2391-7997
Returning the Gods to the People: Heritage Restitution in Nepal
Selter
Elke
author
British Institute of International and Comparative Law
Correspondence to: Elke Selter e.selter@biicl.org
16
12
2022
2/2022 (8)
2022
115
134
Copyright © 2022
2022
<p>Since late 2021, a new development has been taking place in Nepal. Like many governments around the world, the Nepalese authorities are also fully invested in asking for the return of their looted art held in foreign collections. Yet the policy is no longer to keep these in the country’s main museums, but rather to bring them back to the communities of origin, where they can fully take up their role as “living Gods”. With this move – which fully prioritizes intangible heritage values over tangible – a unique process is taking place that allows for reflection on what the restitution of stolen objects could be all about. In this way the case of Nepal demonstrates that the trafficking of art and its placement in museums abroad, as well as its “typical” return to museums in the source countries, are strongly influenced by Western concepts of art and conservation, often ignoring the local values of this heritage.</p>
[
Ancient Monuments Preservation Act, 2013 (1956), Nepal Gazette, 27 July 2013, https://nepaltradeportal.gov.np/resources/docs/ancient-monument-preservation-act-2013-1956.pdf [accessed: 21.07.2022].
]
[
Bangdel L.S., Stolen Images of Nepal, Royal Nepal Academy, Kathmandu 1989.
]
[
Dhakal A., Laxmi-Narayan Is Home, “Nepali Times”, 4 December 2021, https://www.nepalitimes.com/banner/laxmi-narayan-is-home/ [accessed: 30.05.2022].
]
[
Dhakal A., The Enigma of Arrival of Nepal’s Gods, “Nepali Times”, 2 December 2021, https://www.nepalitimes.com/banner/the-enigma-of-arrival-of-nepals-gods/ [accessed: 31.05.2022]
]
[
Dixit K.M., Gods in Exile, “Himal Southasian”, 1 October 1999, https://www.himalmag.com/gods-in-exile/ [accessed: 30.05.2022].
]
[
Le Népal réclame au Musée Guimet le retour de deux statues, “Le Journal des Arts”, 23 April 2014, https://www.lejournaldesarts.fr/le-nepal-reclame-au-musee-guimet-le-retour-de-deux-statues-121620 [accessed: 29.05.2022].
]
[
Meskell L., A Future in Ruins: UNESCO, World Heritage, and the Dream of Peace, Oxford University Press, Oxford 2018.
]
[
National Cultural Policy 2067, 13 July 2010, https://www.tourism.gov.np/files/publication_files/31_1503553165.pdf [accessed: 21.07.2022].
]
[
NHRC, Press Release: Laxmi-Narayan’s Return to Patko Tole, Patan, 4 December 2021, https://nepalheritagerecoverycampaign.org/news/press-release-laxmi-narayans-return-to-patko-tole-patan/ [accessed: 30.05.2022].
]
[
Rai B., Back Where They Belong, “Nepali Times”, December 2013, http://archive.nepalitimes.com/article/nation/Nepal-needs-to-be-prepared-for-the-return-of-stolen-religious-figures,986 [accessed: 29.05.2022].
]
[
Schick J., The Gods Are Leaving the Country: Art Theft from Nepal, rev. Eng. ed., Orchid Press, Bangkok 1998.
]
[
Sijapati A., Nepal’s Gods Return from Exile, NHRC, 28 January 2021, https://nepalheritagerecoverycampaign.org/news/nepals-gods-return-from-exile/ [accessed: 30.05.2022].
]
[
Small Z., Citizen Activists Lead the Hunt for Antiquities Looted from Nepal, “The New York Times”, 29 October 2021.
]
[
Spice M., Piece by Piece, Pillaged Art Is Sent Home to Nepal, “The Guardian”, 6 September 2000, https://www.theguardian.com/world/2000/sep/06/nepal [accessed: 31.05.2022].
]
[
Spice M., The Valley Where the Gods Have Vanished (Book Review of “The Gods Are Leaving The Country: Art Theft from Nepal” by J. Schick), “South China Morning Post”, 3 September 2000, http://d30021575.purehost.com/book_reviews/gods_leave_scmp.html [accessed: 04.04.2022].
]
[
The Ancient Monuments Preservation Act, 1904, 18 March 1904, https://www.indiacode.nic.in/handle/123456789/2339?sam_handle=123456789/1362 [accessed: 21.07.2022].
]
[
Thompson E.L., Returned to Nepal by the FBI, a Sculpture Becomes a God Again, “Hyperallergic”, 17 December 2021, http://hyperallergic.com/700760/returned-to-nepal-by-the-fbi-a-sculpture-becomes-a-god-again/ [accessed: 31.05.2022].
]
[
Tuladhar S., Return of the Gods, “Nepali Times”, August 2000, https://archive.nepalitimes.com/news.php?id=11342#.YkqqerjRZpQ [accessed: 31.05.2022].
]
[
Tythacott L., Arvanitis K. (eds.), Museums and Restitution. New Practices, New Approaches, Ashgate, Farnham 2014.
]
[
Villa A., Albers Foundation to Launch New Museum in Senegal Aimed at Housing Restituted Artifacts, “ARTnews”, 16 May 2022, https://www.artnews.com/art-news/news/albers-foundation-launch-new-museum-senegal-restitution-1234628808/ [accessed: 01.06.2022].
]
[
Wijesuriya G., Living Heritage, in: A. Heritage, J. Copithorne (eds.), Sharing Conservation Decisions: Current Issues and Future Strategies, ICCROM, Rome 2018.
]