FAQ

What We Learn From Comparison: Some Epistemological Remarks

Publication date: 26.09.2024

Konteksty Kultury, 2024, Volume 21 Issue 2, pp. 107-122

https://doi.org/10.4467/23531991KK.24.013.20267

Authors

Luba Jurgenson
Centre national de la recherche scientifique (CNRS), Paris
, France
Sorbonne Université
https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0106-9184 Orcid
All publications →

Download full text

Titles

What We Learn From Comparison: Some Epistemological Remarks

Abstract

This article deals with the comparisons between testimonies and theoretical works on Nazi and Soviet camps carried on within literary studies. Going beyond the debates about potentially antagonistic memories of those two regimes, the comparison contributes to decompartmentalizing research, infusing it with new dynamics and methods as well as the adoption of a renewed approach to the construction of knowledge. Indeed, by conducting textual comparisons rather than basing their research on the study of facts, the researchers in the field of literary studies were able to question narrative strategies and the positions of certain works within their host cultures. Debates on the generic aspects of literary testimonies have thus helped shift the focus from the specificity of the experiences they described to their status and form. The article then compares the two bodies of texts from the point of view of their possible use as historical sources, and analyzes a few examples of narrative strategies.

References

Download references

Adler H.G., Theresienstadt 1941–1945. Das Antlitz einer Zwangsgemeinschaft, mit einem Nachwort von J. Adler, Wallstein Verlag, Gottingen 2005.

Agamben G., Quel che resta di Auschwitz. L’Archivio e il Testimone, Bollati Boringhieri, Turin 1998.

Bartov O., Weitz E.D. (eds.), Shatterzone of Empires: Coexistence and Violence in the German, Habsburg, Russian, and Ottoman Borderlands, Indiana University Press, Bloomington 2013.

Bechter D., Rousso H., “Illiberal policies regarding the past”, Memories at Stake, Summer–Fall 2019, no. 9, pp. 69–121.

Bott F., “Entretien avec Charlotte Delbo”, Le Monde des Livres, 20 juin 1975, p. 15.

Buber-Neumann M., Under Two Dictators, Dodd, Mead & Co., New York 1949.

Conio G., “Du dernier poeme au dernier tableau” [in:] L’Art contre les masses. Esthetiques et ideologies de la modernite, l’Age d’Homme, Paris 2003, pp. 43–65.

de Certeau M., L’Ecriture de l’Histoire, Gallimard, Paris 2002 (English edition: The Writing of History, trans. T. Conley, Columbia University Press, New York 1992).

Decout M., Faire trace. Les Ecritures de la Shoah, Corti, Paris 2022.

Delbo Ch., La Memoire et les jours, Berg international, Paris 1985 (English edition: Days and Memory, trans. R. Lamont, Northwestern University Press, Evanston 1990).

Dombrovsky Y., The Faculty of Useless Knowledge, trans. A. Myers, Harvill Press, London 1997.

Dombrovsky Y., The Keeper of Antiquities, trans. M. Glenny, Longman, London–Harlow 1969.

Foucault M., “L’homme est-il mort?” [in:] Dits et Ecrits, vol. 1: 1954–1975, Quarto Gallimard, Paris 2001, pp. 571–572.

Friedlander S., Nazi Germany and the Jews. 1939–1945: The Years of Extermination, HarperCollins, New York 2007.

Georget A., [documentary film] Festins imaginaires, Planete 2015.

Georget A., [documentary film] Les Recettes de Mina, Terezin 1944, Planete 2007.

Gradowski Z., The Last Consolation Vanished: The Testimony of a Sonderkommando in Auschwitz, eds. A.I. Davidson, P. Mesnard, trans. R. Monet, The University of Chicago Press, Chicago 2022.

Heffermehl F., Karlsohn I. (eds.), The Gulag in Writings of Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn and Varlam Shalamov: Memory, History, Testimony, Brill, Leiden–Boston 2021.

Herling-Grudziński G., Dziennik pisany nocą 1980–1983, Czytelnik, Warsaw 1996.

Hilberg R., The Politics of Memory: The Journey of a Holocaust Historian, Ivan R. Dee, Chicago 1996.

Jurgenson L., “The Periodic Table: Encryptions and decipherings”, trans. J. Gay, Temoigner. Entre histoire et memoire 2014, no. 119, pp. 93–111, https://journals.openedition.org/temoigner/1507 , accessed 19 August 2024.

Jurgenson L., “La question du silence dans les discours critiques sur les representations de la Shoah”, Cedille: Revista de Estudios Franceses, nov. 2015, vol. 5, pp. 117–135.

Jurgenson L., Werth N. (eds.), Le Goulag. Temoignages et archives, Laffont, Paris 2017.

Kassow S., Who Will Write our Story? Emanuel Ringelblum, the Warsaw Ghetto, and the Oyneg Shabes Archive, Indiana University Press, Bloomington 2007.

