Constitutional Moment and the Polish Constitutional Crisis 2015–2018 (a few Critical Remarks)
cytuj
pobierz pliki
RIS BIB ENDNOTEChoose format
RIS BIB ENDNOTEConstitutional Moment and the Polish Constitutional Crisis 2015–2018 (a few Critical Remarks)
Publication date: 2018
Przegląd Konstytucyjny, 2018, Issue 4 (2018), pp. 76 - 106
Authors
Constitutional Moment and the Polish Constitutional Crisis 2015–2018 (a few Critical Remarks)
In the middle of the Polish constitutional 2015–2018 crisis, references to a ‘constitutional moment’ concept had suddenly and unexpectedly appeared in the Polish public debate. This article aims to confront fundamental conditions and implications of constitutional moment theory with the Polish constitutional framework. Firstly, I will argue that it may be controversial to refer directly to the constitutional moment in an interpretive sense due to the scope of current Polish constitutional regulation and its historical development. Secondly, I will argue that according to the fundamental findings of Bruce Ackerman’s theory its application during the constitutional crisis in Poland is also impossible both in a descriptive as well as interpretive sense. Then, with references to Sujit Choudhry’s interpretation of Ackerman’s ‘higher lawmaking,’ the article will conclude that Poland may have a constitutional moment (in a descriptive sense only) at the end of constitutional crisis and the need to restore the rule of law.
Ackerman B., 2006 Oliver Wendell Holmes Lectures: The Living Constitution, “Harvard Law Review” 2007, Vol. 120.
Ackerman B., Katyal N., Our Unconventional Founding, “University of Chicago Law Review” 1995, Vol. 62/2.
Ackerman B., Revolutionary Constitutions Charismatic Leadership and the Rule of Law, Cambridge (MA) 2019 (forthcoming).
Ackerman B., Rooted Cosmopolitanism (1994), < http://digitalcommons.law.yale.edu/fss_papers/135 >.
Ackerman B., The Rise of World Constitutionalism, “Yale Occasional Papers” 1996, Vol. 4, < http://digitalcommons.law.yale.edu/ylsop_papers/4 >.
Ackerman B., We the People. Vol. 1. Foundations, Cambridge (MA) 1995.
Ackerman B., We the People. Vol. 2. Transformations, Cambridge (MA) 2001.
Ackerman B., We the People. Vol. 3. The Civil Rights Revolution, Cambridge (MA) 2014.
Banaszak B., The Judicial Activism of the Constitutional Tribunal, “The Sejm Review” 2014 (5th special issue).
Bernatt M., Ziółkowski M., Evasion of Constitution as a Mean of Change of Legal System, “Washington International Law Journal” 2019 (forthcoming).
von Bogdandy A., Bogdanowicz P., Canor I., Taborowski M., Schmid M., Guest Editorial: A Potential Constitutional Moment for the European Rule of Law – The Importance of Red Lines, “Common Market Law Review” 2018, Vol. 55/4.
Brzezinski M.F., Garlicki L., Judicial Review in Post-Communist Poland: The Emergence of a Rechtsstaat?, “Stanford Journal of International Law” 1995, Vol. 31.
Chmielarz-Grochal A., Sułkowski J., Appointment of Judges to the Constitutional Tribunal in 2015 as the Trigger Point for a Deep Constitutional Crisis in Poland, “Przegląd Konstytucyjny” 2018, nr 2.
Choudhry S., Ackerman’s Higher Lawmaking in Comparative Constitutional Perspective: Constitutional Moments as Constitutional Failures?, “International Journal of Constitutional Law” 2008, Vol. 6/2.
Chruściak R., The Constitution of the Republic of Poland of 2 April 1997 – The Course of Parliamentary Work from 1995–1997, “Droit Polonais Contemporain Revue Trimestrielle” 1997, Vol. 1–2 (113–116).
Czarnota A., in: The Constitutional Tribunal, “Verfassungsblog” of 3 June 2017, < https://verfassungsblog.de/the-constitutional-tribunal >.
