Traces of Conflict: An Archaeological Perspective on the Hasmonean–Herodian Transition (63–37 BCE)
Choose format
RIS BIB ENDNOTEPublication date: 24.04.2026
ELECTRUM, 2026, Volume 33, pp. 243-270
https://doi.org/10.4467/20800909EL.26.012.23125Authors
Traces of Conflict: An Archaeological Perspective on the Hasmonean–Herodian Transition (63–37 BCE)
The transition from Hasmonean rule to Herod’s regime sparked significant unrest among the Jewish population of Judea. Over the course of these two and a half decades, five distinct conflicts occurred between Aristobulus II and his sons on one side, and Hyrcanus II and the House of Antipater on the other. Although these events are thoroughly recounted by Josephus, relatively few archaeological finds have been linked to the conflicts of this period. This study surveys the available material evidence and evaluates its historical implications. The core dataset includes numismatic finds (hoards, Antigonus and early Herodian coinage), hiding complexes, and refuge caves. Two additional, though less conclusive, categories—siege systems around Hasmonean fortresses and indications of site abandonment—are also examined. The distribution and context of these finds not only lend support to Josephus’s account but also potentially indicating that resistance to the rise of the Antipatrid regime may have been more widespread than is reflected in his pro-Herodian narrative.
TJC – Y. Meshorer, A Treasury of Jewish Coins from the Persian Period to Bar Kokhba, Jerusalem– Nyack 2001.
Ariel, D. T. (1998), Appendix: Hasmonean Coins Found in the Cave of the Warrior, in: T. Schick (ed.), The Cave of the Warrior: A Fourth Millennium Burial in the Judean Desert, Jerusalem: 131–137.
Ariel, D. T. (2002), The Coins from the Surveys and Excavations of Caves in the Northern Judean Desert, ‘Atiqot 41(2): 281–304.
Ariel, D. T. (2017), The Mattathias Antigonus Hoard from Area T, in: H. Geva (ed.), Jewish Quarter Excavations, vol. VII: Areas Q, H, O-2 and Other Studies: Final Report, Jerusalem: 352–368.
Ariel, D. T. (2018), Jerusalem, Monbaz Street: The Coins, Hadashot Arkheologiyot—Excavations and Surveys in Israel 130: 1–8.
Ariel, D. T., Fontanille, J. P. (2012), The Coins of Herod: A Modern Analysis and Die Classification, Leiden.
Aviam, M. (2004), Jews, Pagans, and Christians in the Galilee: 25 Years of Archaeological Excavations and Surveys: Hellenistic to Byzantine Periods, Rochester.
Avigad, N. (1983), Discovering Jerusalem, Jerusalem (Hebr.).
Bar, S., Osband, M., Farhi, Y. (2025), Rujum es-Si’a: A Hasmonean Road Station on the way to Alexandrion Fortress, Jordan Valley Studies 8: 7–19 (Hebr.).
Barkay, R. (2000), The Coins of Horvat ‘Eleq, in: Y. Hirschfeld (ed.), Ramat Hanadiv Excavations: Final Report of the 1984–1998 Seasons, Jerusalem: 377–419.
Barshad, D., Shaked, I. (2002), Region III: Survey and Excavations of Caves in Lower Wadi el-Makkuk, ‘Atiqot 41(2): 35–41.
Bijovsky, G. (2004a), The Coins from Khirbet Badd ‘Isa—Qiryat Sefer, in: N. Haimovich-Carmin (ed.), The Land of Benjamin, Jerusalem: 243–300.
Bijovsky, G. (2004b), A Hoard of Coins of Mattathias Antigonus from ‘Ein Feshkha, IEJ 54: 75–76.
Bijovsky, G. (2012), Coins from Khirbet Fa’ush, Maccabim, in: N. Carmin (ed.), Christians and Christianity, vol. III: Churches and Monasteries in Samaria and Northern Judea, Jerusalem: 345–362.
Bijovsky, G. (2021), Coins from the En-Gedi Synagogue and Its Environs, in: Y. Porath, The Synagogue at En-Gedi (Qedem 64). Jerusalem: 175–203.
