FAQ

Ctesias and the Importance of His Writings Revisited

Publication date: 22.01.2013

ELECTRUM, 2012, Volume 19, pp. 9 - 40

https://doi.org/10.4467/20843909EL.12.001.0742

Authors

Eran Almagor
All publications →

Titles

Ctesias and the Importance of His Writings Revisited

Abstract

Following the recent attempts to rehabilitate the reputation of Ctesias and the information given in his works, this paper proposes to understand certain of the seemingly fanciful details that were associated with the physician and his writings. It tries to shed some light on several uncertainties connected with Ctesias (i.e., his sojourn in Persia) and the Persica (i.e., date, original style and sources of imagery). It argues that the pedestrian lists included in the work might have been later interpolations and that the minor works circulating under Ctesias’ name might have been either sections of the Persica that were taken out to be presented as stand-alone volumes or else falsely attributed to him. The paper addresses the Indica and puts forward several possibilities concerning its relation with the Persica. The influence of Ctesias on the author Deinon is examined, and in the appendix the impact of the Persica on Xenophon’s Anabasis is analyzed.

References

Download references

Almagor, E. (2011): Plutarch on the End of the Persian Empire, Graeco-Latina Brunensia 16: 3–16.

Almagor, E., Forthcoming (a): The King’s Road in Greek Sources, in: J. Ma/C.J. Tuplin (eds.), Arshama and Egypt The World of Achamenid Satrape (Oxford: OUP).

Almagor, E., Forthcoming (b): Plutarch and the Persica (Edinburgh: EUP).

Alonso-Nunez, J.-M. (1996): Ctesias, Historien Grec du Monde Perse, in: P. Carlier (ed.), Le IVe siecle av. J.-C., Nancy: 325–333.

Anderson, J.K. (1974): Xenophon, London.

Auberger, J. (1991): Ctesias. Histoires de lOrient, Paris.

Badian, E. (1965): The Date of Cleitarchus, PACA: 5–11.

Bahr, J.C.F. (1824): Fragmente des Ktesias von Knidos, Frankfurt.

Barber, G.L. (1935): The Historian Ephorus, Cambridge.

Barnett, R.D. (1963): Xenophon and the Wall of Media, JHS 83: 1–26.

Bassett, S.R. (1999): The Death of Cyrus the Younger, CQ n.s. 49: 473–483.

Bichler, R. (2004): Some Observations on the Image of the Assyrian and Babylonian Kingdoms with the Greek Tradition, in: R. Rollinger, C. Ulf (eds.), Commerce and Monetary Systems in the Ancient World. Means of Transition and Cultural Interaction, Wiesbaden: 499–518.

Bichler, R. (2007): Ktesias ‘korrigiert’ Herodot, in: R. Bichler, Historiographie Ethnographie Utopie. Gesammelte Schriften, Teil 1: Studien zu Herodots Kunst der Historie, Wiesbaden: 229–245.

Bickerman, E.J., Tadmor, H. (1978): Darius I, Pseudo-Smerdis, and the Magi, Athenaeum, n.s. 56: 239–261.

Bigwood, J.M. (1964): Ctesias of Cnidus, Diss. Harvard University.

Bigwood, J.M. (1965): Ctesias of Cnidus, HSPh 70: 263–265.

Bigwood, J.M. (1976): Ctesias’ Account of the Revolt of Inaros, Phoenix 30: 1–25.

Bigwood, J.M. (1978): Ctesias as Historian of the Persian Wars, Phoenix 32: 19–41.

Bigwood, J.M. (1980): Diodorus and Ctesias, Phoenix 34: 195–207.

Bigwood, J.M. (1983): The Ancient Accounts of the Battle of Cunaxa, AJP 104: 340–357.

Bigwood, J.M. (1986): P. Oxy. 2330 and Ctesias, Phoenix 40: 393–406.

Bigwood, J.M. (1989): Ctesias’ Indica and Photius, Phoenix 43: 302–316.

Bigwood, J.M. (1993a): Aristotle and the Elephant Again, AJP 114: 537–555.

Bigwood, J.M. (1993b): Ctesias’ Parrot, CQ 43: 321–327.

Bigwood, J.M. (1995): Ctesias, His Royal Patrons and Indian Swords, JHS 115: 135–140.

Biltcliffe, A.W. (1969): P. Oxy. N° 2330 and its Importance for the Study of Nicolaus of Damascus, RhM 112: 85–93.

Binder, C. (2008): Plutarchs Vita des Artaxerxes. Ein historischer Kommentar, Berlin.