Działocha K., in: Konstytucja Rzeczypospolitej Polskiej. Komentarz. Tom 1, red. L. Garlicki, M. Zubik, Warszawa 2016.
Flirting with Polexit? Poland’s President Wants a Referendum on the EU, “The Economist” of 20 June 2018.
Florczak-Wątor M., in: Konstytucja RP. Tom 1. Komentarz do art. 1–86, red. M. Safjan, L. Bosek, Warszawa 2016.
Florczak-Wątor M., Wiszowaty M.M., Radziewicz P., Ankieta o Konstytucji Rzeczypospolitej Polskiej. Wyniki badań przeprowadzonych wśród przedstawicieli nauki prawa konstytucyjnego w 2017 r., “Państwo i Prawo” 2016, nr 6.
Garlicki L., Die Ausschaltung des Verfassungsgerichtshofes in Polen? (Disabling the Constitutional Court in Poland?), in: Transformation of Law Systems in Central, Eastern and Southeastern Europe in 1989–2015. Liber Amicorum in Honorem Prof. Dr. Dres. H.C. Rainer Arnold, ed. A. Szmyt, B. Banaszak, Gdańsk 2016.
Garlicki L., in: The Role of the Constitution in a Changing Society. Joint Polish- Norwegian Conference (Oslo, 14–16 May 1991), Oslo 1991.
Garlicki L., Normy konstytucyjne relatywnie niezmieniane, in: Charakter i struktura norm konstytucyjnych, red. J. Trzciński, Warszawa 1997.
Gebethner S., The 1997 Referendum on the Constitution in Poland. The Controversies and the Compromise, “Droit Polonais Contemporain Revue Trimestrielle” 1997, Vol. 1–2 (113–116).
Granat M., Rozumienie zmiany Konstytucji RP a tożsamość konstytucyjna, in: Problemy zmiany konstytucji, red. R. Chruściak, Warszawa 2017.
Hermann M., Wronowska S., in: Problematyka intertemporalna w prawie. Zagadnienia podstawowe. Rozstrzygnięcia intertemporalne. Geneza, funkcje, aksjologia, red. J. Mikołajewicz, Warszawa 2015.
Koncewicz T.T., The Capture of the Polish Constitutional Tribunal and Beyond: Of Institution(s), Fidelities and the Rule of Law in Flux, “Review of Central and East European Law” 2018, Vol. 43/2.
Łętowska E., Wiewiórowska-Domagalska A., A ‘Good’ Change in the Polish Constitutional Tribunal?, “Osteuropa Recht” 2016, Vol. 1.
Lis-Staranowicz D., Galster J., Europeanization of Polish Constitutional Law, “The Sejm Review” 2014 (5th special issue).
Matczak M., Why the Announced Constitutional Referendum in Poland is not a Constitutional Referendum after all, “Verfasssungsblog” 2017, Vol. 5/13.
Mazurkiewicz M., The Draft of the Constitution of the Republic of Poland (1996) – Its Political Conditions and Expectations, in: Constitution-making Process, ed. M. Wyrzykowski, Warsaw 1998.
Minister Paweł Mucha in Interview with Krzysztof Losz, “Nasz Dziennik” of 2 January 2018.
Młynarska-Sobaczewska A., Czy to już moment konstytucyjny?, “Dziennik Gazeta Prawna” of 21 December 2017.
Młynarska-Sobaczewska A., Wokół pojęcia momentu konstytucyjnego, in: Dookoła Wojtek… Księga pamiątkowa poświęcona Doktorowi Arturowi Wojciechowi Preisnerowi, red. R. Balicki, M. Jabłoński, Wrocław 2018.
Naleziński B., in: Konstytucja RP. Tom 2. Komentarz do art. 87–243, red. M. Safjan, L. Bosek, Warszawa 2016.
Piasecki A.K., Direct Democracy in Poland after 1989, “The Sejm Review” 2007 (3rd special issue).
Pietrzak M., Demokracja reprezentacyjna i bezpośrednia w Konstytucji Rzeczypospolitej Polskiej, in: Referendum Konstytucyjne w Polsce, red. M.T. Staszewski, Warszawa 1997.
