Dilemmas of authenticity – between permanent ruin and rebuilding
Choose format
RIS BIB ENDNOTEDilemmas of authenticity – between permanent ruin and rebuilding
Publication date: 13.01.2016
Technical Transactions, 2015, Architecture Issue 6-A (9) 2015, pp. 41-57
https://doi.org/10.4467/2353737XCT.15.238.4641Authors
Dilemmas of authenticity – between permanent ruin and rebuilding
The architectural object is a witness of its age. Its form is the result of once existing requirements and fulfilling defined needs. Over time, however, conditioning is changing, repeated destructions and transformations causing that a historic building stops responding to original assumptions. In consequence a need of assigning a new role to monuments appears: a purely museum-like relic or a fully functioning architectural space adapted to modern expectations. It seems that in spite of functioning regulations, undertakings effected in the last decades depict a different level of taking a stance on the authenticity residing in a historic structure. Perhaps there is a need to take another look at the model of conservator’s action adequate for redefining the position in view of the protection of historic values, withthe possibility of considering additional decisions, towards specific objects and circumstances.
[1] D. Chlebowska, Trwała ruina w Polsce koniecznym świadkiem historycznego krajobrazu, Wiadomości Konserwatorskie, No. 16/2004.
[2] Jasieńko J., Mierzejewska O., Hamrol K., Misztal W., Utrwalanie koron murów obiektów historycznych przeznaczonych do ekspozycji w formie trwałej ruiny, [in:] Wiadomości Konserwatorskie, No. 30/2011, 121–132.
[3] Łuszczkiewicz W., Zamek Lipowiec i jego turma, [in:] Sprawozdania Komisyi do Badania Historyi Sztuki w Polsce, v. III, 1884.
[4] Malawska I., Zamki w Polsce – problem określenia zasobu, Ochrona Zabytków 4/2007, Warszawa 2007, 83–86.
[5] Mojżyn N., Konserwacja i rekonstrukcja zabytków w świadomości studentów Teologii UKSW, [in:] Fides et ratio, Scientific quarterly of the university society Fides et Ratio, No. 3 (11), 2012, 137–138.
[6] Ochrona, konserwacja i adaptacja zabytkowych murów. Trwała Ruina II. Problemy utrzymania i adaptacji, ed. B. Szmygin, Lublin–Warszawa 2010.
[7] Żurawski J., Zamek w Janowcu nad Wisłą. Budowa-rozbudowa-ruina. Konserwacjarewaloryzacja-zagospodarowanie, Ochrona Zabytków 1-2/2003, Warszawa 2003.
Information: Technical Transactions, 2015, Architecture Issue 6-A (9) 2015, pp. 41-57
Article type: Original article
Titles:
Dilemmas of authenticity – between permanent ruin and rebuilding
Dilemmas of authenticity – between permanent ruin and rebuilding
Institute of History of Architecture and Monument Preservation, Faculty of Architecture, Cracow University of Technology
Published at: 13.01.2016
Article status: Open
Licence: CC BY
Percentage share of authors:
Article corrections:
-Publication languages:
EnglishView count: 1545
Number of downloads: 1738