Bosworth, A.B. (1980): Alexander and the Iranians, JHS 100: 1–21.

Braun, T. (2004): Xenophon’s Dangerous Liaisons, in: R. Lane Fox (ed.), The Long March. Xenophon and the Ten Thousand, New Haven, CT–London: 96–130.

Breitenbach, H.R. (1967): Xenophon, RE IX A: 1567–2052.

Briant, P. (ed.) (1995): Dans les pas des Dix-Mille, Toulouse.

Briant, P. (2002): From Cyrus to Alexander, Winona Lake, IN (translation of Histoire de lempire perse: De Cyrus a Alexandre, 1996, Paris).

Brosius, M. (1996): Women in Ancient Persia (559-331 B.C.), Oxford.

Brown, T.S. (1978): Suggestions for a Vita of Ctesias of Cnidus, Historia 27: 1–19.

Burn, A.R. (1962): Persia and the Greeks, London.

Bux, E. (1927): Sophainetos, RE IIIA: 1008–1013.

Calmeyer, P. (1977): Vom Reisehut zur Kaiserkrone: b. Stand der archaeologischen Forschung zu den Iranischen Kronen, AMI 9: 168–190.

Cawkwell, G.L. (1972): Introduction, in: R. Warner (tr.), Xenophon. The Persian Expedition, London.

Cawkwell, G.L. (2004): When, How and Why did Xenophon Write the Anabasis, in: R. Lane Fox (ed.), The Long March. Xenophon and the Ten Thousand, New Haven, CT–London: 47–67.

Cizek, A. (1975): From the Historical Truth to the Literary Convention. The Life of Cyrus the Great viewed by Herodotus, Ctesias and Xenophon, AC 44: 531–552.

Comploi, S. (2002): Die Darstellung der Semiramis bei Diodorus Siculus, in: R. Rollinger, C. Ulf (eds.), Geschlechterrollen und Frauenbild in der Persektive antiken Autoren, Wiesbaden: 223–271.

Cook, J.M. (1983): The Persian Empire, London–New York.

Dalley, S. (2003): Why did Herodotus not mention the Hanging Gardens of Babylon?, in: P. Derow, R. Parker (eds.), Herodotus and his World, Oxford: 171–189.

Del Corno, D. (1962): La lingua di Ctesia (POx. 2330), Athenaeum 40: 126–141.

Delebecque, E. (1957): Essai sur la vie de Xenophon, Paris.

Dillery, J. (1995): Xenophon and the History of His Times, London–New York.

Dorati, M. (1995): Ctesia falsario?, Quaderni di storia 41: 33–52.

Drews, R. (1973): The Greek Accounts of Eastern History, Cambridge, MA.

Durrbach, F. (1893): L’apologie de Xenophon dans l’Anabase, REG 6: 343–386.

Eck, B. (1990): Sur la vie de Ctesias, REG 103: 409–434.

Evans, J.A.S. (1968): Father of History or Father of Lies. The Reputation of Herodotus, CJ 64: 11–17.

Fehling, D. (1989): Herodotus and his Sources(trans. J.G. Howie), Leeds.

Fischer, C.T., Wecker, O. (1924): Kynokephaloi, RE XII: 24–26.

Gasche, H. (1995): Autour des Dix-Mille. Vestiges archeologiques dans les environs du ‘Mur de Medie’, in: Briant 1995: 201–216.

Gera, D.L. (1993): Xenophons Cyropaedia. Style. Genre and Literary Technique, Oxford.

Giangrande, G. (1976): On an alleged fragment of Ctesias, QUCC 23: 31–46.

Gilmore, J. (1888): The Fragments of the Persika of Ktesias, London.

Goossens, G. (1950): Le sommaire des Persica de Ctesias par Photius, Revue Belge de philologie et dhistoire 28: 513–521.

Gray, V.J. (2003): Interventions and citations in Xenophon, Hellenica and Anabasis, CQ n.s. 53: 111–123 (= V.J. Gray (ed.) (2010): Xenophon. Oxford Readings in Classical Studies, Oxford: 558–570).

Griffi ths, A. (1987): Democedes of Croton. A Greek Doctor at Darius’ Court, Achaemenid History 2: 35–71.

Guyot, P. (1980): Eunuchen als Sklaven und Freigelassenen in der griechisch-roemischen Antike, Stuttgart.

Hagg, T. (1973): Photius at Work. Evidence from the Text of the Bibliotheca, GRBS 14: 213–222.

Hanson, A.E. (1991): Continuity and Change. Three Case Studies in Hippocratic Gynecological Therapy and Theory, in: S.B. Pomeroy (ed.), Womens History and Ancient History, Chappel Hill, North Carolina: 73–110.