Billig, Y., Peleg-Barkat, O., Liberman, T., Gorin-Rosen, Y. (2022), Salvage Excavations at Sharafat: A Hasmonean Estate South of Jerusalem?, in: Y. Gadot, Y. Zelinger, O. Peleg-Barkat, Y. Shalev (eds.), New Studies in the Archaeology of Jerusalem and its Region 15, Jerusalem: 107–151 (Hebr.).
Dąbrowa, E. (2026), Antigonus Mattathias: Between Parthia, Rome, and Herod the Great, Electrum 33: 225–245.
Davidovich, U. (2014), The Judean Desert during the Chalcolithic, Bronze and Iron Ages (Sixth-First Millennia BCE): Desert and Sown Relations in light of Activity Patterns in a Defined Desert Environment, Ph.D. diss., The Hebrew University of Jerusalem (Hebr.).
Davidovich, U. (2015), Judean Desert Caves: Archaeology and History, in: A. Frumkin (ed.), Holy Land Atlas: Judean Desert Caves, Jerusalem: 23–36 (Hebr.).
De Vaux, R. (1961), Archeologie, in: P. Benoit, J. T. Milik, R. de Vaux (eds.), Discoveries in the Judean Desert, vol. II: Les Grottes de Murabba’at, Oxford: 3–63.
De Vaux, R. (1973), Archaeology and Dead Sea Scrolls, London.
Ein Mor, D. (2009), Two Refuge Caves at Arak Ismain in Nahal Shorek, in: H. Eshel and R. Porat (eds.), Refuge Caves of the Bar Kokhba Revolt II, Jerusalem: 460–477 (Hebr.).
Einav, M. (2014), The History and Archaeology of Alexandriun/Sartaba: Foundation, Function and Abandonment, M.A. thesis, Ben-Gurion University, Beer Sheva (Hebr.).
Eshel, H., Amit, D. (eds.) (1998), Refuge Caves of the Bar Kokhba Revolt, Eretz—Geographic Research and Publication: Tel-Aviv (Hebr.).
Eshel, H., Porat, R. (eds.) (2009), Refuge Caves of the Bar Kokhba Revolt, vol. 2, Jerusalem (Hebr.).
Eshel, H., Zissu, H. (2002), Region VIII: Survey and Excavations of Caves along the Cliff Slopes of Triangulation Point 86, on the Fringes of Jebel Ma’ar el-Bas, ‘Atiqot 41(2): 117–123.
Eshel, H., Zissu, B. (2020), The Bar Kokhba Revolt: The Archaeological Evidence, Jerusalem.
Farhi, Y. (2016), Khirbet Qeiyafa, vol. 5: Excavation Report, 2007–2013: The Numismatic Finds; Coins and Related Objects, Jerusalem.
Farhi, Y. (2020), Chapter 4: The Coins, in: A. Melamed (ed.), Underground Hiding Complexes and Installations at Nesher-Ramla Quarry, Haifa.
Farhi, Y. (2022a), The Numismatic Finds from Khirbet el-Maqatir, in: S. Stripling, M.A. Hassler (eds.), The Excavations at Khirbet el-Maqatir: 1995–2001 and 2009–2016, vol. 2: The Late Hellenistic, Early Roman, and Byzantine Periods, Oxford: 95–162.
Farhi, Y. (2022b), A Ring from a Cave in ‘En Gedi and the Conflict between Herod the Great and Mattathias Antigonus (40–37 BCE), Jerusalem Journal of Archaeology 3: 3–13.
Farhi Y., Leibner U. (2014), Coins from the Rock Shelters and Fortified Enclosure of Mt. Nitai, Eastern Lower Galilee, INJ 18: 184–197.
Farhi, Y., Melamed, A. (2014), Two Coin Hoards from Underground Complexes at Nesher-Ramla Quarry, INR 9: 109–132.
Farhi, Y., Raviv, D., Tavger, A., Gross, B. (2023), Numismatic Evidence for Instability in Judea under Alexander Yanai (?): A Hasmonean-Period Coin Hoard from Tel Bet Shemesh (East), INR 18: 55–66.
Fischer, M., Gitler, H., Tal, O. (2020), The Coins of Khirbet el-‘Aqd: A Hellenistic-Roman Stronghold in Western Judea, INR 15: 13–44.