Piotrowski R., w: Preambuła Konstytucji Rzeczypospolitej Polskiej, red. K. Budziło, Warszawa 2009.
Rozmaryn S., Konstytucja jako ustawa zasadnicza PRL, Warszawa 1967.
Roznai Y., Unconstitutional Constitutional Amendments. The Limits of Amendment Power, Oxford 2017.
Sadurski W., How Democracy Dies (in Poland): A Case Study of Anti-Constitutional Populist Backsliding, “Sydney Law School Research Paper” 2018, Vol. 18/1.
Sadurski W., Polish Constitutional Tribunal under PiS: From an Activist Court, to a Paralysed Tribunal, to a Governmental Enable, “Hague Journal on the Rule Law” 2018, < https://doi.org/10.1007/s40803–018–0078–1 >.
Sajó A., Constitution without the Constitutional Moment: A View from the New Member States, “International Journal of Constitutional Law” 2005, Vol. 3/2–3.
Sarnecki P., Central Ideas of the Constitution of the Republic of Poland of 2nd April 1997, “Droit Polonais Contemporain Revue Trimestrielle” 1997, Vol. 1–2 (113–116).
Sieyès J.-E., Czym jest stan trzeci? Esej o przywilejach, tłum. M. Jarosz, Warszawa 2016.
Sokolewicz W., in: Konstytucja Rzeczypospolitej Polskiej. Komentarz. Tom 2, red. L. Garlicki, Warszawa 2001.
Steinbeis M., “Do not Go. Do not Vote”: An Interview with Wojciech Sadurski, “Verfasssungsblog” 2018, Vol. 7/24.
Tuleja P., Szczurowski B., in: Konstytucja RP. Tom 2. Komentarz do art. 87–243, red. M. Safjan, L. Bosek, Warszawa 2016.
Tushnet M., Living in a Constitutional Moment?: Lopez and Constitutional Theory, “Case Western Reserve Law Rewiev” 1996, Vol. 46.
Weil R., Constitutional Statutes or Overriding the Court – On Bruce Ackerman’s We the People: The Civil Rights Revolution, “Jerusalem Review of Legal Studies” 2016, Vol. 13/1.
Wiącek M., in: Konstytucja RP. Tom 2. Komentarz do art. 87–243, red. M. Safjan, L. Bosek, Warszawa 2016.
Winczorek P., The Influence of Constitution-making Procedures on the Development of Constitutional Culture, in: Constitutionals Cultures, ed. M. Wyrzykowski, Warsaw 2000.
Wojtyczek K., The Impact of the Treaty of Lisbon on Poland’s System of Government, “The Sejm Review” 2014 (5th special issue).
Wyrzykowski M., Antigone in Warsaw, in: Human Rights in Contemporary World. Essays in Honour of Professor Leszek Garlicki, ed. M. Zubik, Warsaw 2017.
Wyrzykowski M., Bypassing the Constitution or Changing the Constitutional Order outside the Constitution, in: Transformation of Law Systems in Central, Eastern and Southeastern Europe in 1989–2015. Liber Amicorum in Honorem Prof. Dr. Dres. H.C. Rainer Arnold, ed. A. Szmyt, B. Banaszak, Gdańsk 2016.
Zajadło J., Constitution-hostile Interpretation, “Przegląd Konstytucyjny” 2018, nr 2.
Information: Przegląd Konstytucyjny, 2018, Issue 4 (2018), pp. 76 - 106
Article type: Original article
Titles:
Constitutional Moment and the Polish Constitutional Crisis 2015–2018 (a few Critical Remarks)
Constitutional Moment and the Polish Constitutional Crisis 2015–2018 (a few Critical Remarks)
Kozminski University 57/59 Jagiellońska St., 03-301 Warsaw, POLAND
Published at: 2018
Article status: Open
Licence: None
Percentage share of authors:
Article corrections:
-Publication languages:
EnglishView count: 182
Number of downloads: 144