Hamilton, J.R. (1961): Cleitarchus and Aristobulus, Historia 10: 448–458.

Hamilton, J.R. (1969): Plutarch, Alexander. A Commentary, Oxford.

Haug, M. (1854), Die Quellen Plutarchs in den Lebensbeschreibungen der Griechen, Tubingen.

Henry, R. (1947): Ctesias, la Perse, lInde, les sommaires de Photius, Brussels.

Henry, R. (1959): Photius. La Bibliotheque, Paris.

Hintz, W. (1975): Altiranisches Sprachgut der Nebenuberliefrungen, Wiesbaden.

Jacoby, F. (1921): Kleitarchos (2), RE XI: 622–654.

Jacoby, F. (1922): Ktesias, RE XI: 2032–2073.

Jacoby, F. (1930): Die Fragmente der griechischen Historiker, vol. IId, Berlin.

Jacoby, F. (1958): Die Fragmente der griechischen Historiker, vol. IIIc, Leiden.

Justi, F. (1895): Iranisches Namenbuch, Marburg.

Kaemmel, O. (1875): Die Berichte uber die Schlacht von Kunaxa und den Fall des Kyros am 3 September 401 vor Chr., Philologus 34: 515–538, 665–696.

Karttunen, K. (1980): The Reliability of the Indika of Ctesias, Studia Orientalia 50: 105–107.

Karttunen, K. (1989): India in Early Greek Literature, Helsinki.

Karttunen, K. (1991): The Indica of Ctesias and its Criticism, in: Graeco-Indica, Indias Cultural Contects [sic] with the Greek World: in Memory of Demetrius Galanos (17601833), a Greek Sanskritist of Benares, New Dehli: 74–85.

Karttunen, K. (1997): Greeks and Indian Wisdom, in: E. Franco, K. Preisendanz (eds.), Beyond Orientalism. The Work of Wilhelm Halbfass and its Impact on Indian and Cross-Cultural Studies, Amsterdam: 117–122.

Kent, R.G. (1953): Old Persian Grammar Texts Lexicon, New Haven, CT.

King, H. (1998): Hippocrates Woman. Reading the Female Body in Ancient Greece, London.

Kirtley, B.F. (1963): The Ear Sleepers. Some Permutations of a Traveler’s Tale, Journal of American Folklore 76: 119–130.

Konig, F.W. (1972): Die Persika des Ktesias von Knidos, Graz.

Korte, A. (1922): Die Tendenz von Xenophons Anabasis, NJbb 49: 15–24.

Kuhrt, A. (2007): The Persian Empire, 2 vols., London.

Lassen, C. (1874): Indische Alterumskunde, Leipzig.

Le Goff, J. (1964): La civilisation de lOccident medieval, Paris.

Lemerle, P. (1986): Byzantine Humanism (trans. H. Lindsay & A. Moffat), Canberra.

Lendle, O. (1986): Xenophon in Babylonien. Die Marsche der Kyreer von Pylai bis Opis, RhM 129: 193–222.

Lendle, O. (1995): Kommentar zu Xenophons Anabasis, Darmstadt.

Lenfant, D. (1996): Ctesias et Herodote, ou les reecritures de l’histoire dans la Perse achemenide, REG 109: 348–380.

Lenfant, D. (1999): Monsters in Greek Ethnography and Society in the Fifth and Fourth Centuries BCE, in: R. Buxton (ed.), From Myth to Reason? Studies in the Development of Greek Thought, Oxford: 197–214.

Lenfant, D. (2004): Ctesias de Cnide. La Perse, LInde, Autres Fragments, Paris.

Lenfant, D. (2007): Greek Historians of Persia, in: J. Marincola (ed.), A Companion to Greek and Roman Historiography, vol. 1, Oxford: 201–209.

Lenfant, D. (2009): Les Histoires perses de Dinon et dHeraclide. Fragments edites, traduits et commentes, Paris.

Lewis, D.M. (1977): Sparta and Persia, Leiden.

Lindegger, P. (1982): Griechische und romische Quellen zum peripheren Tibet, Teil II: Uberlieferungen von Herodot bis zu den Alexanderhistorikern (Die nordosten Grenzregionen Indiens), Zurich.

Llewellyn-Jones, L., Robson J. (2010): Ctesias History of Persia. Tales of the Orient, London.

MacGinnis, J.D.A. (1988): Ctesias and the Fall of Nineveh, ICS 13: 37–43.

MacLaren, M. (1934): Xenophon and Themistogenes, TAPA 15: 240–247.