Freyne, S. (1988), Galilee, Jesus and the Gospels, Literary Approaches and Historical Investigations, Philadelphia.
Goldman, J. (2022), Coin Hoarding in Roman Palestine: 63 BC–AD 300, in: J. Mairat, A. Wilson, C. Howgego (eds.), Coin Hoards and Hoarding in the Roman World, Oxford: 208–220.
Goldstein, I., Fontanille, J. P. (2013), The Small Denominations of Mattathias Antigonus: Die Classification and Interpretations, INR 8: 55–71.
Hadas, G., Peleg-Barkat, O. (2023), Avigad’s Excavations of the Nahal David Burial Caves and Settlement of ‘En Gedi Under the Hasmoneans and Herod the Great, in: O. Sion, J. Uziel, A. Ganor, E. Klein (eds.), New Studies in the Archaeology of the Judean Desert, Collected Papers, Jerusalem: 247–266.
Har-Even, B. (2012), Khirbat al-Jafir (West) – A Rural Settlement from the Second Temple Period in Western Ramat al-Jib: A Preliminary Report on the 2010 Excavation Season, Judea and Samaria Research Studies 21: 75 – 87 (Hebr.).
Har-Even, B., Shapira, L. (2012), A Late Roman Tower and a Byzantine Church in Khirbet Fa’ush, Maccabim, in: N. Carmin (ed.), Christians and Christianity III, Jerusalem: 327–334.
Hendin, D. (2021), Guide to Biblical Coins, 6th ed., New York.
Hendin, D., Shachar, I. (2008), The Identity of YNTN on Hasmonean Overstruck Coins and the Chronology of the Alexander Jannaeus Types, INR 3: 87–94.
Hirschfeld, Y., Ariel, D. T. (2005), A Coin Assemblage from the Reign of Alexander Jannaeus Found on the Shore of the Dead Sea, IEJ 55: 66–89.
Hirschfeld, Y., Riklin, S. (2002), Region II: Survey and Excavations in the Upper Wadi el-Makkuk Caves, ‘Atiqot 41(2): 5–19.
Ilan, T., Noam, V. (2017), Josephus and the Rabbis, vol. I, Jerusalem (Hebr.).
Jacobson, D. M. (2015), Herod The Great, Augustus Caesar and Herod’s “Year 3” Coins, Strata 33: 89–118.
Janai, J. (1996), Appendix II: Coins from Er-Ras (Midiya), in: M. L. Fischer, B. H. Isaac, I. Roll (eds.), Roman Roads in Judea, vol. II: The Jaffa – Jerusalem Roads, Oxford: 274–280.
Kindler, A. (1967), The Monetary Pattern and Function of the Jewish Coins. In A. Kindler, International Numismatic Convention, Jerusalem, 27–31 December 1963: The Patterns of Monetary Development in Phoenicia and Palestine in Antiquity, Tel Aviv: 180–203.
Kindler, A. (1987), Coins and remains from a mobile mint of Bar Kokhba at Khirbet el-Aqd, INJ 9 (1986–1987): 46–50.
Kirkman, J. S. (1957), The Evidence of the Coins, in: J. W. Crowfoot, G. M. Crowfoot, K. M. Kenyon (eds.), Samaria-Sebaste, vol. III: The Objects from Samaria, London.
Klein, E., Frumkin, A. (2009), A Refuge Cave in Nahal Shilo, in: H. Eshel and R. Porat (eds.), Refuge Caves of the Bar Kokhba Revolt II, Jerusalem: 510–518 (Hebr.).
Klein, E., Ganor, A., Goldenberg, G., Zissu, B. (2021), Underground Storage System XXXIV at Horvat ‘Ethri and the Chronological Development of the Underground Hiding Complexes in Judea, Judea and Samaria Research Studies 30 (1): 35–64 (Hebr.).
Kloner, A., Tepper, Y. (1987), The Hiding Complexes in the Judean Shephelah, Tel Aviv (Hebr.).
Lapp, P. W. and Lapp, N. L. (1974), Discoveries in the Wadi ed-Daliyeh, Annual of the American Schools of Oriental Research 4, Cambridge.
