FAQ
T_LOGIN Log in

Don't have an account on our website?

T_REGISTER Register

Volume 15 (2024)/2

Body Under Threat. Body in History and History of Art

2024 Next

Publication date: 30.12.2024

Description
Publication financed by Memling Research Center at the University of Gdańsk, and Dean of The Faculty of History of the University of Gdańsk.

Cover and Title Pages Design: Andrzej Taranek.

Cover Illustration: Jan Rutka, 2023.

Licence: None

Editorial team

Editor-in-Chief Tadeusz Stegner

Secretary Piotr Perkowski

Editors Grzegorz Berendt, Piotr Derengowski, Aleksandra Girsztowt-Biskup, Iwona Janicka, Barbara Klassa, Michał Kosznicki, Sławomir Kościelak, Rafał Kubicki, Anna Łysiak‑Łątkowska, Tomasz Maćkowski, Anna Mazurkiewicz, Julia Możdżeń, Beata Możejko, Anna Paner, Tomasz Rembalski, Przemysław Różański

Issue editors Piotr Derengowski, Beata Możejko

Issue content

Atricles

Maria Starnawska

Studia Historica Gedanensia, Volume 15 (2024)/2, 2024, pp. 13-26

https://doi.org/10.4467/23916001HG.24.019.20446
The two medieval patron saints of Poland, St. Adalbert and St. Stanislaus, both suffered martyrdom. The tradition of the life and the martyrdom of St. Adalbert developed from the end of the tenth century until the late Middle Ages. On the contrary, the tradition of St. Stanislaus’s martyrdom arose at the turn of the twelfth and thirteenth centuries and had a fully developed form. Information about the details of the martyrdom of both saints are contained in various types of sources: hagiographical, historical and liturgical poetry. In the accounts of martyrdom there are mentions of gestures made by three subjects: the martyr, the killers and God. As a result of these acts, the body is martyred and destroyed, but the soul of the martyr is glorified. Numerous marks on the martyr’s body visible during martyrdom confirm the glory achieved by his soul.
Read more Next

Karolina Białas

Studia Historica Gedanensia, Volume 15 (2024)/2, 2024, pp. 27-54

https://doi.org/10.4467/23916001HG.24.020.20447

The purpose of this paper is to characterise the meaning of the sense of touch for medieval monastic culture from the tenth to the twelfth century using selected sources created at the Cluny abbey as example in comparison to other monastic sources. The paper discusses methodological approaches to the study of the history of the senses. Then, the issues of the sense of touch in Christian theology are described based on the analysis of moralistic and exegetical works created in Cluny Abbey. Examples of the association of touch with particular sins are also indicated, taking into account the temporal context, in which the sources were created (including treatises, poems, sermons and hagiography). Finally, the meaning and function of touch in the daily life of a medieval monastery is described, using the content of Cluniac consuetudines from the eleventh century. The papers concludes with a summary containing reflections on the sensual type of monastic culture and what may have been the basis for the authors bias against the sense of touch.

Read more Next

Mattie van den Bosch

Studia Historica Gedanensia, Volume 15 (2024)/2, 2024, pp. 55-79

https://doi.org/10.4467/23916001HG.24.021.20448

Something we have known since the beginning of mankind is the act of bathing. It is used to clean not only the body, but also the soul. Water has a high ritual function, especially within Christianity. The two main bathing women of the Old Testament are Susanna and Bathsheba. Whereas for some the act of bathing is a small part of their story, for Susanna and Bathsheba it is the most important event of their narratives.

These women have been the topic of many discussions within the theological and art. historical field. Susanna, seen as the perfect example of a pious woman, has been praised during the entire period of the Middle ages, while Bathsheba has often been characterised as seductive, or possibly sexual. However, when looking at the way the two women are depicted in the late Middle Ages, we see both ladies illustrated in almost the exact same manner. Why would two women who are interpreted so differently, be portrayed the same way?