Katzenelson Y., The Song of the Massacred Jewish People, trans. J. Hirschman, Regent Press, Berkeley 2001.

Kershaw I., Lewin M. (eds.), Stalinism and Nazism: Dictatorships in Comparison, University of Cambridge Press, Cambridge 1977.

Kertesz I., The Holocaust as Culture, trans. T. Cooper, The University of Chicago Press, Chicago 2011.

Kotek J., Rigoulot P., Le siecle des camps: emprisonnement, detention, extermination, cent ans de mal absolu, Lattes, Paris 2000.

Kulka O.D., Jackel E., Die Juden in den geheimen NS-Stimmungsberichten 1939–1945, Droste Verlag, Dusseldorf 2004.

Kuon P., L’ecriture des revenants. Lectures de temoignages de la deportation politique, Kime, Paris 2013.

Lacoste Ch., Detue F. (eds.), “Temoigner en literature”, Europe, fevrier 1, 2016, no. 1041–1042, pp. 3–235.

Laks S., Dziennik pisany w biały dzień, Oficyna Poetow i Malarzy, London 1981.

Langfus A., “Il ne suffit pas d’etre sincere pour etre vrai”, Revue d’histoire de la Shoah, septembre–decembre 2002, no. 176.

Levi P., “Dai Lager di Stalin”, La Stampa. Collana Tuttolibri, September 25, 1976.

Levi P., Dello scrivere oscuroOpere complete, Einaudi, Torino 1990, vol. 2, pp. 839–843.

Margolin J., “Можно ли сравнивать гитлеровские лагеря с советскими?”, MAOZ 1950.

Nora P., Le Goff Jacques (eds.), Faire de l’histoireNouveaux problemes, nouvelles approches, nouveaux objets, vol. 1: Nouveaux problemes, Gallimard, Paris 1974.

Nouraud P.B., Figurer l’autre. Essai sur la figure du “musulman” dans les camps de concentration nazis, Kime, Paris 2013.

Parrau A., Ecrire les camps, Berlin–Paris 1995.

Prstojevic A., La Conquete du vide. Une histoire de l’anti-reference dans la litterature et les sciences humaines 1945–2000, Hermann, Paris 2022.

Ricoeur P., Memory, History, Forgetting, trans. K. Blamey, D. Pellauer, The University of Chicago Press, Chicago 2004.

Rousset D., Rosenthal G., Bernard T., Pour la verite sur les camps concentrationnaires (Un proces antistalinien a Paris), Ramsay, Paris 1990.

Rousso H. (ed.), Stalinism and Nazism: History and Memory Compared, trans. P. Rogers, R.J. Golsan, introd. by R.J. Golsan, University of Nebraska Press, Lincoln 2004.

Royer C., Imre Kertesz: “L’histoire de mes morts”, Actes Sud, Arles 2017.

Shalamov V., Собрание сочинений в 6 томах, Terra-Terra, Moskva 2013, vol. 4, pp. 286, 500.

Sica G., [documentary film] Giuseppe Ungaretti, Vita d’un uomo (1888–1970), Rai 1970.

Snyder T., Bloodlands: Europe Between Hitler and Stalin, Basic Books, New York 2010.

Tillion G., Le Verfubar aux enfersUne operette a Ravensbruck, La Martiniere, Paris 2005.

Ullmann V., Kien P., Der Kaiser von Atlantis oder Die Tod-Verweigerung, Hrsg. H. Brauel, Schott Music, Mainz 2015.

Wajcman G., L’Objet du siecle, Verdier, Lagrasse 2020.

Werth N., “De la sovietologie en general et des archives russes en particulier”, Le Debat 1993, no. 77, pp. 127–144.

Werth N., “Totalitarisme ou revisionnisme. L’histoire sovietique – une histoire en chantier”, Communisme 1996, no. 47–48, pp. 57–70.

Werth N., “Le Goulag au prisme des archives” [in:] Le Goulag en heritage. Pour une anthropologie de la trace, eds. E. Anstett, L. Jurgenson, Petra, Paris 2009, pp. 19–44.

Information

Information: Konteksty Kultury, 2024, Volume 21 Issue 2, pp. 107-122

Article type: Original article

Titles:

English: What We Learn From Comparison: Some Epistemological Remarks

Authors

https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0106-9184

Luba Jurgenson
Centre national de la recherche scientifique (CNRS), Paris
, France
Sorbonne Université
https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0106-9184 Orcid
All publications →

Centre national de la recherche scientifique (CNRS), Paris
France

Sorbonne Université

Published at: 26.09.2024

Article status: Open

Licence: CC BY  licence icon

Percentage share of authors:

Luba Jurgenson (Author) - 100%

Article corrections:

-

Publication languages:

English

View count: 191

Number of downloads: 109

What We Learn From Comparison: Some Epistemological Remarks

What We Learn From Comparison: Some Epistemological Remarks

cytuj

pobierz pliki

RIS BIB ENDNOTE