The Role of Open-Source Intelligence in Protecting Cultural Heritage During Armed Conflict: The Case of Ukraine
Wybierz format
RIS BIB ENDNOTEData publikacji: 11.12.2025
Santander Art and Culture Law Review, 2025, 2/2025 (11), s. 223-244
https://doi.org/10.4467/2450050XSNR.25.024.22689Autorzy
The Role of Open-Source Intelligence in Protecting Cultural Heritage During Armed Conflict: The Case of Ukraine
Russia’s ongoing war of aggression against Ukraine, along with the resulting destruction and threats to cultural heritage, poses a major challenge to documenting the scale of the damage and identifying the perpetrators. Recent practice has demonstrated the significant value of information obtained through open-source intelligence (OSINT). The growing recognition of the importance of such information, and the need to safeguard it, highlights the interdependence between information security and the protection of cultural heritage. As information security often depends on visual documentation, this article uses data collected through OSINT to analyse cultural heritage losses in Ukraine between 24 February 2022 (the start of Russia’s full-scale invasion) and 3 July 2025. The objective is to determine whether, and to what extent, information gathered via OSINT can serve as admissible evidence in criminal proceedings before international courts and tribunals when adjudicating crimes against cultural heritage committed during the war against Ukraine. Based on the material, the article posits that the collection and processing of information using OSINT should form the foundation of an institutionalized cultural heritage management system. The discussion is supported by maps and illustrations that visualize the research problem and demonstrate the potential of OSINT in documenting and safeguarding cultural heritage during armed conflicts.
Andriichuk T., Theatres and Museums Volunteering during the War, “Ukraїner”, 6 November 2022, https://www.ukrainer.net/en/theatres-and-museums-volunteering/ [accessed: 28.10.2025].
Baffa R., The Ukraine–Russia War Confirms the Value of OSINT, “Babel Street”, https://www.babelstreet.com/blog/the-ukraine-russia-war-confirms-the-value-of-osint [accessed: 01.07.2025].
Casanovas P., Cyber Warfare and Organised Crime: A Regulatory Model and Meta-Model for Open Source Intelligence (OSINT), in: M. Taddeo, L. Glorioso (eds.), Ethics and Policies for Cyber Operations, Springer, Cham 2017.
Chodak P., Biały wywiad jako źródło informacji [“Open Source Intelligence” as a Source of Information], “International Journal of Legal Studies” 2020, Vol. 2(8).
Convention for the Protection of Cultural Property in the Event of Armed Conflict, 14 May 1954, 249 UNTS 215.
Council of Europe, Draft Convention Establishing an International Claims Commission for Ukraine, 22 October 2025, CM(2025)139-final.
Faiola A., Bennett D., In the Ukraine War, a Battle for the Nation’s Mineral and Energy Wealth, “The Washington Post”, 10 August 2022, https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2022/08/10/ukraine-russia-energy-mineral-wealth/ [accessed: 01.07.2025].
Gwardzińska-Chowaniec Ż., Incoherence of the Provisions of the 1954 Hague Convention and the Importance of Information on Heritage Resources on the Example of the Armed Conflict in Ukraine, “Journal of Heritage Conservation” 2024, Vol. 80.
Hułkewycz W., Karnoprawna ochrona dziedzictwa kulturowego w Ukrainie w sytuacji konfliktu zbrojnego [Protection of Cultural Heritage during Armed Conflict by Criminal Law in Ukraine], “Wrocławsko-Lwowskie Zeszyty Prawnicze” 2022, Vol. 13.
Iaromenko S., Fogel P., Loss and Rebuilding of Historical Sites in Ukraine after the War with Russia in the Context of Balkan Experiences, “Turystyka Kulturowa” 2024, Vol. 4.
Jakubowski A., Safeguarding Ukraine’s Cultural Heritage in War: Identifying the Obligations of Non-Parties to the Conflict, with Special Focus on the European Union, “Polish Review of International and European Law” 2023, Vol. 12(2).
Lee W.H., Yun M.W., Park J.S., Intelligence in the Internet Era: Understanding OSINT and Case Analysis, “Korean Security Journal” 2013, Vol. 34.
Liedel K., Serafin T., Otwarte źródła informacji w działalności wywiadowczej [Open Sources of Information in Intelligence Operations], Difin, Warsaw 2011.
