catharismes: modèles dissidents du christianisme médiéval, XIIe–XIIIe siècles, Rennes 2008.

Jiménez-Sanchez P., Variations spatiales et temporelles dans l’organisation et dans l’encadrement des communautés dites «cathares», “Heresis” 2003, no. 39, pp. 35–62.

Kaepelli T., Une Somme contre les hérétiques de S. Pierre Martyr, “Archivum Fratrum Praedicatorum” 1947, no. 17, pp. 295–335.

Moore R.I., Principles at Stake: The Debate of April 2013 in Retrospect, [in:] Cathars in Question, A. Sennis (ed.), York 2016, pp. 257–273.

Moore R.I., The Formation of a Persecuting Society: Authority and Deviance in Western Europe, 950–1250, Malden 2007.

Moore R.I., The War on Heresy: Faith and Power in Medieval Europe, London 2012.

Pegg M.G., Albigenses in the Antipodes: An Australian and the Cathars, “Journal of Religious History” 2011, no. 35, pp. 577–600.

Pegg M.G., On Cathars, Albigenses, and Good Men of Languedoc, “Journal of Medieval History” 2001, no. 27, pp. 181–195.

Pegg M.G., The Corruption of Angels: The Great Inquisition of 1245–1246, Princeton 2001.

Pegg M.G., The Paradigm of Catharism; or, the Historians’ Illusions, [in:] Cathars in Question, A. Sennis (ed.), York 2016, pp. 21–52.

Poupin R., La papauté, les Cathares et Thomas d’Aquin, Portet-sur-Garonne 2000.

Roquebert M., Le ‘déconstructionnisme’ et les études cathares, [in:] Les Cathares devant l’Histoire. Mélanges offerts à Jean Duvernoy, M. Aurell (ed.), Cahors 2005, pp. 127–133.

Rottenwöhrer G., Der Katharismus, vol. 1 (1), Quellen zum Katharismus, Bad Honnef 1982.

Šanjek F., Raynerius Sacconi O.P. Summa de catharis, “Archivum Fratrum Praedicatorum” 1974, no. 44, pp. 31–60.

Selge K.V., Die ersten Waldenser. Mit Edition des Liber Antiheresis des Durandus von Osca, vol. 2, Berlin 1967.

Taylor C., Evidence for Dualism in Inquisitorial Registers of the 1240s: A Contribution to a Debate, “History” 2013, no. 98, pp. 319–345.

Taylor C., Looking for the ‘Good Men’ in the Languedoc: An Alternative to ‘Cathars’, [in:] Cathars in Question, A. Sennis (ed.), York 2016, pp. 242–256.

Théry J., L’hérésie des bons hommes. Comment nommer la dissidence religieuse non vaudoise ni béguine en Languedoc (XIIe–début XIVe siècle)?, “Heresis” 2002, no. 36–37, pp. 75–117.

Théry-Astruc J., The Heretical Dissidence of the ‘Good Men’ in the Albigeois (1276–1329): Localism and Resistance to Roman Clericalisms, [in:] Cathars in question, A. Sennis (ed.), York 2016, pp. 79–111.

Thouzellier Ch., Le Liber anti-heresis de Durand de Huesca et le Contra hereticos d’Ermengaud de Béziers, “Revue d’histoire ecclésiastique” 1960, no. 55, pp. 130–141.

Vassoli C., Il contra-haereticos di Alano di Lilla, “Bullettino dell’Istituto storico” 1963, no. 75, pp. 123–172.

Wakefield W.L., Notes on Some Antiheretical Writings of the Thirteenth Century, “Franciscan Studies” 1967, no. 27, pp. 285–320.

Werner E., L’evangelie de Jean et le dualisme medieval, “Heresis” 1989, no. 12, pp. 13–26.

Zerner M., Du court moment où on appela les hérétiques des “Bougres” et quelques déductions, “Cahiers de civilisation médiévale” 1989, no. 32, pp. 305–324.

Information

Information: Studia Religiologica, 2018, Volume 51, Issue 1, pp. 47 - 65

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4467/20844077SR.18.004.9493

Article type: Original article

Titles:

Polish:

The Cathar myth of the fall. A late invention of independent heretical exegesis?

English:

The Cathar myth of the fall. A late invention of independent heretical exegesis?

Authors

Piotr Czarnecki

https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4155-4918

Jagiellonian University in Kraków, Gołębia 24, 31-007 Kraków, Poland

Published at: 28.09.2018

Article status: Open

Licence: CC BY-NC-ND

Percentage share of authors:

Piotr Czarnecki (Author) - 100%

Article corrections:

-

Publication languages:

English

View count: 1532

Number of downloads: 1274

<p> The Cathar myth of the fall. A late invention of independent heretical exegesis?</p>

Studia-Religiologica