1733-5760 The Titulus Tiburtinus, Syme’s Piso, Sentius Saturninus and the Province of Syria Kokkinos Nikos author Correspondence to: Nikos Kokkinos 21 01 2013 Volume 10 2012 37 69 Copyright © 2013 2013 <p>A previous paper on the titulus Tiburtinus re-opened the debate concerning the notorious ignotus, then generally thought to be P. Sulpicius Quirinius (cos. 12 BC), suggesting instead that he might be identified with C. Sentius Saturninus (cos. 19 BC). This suggestion was subsequently challenged in favour of L. Calpurnius Piso (cos. 15 BC), who had originally been argued by Sir Ronald Syme. Since the identification of the consular concerned is significant for Augustan prosopography and for the history of Asia, among other provinces such as Syria and Germany, a detailed and wide-ranging restatement of the case for Saturninus is made here. Piso (unlike Quirinius) is really a non-starter, and it is surprising that he would have been supported by formidable Syme. The rex of the titulus could not have been Rhescuporis I or Rhoemetalces I. The iterum would not have referred to the second legateship of Piso (presumably that of Syria) given Piso’s early career. The binas, referring to two public thanksgivings, does not inspire confidence in Piso receiving a second supplicatio. Piso the Pontifex is not attested as proconsul of Asia, nor is he attested as governor of Syria, and the reconstruction of the fasti of this province is much more reasonable than previously thought. By contrast, all points in Saturninus career can be successfully compared with the information in the titulus. Origins of the Sentii from an area near Tibur is a bonus, if dispensable. Saturninus could not have been proconsul of Africa at the time inferred from Tertullian (29 BC), and hence Asia is open for him in c. 14/13 BC. His office in Syria (c. 12–8 BC) is well-attested, as it is that in Germany (c. AD 3–6). He was awarded ornamenta triumphalia in the company of Tiberius, after ‘two’ victories and no doubt supplicationes binas. Finally, a flexible understanding of the word iterum can accommodate also the meanings ‘for another time’ and ‘twice’, either of which can work with the career of Saturninus. As for deprived Quirinius, among various problems, no two thanksgivings can be conceived for a war such as that of the Homonadenses, and, most condemningly, a reference to his important office under Gaius will never have been omitted in the titulus.</p> 1 Atkinson, K.M.T. (1958): The Governors of the Province Asia in the Reign of Augustus, Historia 7: 300–330. 2 Barnes, T.D. (1974): The Victories of Augustus, JRS 64: 21–26. 3 Benoit, P. (1977): ‘(Recensement de) Quirinius’, in: H. Cazelles, A. Feuillet (eds.), Supplément au Dictionnaire de la Bible, vol. 9, Paris: 693–720. 4 Bickerman, E.J. (1947): Syria and Cilicia, AJP 68: 353–362. 5 Bowersock, G.W. (1964): C. Marcius Censorinus, legatus Caesaris, HSCP 68: 207–210. 6 Bowersock, G.W. (1965): Augustus and the Greek World, Oxford. 7 Bradley, K.R. (1978): Suetonius’ Life of Nero: An Historical Commentary, Brussels. 8 Braund, D.C. (1984): Rome and the Friendly King. The Character of Client Kingship, London–Canberra–New York. 9 Braund, D.C. (1985): Augustus to Nero: A Sourcebook on Roman History: 31 BC – AD 68, London–Sydney. 10 Brunt, P.A. (1974): C. Fabricius Tuscus and an Augustan dilectus, ZPE 13: 161–185. 11 Cagnat, R. et al. (1923): Inscriptions Latines d’Afrique, Paris. 12 Castritius, H. (1971): Ein bisher unbekannter Statthalter Kilikiens?, Historia 20: 80–83. 13 Cichorius, C. (1922): Römische Studien. Historisches, Epigraphisches, Literaturgeschichtliches aus vier Jahrhunderten Roms, Berlin. 14 Dagron, G., Feissel, D. (1987): Inscriptions de Cilicie, Paris. 15 Desanges, J. (1969): Un drame africain sous Auguste: Le meurtre du proconsul L. Cornelius Lentulus par les Nasamons, in: J. Bibauw (ed.), Hommages à Marcel Renard, vol. 2, Bruxelles: 197–213. 16 Desideri, P. (1991): Strabo’s Cilicians, in: J. Courtils et al. (eds.), De Anatolia Antiqua 1, Paris: 299–304. 