Read more Next

Huib Iserief

Studia Historica Gedanensia, Volume 15 (2024)/2, 2024, pp. 81-95

https://doi.org/10.4467/23916001HG.24.022.20449
Miniatures depicting the Wounds of Christ figure in many medieval manuscripts. These fascinating images look weird and alienating, without the body they were inflicted on. They also invoke the feeling we are looking at something scabrous because of their similarity to a vulva. It is uncomfortable: these miniatures depict a sacred matter, the Wounds of Christ. There shouldn’t be an association with something vulgar. Is this strange resemblance maybe a product of a dirty mind. The article attempts to answer the question: How should one approach depictions of the Wounds of Christ in medieval art? Are such depictions sacred, or scandalous?
Read more Next

Wendelien A.W. van Welie-Vink

Studia Historica Gedanensia, Volume 15 (2024)/2, 2024, pp. 96-114

https://doi.org/10.4467/23916001HG.24.023.20450
Miniatures depicting the Wounds of Christ figure in many medieval manuscripts. These fascinating images look weird and alienating, without the body they were inflicted on. They also invoke the feeling we are looking at something scabrous because of their similarity to a vulva. It is uncomfortable: these miniatures depict a sacred matter, the Wounds of Christ. There shouldn’t be an association with something vulgar. Is this strange resemblance maybe a product of a dirty mind. The article attempts to answer the question: How should one approach depictions of the Wounds of Christ in medieval art? Are such depictions sacred, or scandalous?
Read more Next

Agata Jakóbowska

Studia Historica Gedanensia, Volume 15 (2024)/2, 2024, pp. 115-134

https://doi.org/10.4467/23916001HG.24.024.20451

The theme of this article focuses on a specific group of visual artworks created during the late Middle Ages. This group is characterised by the use of the Adoration of the Three Kings iconography, with the key aspect of the composition being the act of gazing at the genitals of the Infant Jesus. The article has reviewed the medieval cultural and theological model of thinking about the naked body of the child as both sexless and male. The origins of Christian views on the biological nature of man can be traced back to Hebrew and ancient culture and the concept of Logos. The relationship between creation, male sexuality, and the ideal of physical perfection was vividly taken up by medieval theologians, and also reflected in fine art works. The formation of the iconography of representations of the Adoration and the understanding of how secular rulers and representatives of the clergy were viewed is also an important theme. The group of depictions in question seems to serve to explain the origins of power and to indicate moral standards. The use of the depiction of the naked body of the Child to demonstrate the genesis of earthly, secular, and clerical authority was specific to the late Middle Ages.

Read more Next

Kalina Słaboszowska

Studia Historica Gedanensia, Volume 15 (2024)/2, 2024, pp. 135-148

https://doi.org/10.4467/23916001HG.24.025.20452

The article discusses the intersection between emotions and physical health in the narration of the Annales seu cronicae incliti regni Poloniae by Jan Długosz (14151480). The research is placed within the framework of the history of emotions, a field aimed at determining how people in the past used to perceive and experience emotions. Its main scope is to find out how emotions can influence the body and health according to the medieval author. The descriptions of illnesses and deaths caused by the influence of emotions are analysed both from the point of view of the medieval medicine and approach to emotions as well as contemporary concepts of psychosomatics and Susan Sontags approach.

Read more Next

Andrzej Woziński

Studia Historica Gedanensia, Volume 15 (2024)/2, 2024, pp. 149-169

https://doi.org/10.4467/23916001HG.24.026.20453
The en grisaille convention appeared in painting at the beginning of the fourteenth century in Italy, although it was already known in Antiquity – for instance, it is mentioned by Pliny the Elder, who calls it “monochromata.” It was quickly adopted by the French painters, especially illuminators. In the early fifteenth century, Dutch artists began to use it as well to decorate the closed wings of altarpieces with images imitating stone carvings. Monochrome was also used by Hans Memling, who introduced several innovations to this technique. There are several variants of monochrome in his works; though it should also be noted that he did not always use it. In almost all of his works, Memling gave the figures painted en grisaille an ambiguous character. They combine in varying proportions the qualities of living, corporeal beings and at the same time the qualities of a stone sculpture. They are also materially different from the accompanying lay persons and various accessories painted in multicolour. The reverses are fundamentally different from the open versions of the retables, where the scale and intensity of colour is incomparably richer; moreover, they are shallower in space and more modestly arranged. One of the most salient features of retables with movable wings is the transformation that takes place in the process of opening them. In Memling’s work, it has several stages: it begins with the closed wings, where, by means of illusion, the stone is transformed into a figure and the sculpture into a painting; it is then followed by a further, more radical stage after the opening of the wings: sacred reality appears in its full material and colour dimension, close to, but not identical to, the empirical world. The transformations of form, colour, and conventions that occur in Memling’s retables cannot be explained by purely liturgical considerations; such may have come into play in the large retables from Gdańsk and Lübeck intended to furnish chapels, while the small triptychs served private devotions and very possibly functioned in secular spaces. What is certain is that Memling’s monochrome images have an indeterminate status both in terms of their materiality – they are neither stone nor living being – and in terms of their genre – they are neither an imitation of a sculpture nor a painting, or in other words: they are at once stone and living beings, imitation sculpture and direct painting. This precarious state of the permanent intermingling of matter and means of expression made it all the more inviting to open the wings in order to find there – in the open retable – the solution to the riddle posed by the images outside.
Read more Next