Larsen, K. W. (2023), Appendix: Alexander Jannaeus Coins of the TJC Group Type, in: S. Stripling, M. A. Hassler (eds.), The Excavations at Khirbet el-Maqatir: 1995–2001 and 2009–2016, vol. 2: The Late Hellenistic, Early Roman, and Byzantine Periods, Oxford: 143–162.
Leibner, U. (2004), History of the Settlement of the Eastern Galilee in the Hellenistic, Roman and Byzantine Periods in Light of Finds from an Archaeological Survey, Ph.D. diss., Bar-Ilan University (Hebr.).
Leibner, U. (2009), Settlement and history in Hellenistic, Roman, and Byzantine Galilee: an archaeological survey of the Eastern Galilee, Tubingen.
Levy, Y. D., Raviv, D. (forthcoming), The Numismatic Finds from the Tel Tibna Survey 2022–2024 Seasons, KOINON 9.
Lykke, A. (2015), Reign and Religion in Palestine: The Use of Sacred Iconography in Jewish Coinage, Wiesbaden.
Magen, Y. (2021), The Samaritans and the History of Mount Gerizim, in: Y. Magen, G. Bijovsky, Y. Zionit (eds.), Mount Gerizim excavations, vol. III: The Coins, Jerusalem: 3–78.
May, M. (2001), Ṣur Bahir, Hadashot Arkheologiyot 113: 92*–94*.
Mazar, B., Dothan, T., Dunayewsky, E. (1963), ‘Ein Gedi: Archaeological Excavations 1961–1962, Yediot 27: 1–133 (Hebr.).
Melamed, A. (2010), Hiding Complexes, in: S. Kol-Ya’akov (ed.), Salvage Excavations at Nesher-Ramla Quarry, vol. 1, Haifa: 89–97.
Melamed, A. (2018), Hiding Complexes, in: S. Kol-Ya’akov (ed.), Salvage Excavations at Nesher-Ramla Quarry, vol. 2, Haifa: 30–78.
Melamed, A. (2020), Underground Hiding Complexes and Installations at Nesher-Ramla Quarry, Haifa.
Melamed, A. (2022), A New Perspective on the Research of the Underground Complexes in Light of the Excavations at Nesher-Ramla Quarry, Jerusalem Journal of Archaeology 3 (2): 164–207.
Meshel, Z. (1983), The Late Hasmonean Siege System at Hyrcania, Eretz-Israel 17: 251–256 (Hebr.).
Meshel, Z. (1989), A Siege System and an Ancient Road at Alexandrium, Eretz- Israel 20: 292–301 (Hebr.).
Meshorer, Y. (1989), The Coins of Masada, in: Masada: The Yigael Yadin Excavations 1963–1965: Final Report, vol. 1, Jerusalem.
Mitchel, L. A. 1992. Hesban 7: Hellenistic and Roman Strata. Berrien Springs.
Netzer, E. (1977), Winter Palaces of the Judean Kings at Jericho at the End of Second Temple Period, BASOR 228: 1–13.
Netzer, E. (2018), The Palaces of the Hasmoneans and Herod the Great, Jerusalem.
Patrich, J. (1986), Excavations in the el Massaiah Cave in the Upper Nachal Deragot, Niqrot Zurim 13: 76–87 (Hebr.).
Porat, R., Eshel, H., Frumkin, A. (2009), The Christmas Cave in the Lower Nahal Kidron, in: Refuge Caves of the Bar Kokhba Revolt, vol. 2, Jerusalem: 31–52 (Hebr.).
Rappaport, U. (2013), The House of the Hasmoneans—the People of Israel in the Land of Israel in the Hasmonean Period, Jerusalem (Hebr.).
Rassalle, T. (2021), Coin Deposits from Ancient Synagogues in Late Antique Palestine, Ph.D. diss., The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.
Raviv, D. (2018), The Settlement in South Samaria during the Hellenistic and Roman Periods According to Archaeological Surveys, vol. II: The Catalogue, Ph.D. diss., Bar-Ilan University, Ramat Gan (Hebr.).
Raviv, D. (2023a), The Typology, Chronology and Development of the Hiding Complexes of Judea in Light of the New Discoveries at the Nesher-Ramla Quarry site: A Reevaluation, BASOR 390: 189–207.