17 Dessau, H. (1930): Geschichte der Römischen Kaiserzeit, vol. 2, Berlin. 18 Dobiáš, J. (1960): King Maroboduus as a Politician, Klio 38: 155–166. 19 Dorbarakes, Ch. (1974): Epitomon Lexikon tēs Archaias Hel ēnikēs Glōssēs, Athens. 20 Dupont-Sommer, A., Robert, L. (1964): La Déesse de Hiérapolis Castabala (Cilicie), Paris. 21 Eck, W. (1987): Senatorische Amtsträger und Rätien unter Augustus, ZPE 70: 203–209. 22 Eilers, C. (1996): C. Sentius Saturninus, Piso Pontifex, and the Titulus Tiburtinus: A Reply, ZPE 110: 207–226. 23 Firpo, G. (1983): Il problema cronologico del a nascita di Gesù, Brescia. 24 Gaggiotti, M. (1978): Le iscrizioni del a basilica di Saepinum e i rectores del a provincia del Samnium, Athenaeum 56: 145–169. 25 Gordon, A.E. (1952): Quintus Veranius Consul A.D. 49: a Study based upon his recently identified sepulchral Inscription, University of  26 California Publications in Classical Archaeology 2: 231–341. 27 Gordon, A.E. (1954): Potitus Valerius Messal a Consul Suffect 29 B.C., University of California Publications in Classical Archaeology 3: 31–64. 28 Gordon, A.E. (1958): Album of Dated Latin Inscriptions, vol. 1, Berkeley–Los Angeles. 29 Gow, A.S., Page, D.L. (eds.) (1968): The Greek Anthology: The Garland of Philip, 2 vols., Cambridge. 30 Groag, E. (1922/24): Prosopographische Beiträge: VII. M. Plautius Silvanus, JOEAI 21/2 (1922/4), Beibl.: 425–478. 31 Gwatkin, W.E. (1930): Cappadocia as a Roman Procuratorial Province, Columbia, MO–Princeton, NJ. 32 Habicht, Ch. (1969): Die Inschriften des Asklepieion (Altertümer von Pergamon 8.3), Berlin. 33 Head, B.V. (1911): Historia Numorum, 2nd ed., Oxford. 34 Herrmann, P. (1960): Die Inschriften römischer Zeit aus dem Heraion von Samos, MDAI (Ath. Abt.) 75: 68–183. 35 Herz, P. (1980): Der Aufbruch des Gaius Caesar in den Osten, ZPE 39: 285–290. 36 Hild, F., Hellenkemper, H. (1990): Kilikien und Isaurien (Tabula Imperii Byzantini 5.1), Wien. 37 Hoehner, H.W. (1972): Herod Antipas, Cambridge. 38 Hoffman, M.W. (1952): The College of Quindecimviri (Sacris Faciundis) in 17 B.C., AJP 73: 289–294. 39 Honigmann, E. (1950): Neronias-Irenopolis in Eastern Cilicia’, Byzantion 20: 39–61. 40 Jones, A.H.M. (1940): The Greek City from Alexander to Justinian, Oxford. 41 Jones, A.H.M. (1971): The Cities of the Eastern Roman Provinces (2nd ed.), Oxford. 42 Kajava, M. (1990): Roman Senatorial Women and the Greek East: Epigraphic Evidence from the Republican and Augustan Period, in: H. Solin, M. Kajava (eds.), Roman Eastern Policy and Other Studies in Roman History. Proceedings of a Col oquium at Tvärminne, 2–3 October 1987, Helsinki: 59–124. 43 Kokkinos, N. (1993/1998): The Herodian Dynasty: Origins, Role in Society and Eclipse, Sheffield (= Ph.D. thesis Oxon 1993). 44 Kokkinos, N. (1995): The Honorand of the Titulus Tiburtinus: C. Sentius Saturninus?, ZPE 105: 21–36. 45 Kokkinos, N. (2013): Aspects of Jerusalem under Herod, Eretz-Israel 31: forthcoming. 46 Kushnir-Stein, A. (1995): Another Look at Josephus’ Evidence for the Date of Herod’s Death, SCI 14: 73–86. 47 Levick, B. (1967): Roman Colonies in Southern Asia Minor, Oxford. 48 Magie, D. (1950): Roman Rule in Asia Minor to the End of the 3rd Century after Christ, 2 vols., Princeton, NJ. 49 Maricq, A. (1958): Res Gestae Divi Saporis, Syria 35: 245–360. 50 Maxfield, V.A. (1981): The Military Decorations of the Roman Army, London. 51 Mil ar, F. (1993): The Roman Near East, 31 BC – AD 337, Cambridge, MA–London. 52 Mitchel , S. (1993): Anatolia: Land, Men and Gods in Asia Minor, vol. 1, Oxford. 53 Paltiel, E. (1981): War in Judaea – after Herod’s Death, RBPh 59/60: 107–136. 54 Pitts, L.F. (1989): Relations between Rome and the German ‘Kings’ on the Middle Danube in the First to Fourth Centuries A.D., JRS 79: 45–58. 55 Pucci Ben Zeev, M. (1994): Greek and Roman Documents from the Republican Times in the Antiquities: What Was Josephus’ Source?, SCI 13: 46–59. 56 Rey-Coquais, J.-P. (1978): Syrie Romaine, de Pompée à Dioclétien, JRS 68: 44–73. 