Mamchenko N., Verkhovnaya Rada ratyfytsyrovala Rymskyy statut Mezhdunarodnoho uholovnoho suda [The Verkhovna Rada Ratified the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court], “Sudebno-yurydycheskaya hazeta”, 21 August 2024, https://sud.ua/ru/news/publication/308622-verkhovnaya-rada-ratifitsirovala-rimskiy-statut-mezhdunarodnogo-ugolovnogo-suda [accessed: 01.07.2025].
Manachynskyi O., Wykorzystanie OSINT do weryfikacji przypadków złamania międzynarodowego prawa humanitarnego podczas wojny w Ukrainie [Using OSINT to Verify Violations of International Humanitarian Law during the War in Ukraine], “Analiza KBN” 2023, Vol. 9(124), https://zbn.inp.uj.edu.pl/documents/92718966/141790394/Manachynskyi+O.+-+A124/661a5ce9-ee15-4d98-9132-c79fdc34dddd [accessed: 01.07.2025].
McDermott Y., Koenig A., Murray D., Open Source Information’s Blind Spot: Human and Machine Bias in International Criminal Investigations, “Journal of International Criminal Justice” 2021, Vol. 19(1).
Mincewicz W., Internetowy OSINT jako źródło wiedzy o wojnie w Ukrainie [Online OSINT as a Source of Knowledge about the War in Ukraine], “Zeszyty Naukowe Pro Publico Bono” 2023, Vol. 1(1).
Ministerstvo kul’tury ta stratehichnykh komunikatsiy Ukrayiny, 1096 ob”yektiv kul’turnoyi spadshchyny postrazhdaly v Ukrayini cherez rosiys’ku ahresiyu [1,096 Cultural Heritage Sites Have Been Damaged in Ukraine as a Result of Russian Aggression], 2 August 2024, https://mcsc.gov.ua/news/1096-obyektiv-kulturnoyi-spadshhyny-postrazhdaly-v-ukrayini-cherez-rosijsku-agresiyu/ [accessed: 01.07.2025].
Ministerstvo kul’tury ta stratehichnykh komunikatsiy Ukrayiny, 1222 pam”yatky kul’turnoyi spadshchyny postrazhdaly v Ukrayini cherez rosiys’ku ahresiyu [1,222 Cultural Heritage Sites Have Been Damaged in Ukraine as a Result of Russian Aggression], 5 December 2024, https://mcsc.gov.ua/news/1222-pamyatky-kulturnoyi-spadshhyny-postrazhdaly-v-ukrayini-cherez-rosijsku-agresiyu/ [accessed: 01.07.2025].
Ministerstvo kul’tury ta stratehichnykh komunikatsiy Ukrayiny, 1255 pam”yatok kul’turnoyi spadshchyny postrazhdaly v Ukrayini cherez rosiys’ku ahresiyu stanom na kinets’ hrudnya 2024 roku [As of the End of December 2024, 1,255 Cultural Heritage Sites Have Been Damaged in Ukraine as a Result of Russian Aggression], 3 January 2025, https://mcsc.gov.ua/news/1255-pamyatok-kulturnoyi-spadshhyny-postrazhdaly-v-ukrayini-cherez-rosijsku-agresiyu-stanom-na-kinecz-grudnya-2024-roku/ [accessed: 01.07.2025].
Ministerstvo kul’tury ta stratehichnykh komunikatsiy Ukrayiny, 1419 pam”yatok kul’turnoyi spadshchyny ta 2233 ob”yekty kul’turnoyi infrastruktury postrazhdaly v Ukrayini cherez rosiys’ku ahresiyu [1,419 Cultural Heritage Sites and 2,233 Cultural Infrastructure Facilities Have Been Damaged in Ukraine as a Result of Russian Aggression], 2 April 2025, https://mcsc.gov.ua/news/1419-pamyatok-kulturnoyi-spadshhyny-ta-2233-obyekty-kulturnoyi-infrastruktury-postrazhdaly-v-ukrayini-cherez-rosijsku-agresiyu/ [accessed: 01.07.2025].
