The Seleucid Akra and the Hasmonean “First Wall”: Could They Have Coexisted?
Choose format
RIS BIB ENDNOTEPublication date: 24.04.2026
ELECTRUM, 2026, Volume 33, pp. 139-153
https://doi.org/10.4467/20800909EL.26.007.23120Authors
The Seleucid Akra and the Hasmonean “First Wall”: Could They Have Coexisted?
This paper re-examines the timing of the construction of the “First Wall” around Jerusalem’s Western Hill and the process of the city’s westward expansion. The author argues that internal struggles within the Seleucid court during the mid-second century BCE created instability, weakening Seleucid control in Judea. This allowed Jonathan and Simon to strategically navigate the political landscape. This context suggests that Jonathan and Simon often acted with a Seleucid mandate. Given this political climate, the article proposes that the initiative to rebuild the Western Hill’s ancient wall may have begun earlier, potentially during Simon’s reign or even Jonathan’s leadership, while a Seleucid garrison was still stationed in the Akra. The restoration, starting with the rehabilitation of the ancient wall, may have been a mutually beneficial act. Later, several towers built of marginally dressed ashlar stones were added at strategic points, likely for tactical reasons. In summary, this paper suggests that the westward expansion and the construction of the First Wall were more gradual than previously assumed, and that the initial restoration may have begun before 141 BCE due to Seleucid instability and the Hasmonean brothers’ skillful diplomacy and growing authority—possibly undertaken with some level of coordination with the Seleucid rulers.
Arav, R. (1989), Hellenistic Palestine: Settlement Patterns and City Planning, 337–31 B.C.E., Oxford.
Ariel, D. T. (1990), Imported Stamped Amphora Handles, in: D. T. Ariel (ed.), Excavations at the City of David 1978–1985 Directed by Yigal Shiloh, vol. II: Imported Stamped Amphora Handles, Coins, Worked Bone and Ivory, and Glass, Jerusalem: 13–98.
Ariel, D. T. (2000), Imported Greek Stamped Amphora Handles, in: H. Geva (ed.), Jewish Quarter Excavations in the Old City of Jerusalem Conducted by Nahman Avigad, 1969–1982, vol. I: Architecture and Stratigraphy: Areas A, W and X–2. Final Report, Jerusalem: 267–283.
Ariel, D. T. (2019), New Evidence for the Dates of the Walls of Jerusalem in the Second Half of the Second Century BC, Electrum 26: 25–52.
Ariel, D. T. (2021), Archaeological Evidence for the Siege of Jerusalem by Antiochus VII Sidetes, in: C. Feyel, L. Graslin-Thomé (eds.), Les derniers Séleucides et leur territoire. Actes du colloque international organisé à Nancy les 20–22 novembre 2019, Nancy–Paris: 232–279.
Ariel, D. T., Shoham, Y. (2000), Locally Stamped Handles and Associated Body Fragments of the Persian and Hellenistic Periods, in: D. T. Ariel (ed.), Excavations at the City of David 1978–1985 Directed by Yigal Shiloh, vol. VI: Inscriptions, Jerusalem: 137–171.
Avigad, N. (1980), The Upper City of Jerusalem, Jerusalem (Hebr.).
Balandier, C. (2014), La défense de la Syrie-Palestine des Achéménides aux Lagides: Histoire et archéologie des fortifications à l’ouest du Jourdain (532–199 av. J.-C.) avec appendices sur Jérusalem, les ouvrages fortifiés de Transjordanie et du Nord du Sinaï, Paris.
Ben-Ami, D., Tchekhanovets, Y. (2016), “Then They Built Up the City of David with a High, Strong Wall and Strong Towers, and It Became Their Citadel” (I Maccabees 1:33), in: E. Meiron (ed.), City of David Studies of Ancient Jerusalem, vol. 11, Jerusalem: 19–29.
Ben-Ami, D., Tchekhanovets, Y., Dan-Goor, S. (2021), Jerusalem, Giv‘ati Parking Lot. Hadashot Arkheologiyot—Excavations and Surveys in Israel 133, https://www.hadashot-esi.org.il/report_detail_eng.aspx?id=25886&mag_id=133 (accessed on April 17, 2025).