Manfredi, V. (1978): Proposte per una revisione itineraria e per un commento topografi co dell’Anabasi di Senofonte, Aevum 52: 62–67.

Manfredi, V. (2004): The Identifi cation of Mount Thekes in the Hincrary of the Ten Thousand: A New Hypothesis, in: C. Tuplin (ed.), Xenophon and this World: Papers from a Conference held in Liverpool in July 1999, Stuttgart: 319–324.

Manfredini, M., Orsi, D.P., Antelami, V. (1987; 19962): Plutarcho, Le Vite di Arato et di Artaserse, Roma.

Mango, C. (1975): The Availablity of Books in the Byzantine Empire, A.D. 750–850, in: C. Mango, I. Ševčenko (eds.), Byzantine Books and Bookmen. A Dumbarton Oaks Colloquium, Washington, DC–New York: 29–45.

Mantey, O.A. (1888): Welchen Quellen folgte Plutarch in seinem Leben des Artaxerxes, Greifenberg in Pommern.

Marincola, J. (1997): Authority and Tradition in Ancient Historiography, Cambridge.

McCrindle, J.W. (1881): Ancient India as Described by Ktesias the Knidian, Calcutta–Bombay.

Mendels, D. (1981): The Five Empires. A Note on a Propagandistic Topos, AJPh 102: 330–337.

Mendels, D. (2004): Memory in Jewish, Pagan and Christian Societies of the Graeco-Roman World, London–New York.

Mess, A. von (1906): Untersuchenen uber Ephoros, RhM 61: 360–407.

Miller, M. (1997): Athens and Persia in the Fifth Century BC. A Study in Cultural Receptivity, Cambridge.

Mitscherling, J. (1982): Xenophon and Plato, CQ n.s. 32: 468–469.

Momigliano, A. (1931): Tradizione e invenzione in Ctesia, Atena e Roma n.s. 12: 15–44.

Momigliano, A. (1958): The Place of Herodotus in the History of Historiography, History 43: 1–13.

Momigliano, A. (1971): The Development of Greek Biography, Cambridge, MA–London.

Momigliano, A. (1975): Alien Wisdom. The Limits of Hellenization, Cambridge.

Muller, C. (1844): Ctesiae Cnidii et Chronographorum Castoris, Eratosthenes, etc. Fragmenta, Paris.

Murray, O. (2001): Herodotus and Oral History, in: N. Luraghi (ed.), The Historians Craft in the Age of Herodotus, Oxford: 16–44.

Neuhaus, O. (1901): Die Uberlieferung uber Aspasia von Phokaia, RhM 56: 272–283.

Nichols, A. (2008): The Complete Fragments of Ctesias of Cnidus. Translation and Commentary with an Introduction, PhD diss., University of Florida.

Nichols, A. (2011): Ctesias on India, London.

Nippel, W. (2001): The Construction of the ‘Other,’ (trans. A. Nevill), in: T. Harrison (ed.), Greeks and Barbarians, Edinburgh: 278–310.

Nutton, V. (2004): Ancient Medicine, London–New York.

Obermeyer, J. (1929): Die Landschaft Babylonien in Zeitalter des Talmuds und des Gaonats, Frankfurt am Main.

Pearson, L. (1960): The Lost Histories of Alexander the Great, New York.

Perlman, S. (1976/1977): The Ten Thousand. A Chapter in the Military, Social and Economic History of the Forth Century. RSA 6/7: 241–284.

Pritchett, W.K. (1993): The Liar School of Herodotus, Amsterdam.

Rettig, H.C.M. (1827): Ctesiae Cnidii vita cum appendice de libris quos Ctesias composuisse fertur, Hannover.

Reuss, E. (1887): Kritische und exegetische Bemerkungen zu Xenophons Anabasis, Wetzlar.

Ritter, H.W. (1965): Diadem und Konigsherrschaft, Munchen.

Rood, T. (2004): Panhellenism and Self-presentation. Xenophon’s Speeches, in: R. Lane Fox (ed.), The Long March: Xenophon and the Ten Thousand, New Haven, CT–London: 305–329.

Russell, D.A. (1973): Plutarch, London.

Sachs, A.J., Hunger, H. (1988): Astronomical Diaries and Related Texts from Babylonia, vol. 1: Diaries from 652 B.C. to 262 B.C., Wien.

Sancisi-Weerdenburg, H. (1983): Exit Atossa, in: A. Cameron, A. Kuhrt (eds.), Images of Women in Antiquity, London: 20–33.