Raviv, D. (2023b), Hiding Complexes in Fortified Sites of the Bar Kokhba War, JJS 74: 273–302.
Raviv, D. (2024), The Hiding Complexes of Judea: An Update Regarding Their Geographical Distribution, Typology and Function, Eretz-Israel 35: 511–519 (Hebr.).
Raviv, D. (2025), A Numismatic Survey at Ḥorbat Bet Zekharya and Possible Evidence for the Fifth Battle of Judah Maccabi, INR 20: 85–118.
Raviv, D., Farhi, Y., Tsuf, O., Hodson, A., Ushki-Tanami, R., Gross, B. (forthcoming), “The Smallest of Them?” A Jewish Town from the Hellenistic and Early Roman Periods at Tel Beth Shemesh, Tel Aviv.
Raviv, D., Har Even, B., Tavger, A., Aharonvich, E., Langford, B., Frumkin, A., (2021), An Archaeological Survey of the Nemerim (Leopards) Cave A Refuge Cave from the Second Temple Period and the Bar Kokhba Revolt in Southeast Samaria, in: Hawkins, R.K., Gaß, E., and Ben-Yosef, D., eds., נחלתו : A Memorial Volume for Adam Zertal, Ugarit-Verlag – Münster: 145–174.
Raviv, D., Levy, Y. D. (2025), The Geographical Distribution of Mattatya (Mattathias) Antigonos’ Coins: New Insights from Recent Discoveries, INR 20: 145–180.
Raviv, D., Sasson, S. T., Langford, B., Frumkin, A., Zissu, B. (2024), An Archaeological Survey at Naḥal Bet ‘Arif Cave, Israel, ZDPV 140: 213–237.
Raviv, D., Stripling, S., Farhi, Y. (2023), New Findings from the Acrabat Toparchy and the Northern Border of Judea before and after the Great Revolt, Jerusalem Journal of Archaeology 4: 108–136.
Raviv, D., Lewis, R., Tavger, A., Shkolnik, H., Har-Even, B., Aharonovich, E., Ullman, M., Langford, B., Frumkin, A. (2022), An Archaeological Survey at el-Jenab Cave (Eastern Samaria), Jerusalem Journal of Archaeology 3: 233–282.
Regev, E. (2000), Why Did Aristobulus and His Son Alexander Fortify Alexandrion-Sartaba?, in: J. Schwartz, Z. Amar, I. Ziffer (eds.), Jerusalem and Eretz Israel: Arie Kindler Volume, Jerusalem: 119–132 (Hebr.).
Richardson, P. (1996), Herod: King of the Jews and Friend of the Romans, Columbia.
Sabar, R. (2023), The Galilee during the Hellenistic Period (4th–1st c. B.C.E.): Geopolitical Changes in Light of the Fortified Sites and the Settlement History, Ph.D. diss., The Hebrew University, Jerusalem (Hebr.).
Sharon, N. (2017), Judea under Roman Domination: The First Generation of Statelessness and Its Legacy, Atlanta, GA.
Shatzman, I. (1992), The Hasmoneans in Greco-Roman Historiography, Zion 57: 5–64 (Hebr.).
Shivtiel, Y. (2018), The Hiding Complex at Horbat Rosh Maya, Haifa: A Landmark in the Appearance of Hiding Complexes during the Hasmonean Period, Tel-Hai Galilee Studies III: 98–118 (Hebr.).
Shivtiel, Y., Ahipaz, N. (2014), Coins from Cliff Shelters and Hiding Complexes in Galilee and Their Historical and Archaeological Significance. INR 9: 133–147.
Shukron, E., Savriago, A. (1993), Pisgat Ze’ev, Hadashot Arkheologiyot 99: 51–53 (Hebr.).
Sion, O. (2002), Regions IV and VI: Survey and Excavations of Caves along the Jebel Abu Saraj Cliff, ‘Atiqot 41(2): 43–70.
Sion, O., Ariel, D. T. (2001), The Struggles between Herod and Antigonus in the Qarantal Cliffs, Judea and Samaria Research Studies 10: 113–118 (Hebr.).