Zofia Wilk-Woś

Studia Historica Gedanensia, Volume 15 (2024)/2, 2024, pp. 170-181

https://doi.org/10.4467/23916001HG.24.026.20454
The role of the archbishops of Gniezno for the state encourages research on various aspects of their lives and activities. It is therefore worth trying to look at their physical condition and state of health. The primary source of observation for this is the works of Jan Długosz.
Information about the health of the archbishops is very sparse, but falling off a horse, stroke and dropsy are known causes of their death. The hierarchs’ health was probably affected by their age and public activity, and could have limited their mobility.
Read more Next

Sylwia Konarska-Zimnicka

Studia Historica Gedanensia, Volume 15 (2024)/2, 2024, pp. 182-196

https://doi.org/10.4467/23916001HG.24.027.20455

Healthcare has always been one of the key elements of human existence. The issue of the prevention of diseases and all kinds of ailments was taken up by scholars who represented various disciplines. Iatromathematics, combining medicine and astrology, offered excellent possibilities. The interpretation of this knowledge can be found in various astrological treatises, notes, calendars and prognostics, or strictly iatromathematical works. It is in these works that the manner and scale of the influence of the elements of the lunar world on man in the context of his health and illness are described. It is also here that a description of a rich array of diseases and ailments that affected the human body can be found. This gives us the possibility to deduce what type of diseases they were, but also how frequently they occurred. All this is placed in the context of the parallels between the macroand the microcosm.

Read more Next

Agnieszka Szwach, Beata Wojciechowska

Studia Historica Gedanensia, Volume 15 (2024)/2, 2024, pp. 197-204

https://doi.org/10.4467/23916001HG.24.028.20456

The following article presents how in the sixteenth century England, thanks to the increased awarness of the problems with mental disorders, the stories of madness entered the world of Renaissance drama and appeared in the works of numerous writers. As early modern culture and literature made attempts to understand female melancholy or insanity, particular focus is given to the characters of Ophelia in Shakespeares Hamlet and the Duchess in John Websters The Duchess of Malfi. The thorough analysis of the texts shows that contrary to the then common belief that all womens illness and irrationality derived from the womb, those were, too a great degree, social constraints which affected women and pushed them into insanity. Oppressive, male dominant and chaotic socjety either pushed women into a state of complete madness, which subsequently results in death or it is the madness, confusion and chaos around them that was the cause of their death.

Read more Next

Dariusz Kaczor

Studia Historica Gedanensia, Volume 15 (2024)/2, 2024, pp. 205-223

https://doi.org/10.4467/23916001HG.24.029.20457

The paper explores the issue of physical injuries resulting from interpersonal conflicts, in particular arguments, disputes, ordinary brawls and deliberate acts of physical violence occurring in the lower and middle classes in urban settings, based on the example of Gdańsk at the end of the 16th century and in the first half of the 17th century. This is based on the records of physical examination reports drawn up by the citys barbersurgeons on behalf of the municipal authorities for law enforcement purposes, subsequently appended to the burgraves and deputy mayors registers. In total, more than 18,000 such documents dated between 1580 and 1642 have survived. This enables an analysis of the subject at hand on a icrohistorical scale, as well as employing a statistical (quantitative) approach. The paper considers undamental issues pertaining to the nature and extent of injuries, common injury types, lasting damage, as well as questions regarding injuries, the origin and cause of which fall between physical and symbolic violence this concerns aggressive demonstrative behaviour, marks of shame and others.