Ministerstvo kul’tury ta stratehichnykh komunikatsiy Ukrayiny, 1482 pam”yatky kul’turnoyi spadshchyny ta 2302 ob”yekty kul’turnoyi infrastruktury postrazhdaly v Ukrayini cherez rosiys’ku ahresiyu [1,482 Cultural Heritage Sites and 2,302 Cultural Infrastructure Facilities Have Been Damaged in Ukraine as a Result of Russian Aggression], 3 June 2025, https://mcsc.gov.ua/news/1482-pamyatky-kulturnoyi-spadshhyny-ta-2302-obyekty-kulturnoyi-infrastructure-postrazhdaly-v-ukrayini-cherez-rosijsk-agresiyu/ [accessed: 03.06.2025].
Ministerstvo kul’tury ta stratehichnykh komunikatsiy Ukrayiny, Cherez rosiys’ku ahresiyu v Ukrayini postrazhdaly 902 pam”yatky kul’turnoyi spadshchyny [902 Cultural Heritage Sites Have Been Damaged as a Result of Russian Aggression in Ukraine], 8 February 2024, https://mcsc.gov.ua/news/cherez-rosijsku-agresiyu-v-ukrayini-postrazhdaly-902-pamyatky-kulturnoyi-spadshhyny/ [accessed: 01.07.2025].
Ministerstvo kul’tury ta stratehichnykh komunikatsiy Ukrayiny, Derzhavnyy reyestr nerukhomykh pam”yatok Ukrayiny [State Register of Immovable Monuments of Ukraine], https://mcsc.gov.ua/kulturna-spadshchyna/derzhavnyy-reiestr-nerukhomykh-pam-iatok-ukrainy/ [accessed: 01.07.2025].
Munawar N.A., Symonds J., Empires of Lies? The Political Uses of Cultural Heritage in War, “The Historic Environment: Policy & Practice” 2023, Vol. 14(3).
Narodowy Instytut Dziedzictwa, Centrum Pomocy dla Kultury na Ukrainie – podsumowanie działań w 2022 roku [Centre for Assistance to Culture in Ukraine – Summary of Activities in 2022], 29 December 2022, https://nid.pl/2022/12/29/centrum-pomocy-dla-kultury-na-ukrainie-podsumowanie-dzialan-w-2022-roku/ [accessed: 01.07.2025].
NATO Open Source Intelligence Reader, February 2002, https://cyberwar.nl/d/NATO%20OSINT%20Reader%20FINAL%20Oct2002.pdf [accessed: 01.07.2025].
NATO Open Sources Intelligence Handbook, November 2001, https://archive.org/details/NATOOSINTHandbookV1.2 [accessed: 01.07.2025].
Putin V., On the Historical Unity of Russians and Ukrainians, 12 July 2021, http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/66181 [accessed: 01.07.2025].
Rochowicz R., Drones in War of Ukraine with Russia, “Problemy Techniki Uzbrojenia” 2022, Vol. 160(2).
Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court, 17 July 1998, 2187 UNTS 3.
Stone H. et al., Open-Source Intelligence for Detection of Radiological Events and Syndromes Following the Invasion of Ukraine in 2022: Observational Study, “JMIR Infodemiology” 2023, Vol. 3(1), https://doi.org/10.2196/39895.
Timonina M. (ed.), Number of Present Population of Ukraine, as of January 1, 2021, State Statistics Service of Ukraine, Kyiv 2021, https://web.archive.org/web/20210526125741/http://database.ukrcensus.gov.ua/PXWEB2007/ukr/publ_new1/2021/zb_chuselnist%202021.pdf [accessed: 21.01.2025].
UNESCO, Damaged Cultural Sites in Ukraine Verified by UNESCO, https://www.unesco.org/en/articles/damaged-cultural-sites-ukraine-verified-unesco [accessed: 01.07.2025].
Zharikov N.L. et al., Pamyatniki gradostroitel’stva i arkhitektury Ukrainskoy SSR [Monuments of Urban Planning and Architecture of the Ukrainian SSR], Vols. 1-4, Kiev 1983-1986, https://ua.vlasenko.net/_pgs/index.html [accessed: 01.07.2025].
Informacje: Santander Art and Culture Law Review, 2025, 2/2025 (11), s. 223-244
Typ artykułu: Oryginalny artykuł naukowy
Uniwersytet VIZJA
Polska
Publikacja: 11.12.2025
Status artykułu: Otwarte
Licencja: CC BY
Udział procentowy autorów:
Informacje o autorze:
Korekty artykułu:
-Języki publikacji:
AngielskiLiczba wyświetleń: 329
Liczba pobrań: 186