Berlin, A. M., Kosmin, P. J. (eds.) (2021), The Middle Maccabees: Archaeology, History, and the Rise of the Hasmonean Kingdom, Atlanta, GA.
Bliss, F. J., Dickie, A. C. (1898), Excavations at Jerusalem 1894–1897, London.
Bocher, E., Lipschits, O. (2013), The Corpus of yršlm Stamp Impressions—The Final Link, Tel Aviv 40: 99–116.
Crowfoot, J. W. (1928), Excavations in the Tyropoeon Valley, PEQ 60: 9–27.
Crowfoot, J. W. (1929a), Excavations on Ophel, 1928, Preliminary Report to December 8, PEQ 61: 9–16.
Crowfoot, J. W. (1929b), Ophel, 1928, PEQ 61: 75–77.
Crowfoot, J. W. (1929c), Excavations on Ophel, 1928, PEQ 61: 150–166.
Crowfoot, J. W. (1945), Ophel Again, PEQ 77: 66–104.
Crowfoot, J. W., Fitzgerald, G. M. (1929), Excavations in the Tyropoeon Valley, Jerusalem, 1927, London.
Dąbrowa, E. (2010), The Hasmoneans and Their State: A Study in History, Ideology, and the Institutions, Kraków.
Dąbrowa, E. (2024), Attributes of Power of the Hasmoneans (152–76 BCE) as an Expression of Their Political Standing, in: E. Dąbrowa, S. Fink (eds.), Autocratic Rule in Antiquity: Proceedings of the 14th Melammu Workshop, Kraków, 4–6 October 2021, Münster: 173–186.
De Groot, A. (2012), Discussion and Conclusions, in: A. De Groot, H. Bernick-Greenberg, Excavations at the City of David, 1978–1985 Directed by Yigal Shiloh, vol. VIIA: Area E; Stratigraphy and Architecture, Jerusalem: 141–184.
Eckhardt, B. (2021), Reading the Middle Maccabees, in: Berlin – Kosmin 2021: 349–362.
Finkielsztejn, G. (1999), Hellenistic Jerusalem: The Evidence of the Rhodian Amphora Stamps, in: A. Faust, E. Baruch (eds.), New Studies on Jerusalem: Collected Papers, vol. V, Ramat-Gan: 21–36.
Finkielsztejn, G. (2001), Chronologie détaillée et révisée des éponymes amphoriques rhodiens, de 270 à 108 av. J.-C. environ: premier bilan, Oxford.
Finkielsztejn, G. (2014), Amphoras from Area J., in: H. Geva (ed.), Jewish Quarter Excavations in the Old City of Jerusalem Conducted by Nahman Avigad, 1969–1982 VI: Areas J, N, Z and Other Studies. Final Report. Jerusalem: 212–228.
Geva, H. (1985), The “First Wall” of Jerusalem during the Second Temple Period—An Architectural-Chronological Note, Eretz-Israel: Archaeological, Historical and Geographical Studies 18: 21–39 (Hebr.).
Geva, H. (1994), Excavations at the Citadel of Jerusalem, 1976–1980, in: H. Geva (ed.), Ancient Jerusalem Revealed, Jerusalem: 156–167.
Geva, H. (2003), Hellenistic Pottery from Areas W and X-2, in: H. Geva (ed.), Jewish Quarter Excavations in the Old City of Jerusalem, Conducted by Nahman Avigad, 1969–1982, vol. II: The Finds from Areas A, W and X-2. Final Report, Jerusalem.
Geva, H. (2007), A Chronological Reevaluation of Yehud Stamp Impressions in Paleo-Hebrew Script, Based on Finds from Excavations in the Jewish Quarter of the Old City of Jerusalem, Tel Aviv 34: 92–103.
Geva, H. (2018), Hasmonean Jerusalem in the Light of Archaeology—Notes on Urban Topography, Journal of Hellenistic Pottery and Material Culture 3: 30–60.