Read more Next

Aleksandra Jaśniewicz-Downes

Studia Historica Gedanensia, Volume 15 (2024)/2, 2024, pp. 224-256

https://doi.org/10.4467/23916001HG.24.030.20458

In the years 16851687 Gottfried Dreyer from Gdańsk stayed in Batavia (Jakarta) as a soldier in the service of the Dutch East India Company. Back in his native city, Dreyer wrote down memories of his travels. His description of Batavia in the travelogue written in 1706 is opened by an account of public executions of native men guilty of running amok. The analysis of this fragment of the journal will provide insight into the authors mentality: his perception of public executions, as well as criminal and legitimate violence, his attitude towards the colonial authorities and the indigenous inhabitants of Java. Gottfried Dreyers detailed recount of the Batavian spectacle of power and accompanying drawings are shedding light on the details of the proceedings. Moreover, Dreyer recalled beliefs of the Javanese which were underpinning their understanding of the punishment. The text gives a distinctive insight into the workings of the judicial system in Batavia and includes information previously not discussed in the literature on penal practices in seventeenthcentury Java.

Read more Next

Marcin Baranowski

Studia Historica Gedanensia, Volume 15 (2024)/2, 2024, pp. 257-264

https://doi.org/10.4467/23916001HG.24.031.20459
The text sketches various aspects of a soldier’s life in the Napoleonic era. The issues focus on matters related to the body, such as illness, wounds, their treatment, matters of nutrition and stimulants. The source basis is primarily Polish narrative sources, less well known to the Western historiography.
Read more Next

Piotr Derengowski

Studia Historica Gedanensia, Volume 15 (2024)/2, 2024, pp. 265-276

https://doi.org/10.4467/23916001HG.24.032.20460

Both armies and the soldiers serving in them have, since the earliest times, functioned according to army regulations and military law. The primary purpose of such regulations has been to ensure effective army management. One of the sine qua non conditions was the maintenance of iron discipline and unconditional obedience of subordinates to their superiors. Any actions that threatened this principle were seen as detrimental to the army. Hence, it is not surprising that in practically all such situations, soldiers who committed rulebreaking offences were brought before courts martial, tried and, if found guilty, convicted and punished according to the offence/crime committed. This article will Focus primarily on the various types of corporal and dishonourable punishments that were applied to soldiers during the American Civil War (18611865), most of which, from todays perspective, would be seen as torture. This issue will be presented on the basis of contemporary army regulations and the proceedings of general courtsmartial, thus showing both the theoretical and practical side of the issue hand.

Read more Next

Katarzyna Szmigiero

Studia Historica Gedanensia, Volume 15 (2024)/2, 2024, pp. 277-304

https://doi.org/10.4467/23916001HG.24.033.20461

The history of the body is inextricably linked with the history of lingerie. Underclothes, apart from performing mundane functions of protecting the body from the elements and coarser layers of clothing, were also designed to shape the figure, especially the female figure, according to the currently fashionable beauty standards. They were to hide and to accentuate suggestively those aspects of the body that were considered titillating. The purpose of this article is to look at the history of underwear, focusing on its shaping, or even deforming properties, and to analyse the correlation between lingerie, class, and gender roles. Thus, the history of womens undergarments is simultaneously the story of womens liberation. Some types of underwear severely limited the possibility of movement, while others enabled the participation in sports and social life. The decision of what underclothes to wear (or whether to wear them at all) is not a mere matter of aesthetics but a powerful political statement. It is not a coincidence that feminists were labelled, erroneously, braburners, while there is also a more controversial variety of the movement, the socalled stiletto feminism. Attitudes to underwear and its sexiness often correspondto individual and social attitudes to femininity and gender norms.

Read more Next

Martin Šorm

Studia Historica Gedanensia, Volume 15 (2024)/2, 2024, pp. 305-318

https://doi.org/10.4467/23916001HG.24.034.20462

This paper analyses history textbooks currently used in the Czech Republic; it focuseson how they deal with the issue of the historicity of the body and its related functions, and relations in premodern history. It shows that the medieval body is surprisingly present in primary and secondary education, at least through history textbooks. The ways in which it is presented, however, are problematic: it remains at the margins of the canonical narrative and is not used to develop key competencies associated with historical thinking (unlike some topics in political history). In explanatory texts the history of the body is incorporated mostly in apparently unreflective ways. The author argues that a rearrangement of information and changes of perspective (which would make the historicity of the body the focus of the interpretation) would be enough to offer a more complex view of the historicity of the human body in premodern societies. He also expresses hope for more researchoriented (thus not just transmissive) teaching materials.

Read more Next