57 Romer, F.E. (1978): A Numismatic Date for the Departure of C. Caesar?, TAPA 108: 187–202. 58 Romer, F.E. (1979): Gaius Caesar’s Military Diplomacy in the East, TAPA 109: 199–214. 59 Salomies, O. (1993): Römische Amtsträger und Römisches Bürgerrecht in der Kaiserzeit: Die Aussagekraft der Onomastik (unter besonderer Berücksichtigung der kleinasiatischen Provinzen), in: W. Eck (ed.), Prosopographie und Sozialgeschichte. Studien zur Methodik und Erkenntnismöglichkeit der kaiserzeitlichen Prosopographie, Kol oquium Köln 24. – 26. November 1991, Köln–Wien–Wei-mar: 119–145. 60 Schalit, A. (1968): Namenwörterbuch zu Flavius Josephus, Leiden. 61 Scheid, J. (1975): Les Frères Arvales. Recrutement et origine sociale sous les empreurs julio-claudiens, Paris. 62 Schumacher, L. (1985): Die imperatorischen Akklamationen der Triumvirn und die auspicia des Augustus, Historia 34: 191–222. 63 Schürer, E. (1973): The History of the Jewish People in the Age of Jesus Christ, vol. 1 (rev. by F. Mil ar and G. Vermes), Edinburgh. 64 Sherk, R.K. (1980): Roman Galatia: The Governors from 25 B.C. to A.D. 114, ANRW II.7.2: 954–1054. 65 Strauss, D.F. (1865): Die Halben und die Ganzen, Berlin. 66 Sullivan, R.D. (1979): Thrace in the Eastern Dynastic Network, ANRW II.7.1: 186–211. 67 Sullivan, R.D. (1990): Near Eastern Royalty and Rome, 100–30 B.C., Toronto, Ont. 68 Syme, R. (1934a): Lentulus and the Origin of Moesia, JRS 24: 113–137. 69 Syme, R. (1934b): Galatia and Pamphylia under Augustus: the Governorships of Piso, Quirinius and Silvanus, Klio 27: 122–148. 70 Syme, R. (1939a): The Roman Revolution, Oxford. 71 Syme, R. (1939b): Observations on the Province of Cilicia, in: W.M. Calder, J. Keil (eds.), Anatolian Studies Presented to Wil iam  72 Hepburn Buckler, 299–332 (= Syme 1979a: 120–148). 73 Syme, R. (1955): Review: Gordon 1954, JRS 45: 155–160. 74 Syme, R. (1960): Piso Frugi and Crassus Frugi, JRS 50: 12–20. 75 Syme, R. (1964a): Senators, Tribes and Towns, Historia 13: 105–125 (= Syme 1979a: 582–604). 76 Syme, R. (1964b): The Stemma of the Sentii Saturnini, Historia 12: 156–166 (= Syme 1979a: 605–616). 77 Syme, R. (1970): Some Pisones in Tacitus, in: R. Syme, Ten Studies in Tacitus, Oxford. 78 Syme, R. (1971a): Danubian Papers, Bucarest. 79 Syme, R. (1971b): M. Vinicius (cos. 19 BC), in: Syme 1971: 35 (addendum). 80 Syme, R. (1973): The Titulus Tiburtinus, in: Akten des VI. Internationalen Kongresses für Griechi sche und Lateinische Epigraphik, München 1972 (Vestigia 17), München: 585–601 (= Syme 1984: 869–884). 81 Syme, R. (1979a), Roman Papers, vol. I–II, ed. by E. Badian, Oxford. 82 Syme, R. (1979b): Some Imperatorial Salutations, Phoenix 33: 308–329. 83 Syme, R. (1980): The Sons of Piso the Pontifex, AJP 101: 333–341. 84 Syme, R. (1981): Governors Dying in Syria, ZPE 41: 125–144. 85 Syme, R. (1984): Roman Papers, vol. III, ed. by A.R. Birley, Oxford. 86 Syme, R. (1986): The Augustan Aristocracy, Oxford. 87 Syme, R. (1995): Anatolica. Studies in Strabo, ed. by A.R. Birley, Oxford. 88 Tataki, A. (1988): Ancient Beroea: Prosopography and Society, Athens. 89 Taeuber, H. (1991): Die syrisch-kilikische Grenze während der Prinzipatszeit, Tyche 6: 201–210. 90 Taylor, L.R. (1933): Quirinius and the Census of Judaea, AJP 54: 129–133. 91 Taylor, L.R. (1939): M. Titius and the Syrian Command, JRS 26: 161–173. 92 Taylor, L.R. (1960): The Voting Districts of the Roman Republic, Rome. 93 Thomas, J. (1900): Our Records of the Nativity and Modern Historical Research, London. 94 Thomasson, B.E. (1984): Laterculi Praesidum, vol. 1, Göteborg. 95 Timpe, D. (1970): Arminius-Studien, Heidelberg. 96 Vitucci, G. (1947): Note al ‘Cursus Honorum’ di M. Iulius Romulus, praefectus frumenti dandi ex S.C., RFC 25: 252–253. 97 Wilkes, J.J. (1969): Dalmatia, London. 98 Wiseman, T.P. (1971): New Men in the Roman Senate, 139 B.C.–A.D. 14, Oxford. 99 Woodman, A.J. (1977): Vel eius Paterculus: The Tiberian Narrative (2.94–131), Cambridge. 100 Zumpt, A.W. (1869): Das Geburtsjahr Christi, Leipzig.