Sion, O., Uziel, J., Ganor, A., Klein, E. (eds.) (2023), New Studies in the Archaeology of the Judean Desert, Collected Papers: Jerusalem.
Spiezer, Y., Zissu, B., Zelinger, Y. (2022), The Rural Environs of Jerusalem and its Surroundings in the Hasmonean Period, in: Y. Gadot, Y. Zelinger, O. Peleg-Barkat, and Y. Shalev. New Studies in the Archaeology of Jerusalem and its Region, Collected Papers 15. Jerusalem: 321–345 (Hebr.).
Stern, E. (2007), En-Gedi Excavations, vol. I: Final Report (1961–1965), Jerusalem.
Stern, M. (1995), Hasmonaean Judea in the Hellenistic World: Chapters in Political History, Jerusalem (Hebr.).
Stiebel, G. D. (2007), Armis et Litteris—The Military Equipment of Early Roman Palestine in Light of the Archaeological and Historical Sources, vol. 2: The Catalogue, Ph.D. diss., University of London.
Syon, D. (2015), Small Change in Hellenistic-Roman Galilee, Jerusalem.
Tendler, A. S. (2024), The Agricultural Settlement Systems of the Modiʿin Region from the Hellenistic Period until the Modern Era, Ph.D. diss., Bar-Ilan University, Ramat Gan.
Terian, A. (1974), Coins from the 1971 Excavations at Heshbon, Andrews University Seminary Studies 12: 35–46.
Terian, A. (1976), Coins from the 1973 and 1974 Excavations at Heshbon, Seminary Studies 14(1): 133–141.
van Henten, J. W. (2020), Good and Bad Rulers in Josephus, in: J. A. Snyder, K. Zamfir (eds.), Reading the Political in Jewish and Christian Texts, Leuven–Paris–Bristol, CT: 83–105.
van Henten, J. W. (2011), Rebellion under Herod the Great and Archelaus: Prominent Motifs and Narrative Function, in: M. Popović (ed.), The Jewish Revolt against Rome: Interdisciplinary Perspectives, Leiden–Boston: 241–270.
Vitto, F. (1998), Mahoza D-Yamnim: A Mosaic Floor from the Time of Eudocia?, ‘Atiqot 35: 109–134.
Vörös, G. (2013), Machaerus I: History, Archaeology and Architecture of the Fortified Herodian Royal Palace and City Overlooking the Dead Sea in Transjordan: Final Report of the Excavations and Surveys 1807–2012, Milano.
Waner, M., Safrai, Z. (2001), Hoards and Revolts: The Chronological Distribution of Coin Hoards in Eretz Israel during the Roman and Byzantine Periods, Cathedra 101: 71–90 (Hebr.).
Wright, G. R. H., Milik, J. T. (1961), The Archaeological Remains at El-Mird in the Wilderness of Judea, Biblica 42: 1–27.
Zelinger, Y. (2004), Priestly Settlements in the Benjamin Region during the Second Temple Period, Judea and Samaria Research Studies 13: 57–70 (Hebr.).
Zelinger, Y. (2009), The Rural Settlements in the Shephela of Lod (Lydda) during the Second Temple Period, PhD diss., Bar-Ilan University (Hebr.).
Zissu, B., Ganor, A. (2009), Horvat ‘Ethri—a Jewish village from the Second Temple period and the Bar Kokhba Revolt in the Judean foothills, JJS 60: 90–136.
Zissu, B., Hendin, D. (2012), Further Remarks on Coins in Circulation the Bar Kokhba War: Te’omim Cave and Horvat ‘Ethri Coin Hoards, in: D. M. Jacobson, N. Kokkinos (eds.), Judea and Rome in Coins 65 BCE–135 CE, London: 215–228.
Zissu, B., Langford, B., Raviv, D., Davidovich U., Porat, R., Frumkin, A. (2014), Coins from the Elqana Cave in Western Samaria, INJ 18: 146–154.
Information: ELECTRUM, 2026, Volume 33, pp. 243-270
Article type: Original scientific article
Bar-Ilan University
Israel
Published at: 24.04.2026
Article status: Open
Licence: CC BY 4.0
Percentage share of authors:
Article corrections:
-Publication languages:
EnglishView count: 105
Number of downloads: 72