Sancisi-Weerdenburg, H. (1987): Decadence in the Empire or Decadence in the Sources? From Source to Synthesis: Ctesias, Achaemenid History 1: 33–46.

Sancisi-Weerdenburg, H. (1988): Was there Ever a Median Empire?, Achaemenid History 3: 197–212.

Schmitt, R., (2002): Die Iranischen und Iranier-Namen in den Schriften Xenophons, Vienna.

Schmitt, R. (2006): Iranische Anthroponyme in den Erhaltenen Resten von Ktesias Werk, Vienna.

Schottin, (1865): Observationes de Plutarchi Vita Artaxerxeis, Budissin.

Schwartz, E. (1905): Dinon (2), RE V: 654.

Shafer, R. (1964): Unmasking Ktesias’ Dogheaded People, Historia 13: 499–503.

Shepard, O. (1930): The Lore of the Unicorn, London.

Smith, C.F. (1881): A Study of Plutarchs Life of Artarxerxes, Leipzig, PhD diss.

Stadter, P.A. (1965): Plutarchs Historical Methods, Cambridge, MA.

Stevenson, R.B. (1997): Persica, Edinburgh.

Stronk, J. (2004/2005): Ctesias of Cnidus. From Physician to Author, Talanta 36–37: 101–122.

Stronk, J. (2007): Ctesias of Cindus. A Reappraisal, Mnemosyne 60: 25–58.

Stronk, J. (2010): Ctesias of Cnidus Persica. Editio Minor with Introduction, Text, Translation and Historical Commentary, vol. 1, Dusseldorf.

Stylianou, P.J. (2004): One Anabasis or two?, in: R. Lane Fox (ed.), The Long March. Xenophon and the Ten Thousand, New Haven, CT–London: 68–96.

Sulimani, I. (2011): Diodorus Mythistory and the Pagan Mission. Historiography and Culture-Heroes in the First Pentad of the Bibliotheke, Leiden.

Syme, R. (1988): The Cadusii in History and in Fiction, JHS 108: 137–150.

Tarn, W.W. (1927): Persia. From Xerxes to Alexander, CAH VI1: 1–24.

Tuplin, C.J. (2004a): Doctoring the Persians. Ctesias of Cnidus, Physician and Historian, Klio 86: 305–347.

Tuplin, C.J. (2004b): The Persian Empire, in: R. Lane Fox (ed.), The Long March. Xenophon and the Ten Thousand, New Haven, CT–London: 154–183.

Turner, E.G. (1952): Athenian Books in Fifth and Fourth Centuries B.C., London.

Vander Waerdt, P.A. (1993): Socratic Justice and Self-suffi ciency. The Story of the Delphic Oracle in Xenophon’s Apology, OSAPh 11: 1–48.

Waterfi eld, R. (2004): Xenophon’s Socratic Mission, in: C.J. Tuplin (ed.), Xenophon and his World, Stuttgart: 79–114.

Weissbach, F.H. (1922): Kounaxa, RE XI: 2193–2194.

Westlake, H.D. (1987): Diodorus and the Expedition of Cyrus, Phoenix 41: 241–254.

White, D. (1991): Myths of the Dog-man, Chicago.

Whitmarsh, T. (2008): Introduction, in: T. Whitmarsh (ed.), The Greek and Roman Novel, Cambridge: 1–14.

Wiesehofer, J. (2003): The Medes and the Idea of the Succession of Empires in Antiquity, in: G.B. Lanfranchi, M. Roaf, R. Rollinger (eds.), Continuity of Empire (?) Assyria, Media, Persia, Padova: 391–396.

Wiesehofer, J., Lanfranchi, G., Rollinger, R. (eds.) (2011): Die Welt des Ktesias von Knidos, Stuttgart.

Wilson, N.G. (1968): The Composition of Photius’ Bibliotheca, GRBS 9: 451–455.

Wilson, N.G. (1983): Scholars of Byzantium, London.

Wilson, N.G. (ed.) (1994): Photius, The Bibliotheca, London.

Wylie, G. (1992): Cunaxa and Xenophon, AC 61: 119–134.

Ziegler, K. (1951): Plutarchos, Stuttgart.

Information

Information: ELECTRUM, 2012, Volume 19, pp. 9 - 40

Article type: Original article

Published at: 22.01.2013

Article status: Open

Licence: None

Percentage share of authors:

Eran Almagor (Author) - 100%

Article corrections:

-

Publication languages:

English

View count: 2941

Number of downloads: 7153

<p>Ctesias and the Importance of His Writings Revisited</p>

The article is included in the collection

photograph of Crete by Giannis Osep

5 elements