Geva, H., Avigad, N. (2000), Area W-Stratigraphy and Architecture, in: H. Geva (ed.), Jewish Quarter Excavations in the Old City of Jerusalem Conducted by Nahman Avigad, 1969–1982, vol. I: Architecture and Stratigraphy: Areas A, W and X-2. Final Report, Jerusalem: 131–198.
Honigman, S. (2021), Before the Spark Ignites the Fire: Structural Instabilities in Southern Syria, in: Berlin – Kosmin 2021: 257–267.
Kosmin, P. J. (2021), Overview: The Middle Maccabees in Context, in: Berlin – Kosmin 2021: 243–256.
Lipschits, O., Vanderhooft, D. (2011), The Yehud Stamp Impressions: A Corpus of Inscribed Impressions from the Persian and Hellenistic Periods in Judah, Winona Lake.
Magness, J. (2024), Jerusalem Through the Ages: From Its Beginnings to the Crusades, Oxford.
Mazar, B., Eshel, H. (1998), Who Built the First Wall of Jerusalem?, IEJ 48: 265–268.
Mazis, M., Wright, N. L. (2018), Archers, Antiochos VII Sidetes, and the BE Arrowheads, BASOR 380: 205–229.
McNicoll, A. (1997), Hellenistic Fortifications from the Aegean to the Euphrates, ed. by N. P. Milner, Oxford.
Milner, N. P. (1997), Conclusions and Recent Developments, in: A. McNicoll, Hellenistic Fortifications from the Aegean to the Euphrates, ed. by N. P. Milner, Oxford: 207–223.
Rappaport, U. (2013), The House of the Hasmoneans: The People of Israel in the Land of Israel in the Hasmonean Period, Jerusalem (Hebr.).
Shalev, Y., Bocher, E., Roth, H., Sandhaus, D., Shalom, N., Gadot, Y. (2021), Jerusalem During the Early Hellenistic Period: New Evidence for Its Nature and Location, in: Berlin – Kosmin 2021: 17–36.
Shalev, Y., Shalom, N., Bocher, E., Gadot, Y. (2020), New Evidence on the Location and Nature of Iron Age, Persian and Early Hellenistic Period Jerusalem, Tel Aviv 47: 149–172.
Shatzman, I. (1991), The Armies of the Hasmonaeans and Herod: From Hellenistic to Roman Frameworks, Tübingen.
Sievers, J. (1994), Jerusalem, the Akra, and Josephus, in: F. Parente, J. Sievers (eds.), Josephus and the History of the Greco-Roman Period: Essays in Memory of Morton Smith, Leiden: 195–209.
Sivan, R., Solar, G. (1994), Excavations in the Jerusalem Citadel, 1980–1988, in: H. Geva (ed.), Ancient Jerusalem Revealed, Jerusalem: 168–176.
Tal, O. (2006), The Archaeology of Hellenistic Palestine: Between Tradition and Renewal, Jerusalem (Hebr.).
Zilberstein, A. (2019), “On Your Walls, City of David:” The Line of the Western Fortification of the City of David Hill During the Hellenistic Period in Light of New Finds, New Studies in the Archaeology of Jerusalem and its Region 13: 31–50 (Hebr.).
Zilberstein, A. (2021), Hellenistic Military Architecture from the Giv’ati Parking Lot Excavations, Jerusalem, in: Berlin – Kosmin 2021: 37–52.
Zilberstein, A. (2022), Jerusalem During the Seleucid Period in Light of the Archaeological Finds in “The City of David,” PhD diss., Tel Aviv University (Hebr.).
Zilberstein, A. (forthcoming), “A City and Memories:” The Story of Antiochus VII’s Siege of Jerusalem as Seen Through Its City Walls.
Information: ELECTRUM, 2026, Volume 33, pp. 139-153
Article type: Original scientific article
Published at: 24.04.2026
Article status: Open
Licence: CC BY 4.0
Article financing:
Percentage share of authors:
Article corrections:
-Publication languages:
EnglishView count: 71
Number of downloads: 74